Paper ID: 2309.08621

Exploring Social Choice Mechanisms for Recommendation Fairness in SCRUF

Amanda Aird, Cassidy All, Paresha Farastu, Elena Stefancova, Joshua Sun, Nicholas Mattei, Robin Burke

Fairness problems in recommender systems often have a complexity in practice that is not adequately captured in simplified research formulations. A social choice formulation of the fairness problem, operating within a multi-agent architecture of fairness concerns, offers a flexible and multi-aspect alternative to fairness-aware recommendation approaches. Leveraging social choice allows for increased generality and the possibility of tapping into well-studied social choice algorithms for resolving the tension between multiple, competing fairness concerns. This paper explores a range of options for choice mechanisms in multi-aspect fairness applications using both real and synthetic data and shows that different classes of choice and allocation mechanisms yield different but consistent fairness / accuracy tradeoffs. We also show that a multi-agent formulation offers flexibility in adapting to user population dynamics.

Submitted: Sep 10, 2023