Paper ID: 2202.10816

Why Fair Labels Can Yield Unfair Predictions: Graphical Conditions for Introduced Unfairness

Carolyn Ashurst, Ryan Carey, Silvia Chiappa, Tom Everitt

In addition to reproducing discriminatory relationships in the training data, machine learning systems can also introduce or amplify discriminatory effects. We refer to this as introduced unfairness, and investigate the conditions under which it may arise. To this end, we propose introduced total variation as a measure of introduced unfairness, and establish graphical conditions under which it may be incentivised to occur. These criteria imply that adding the sensitive attribute as a feature removes the incentive for introduced variation under well-behaved loss functions. Additionally, taking a causal perspective, introduced path-specific effects shed light on the issue of when specific paths should be considered fair.

Submitted: Feb 22, 2022