Paper ID: 2402.05806

On Calibration and Conformal Prediction of Deep Classifiers

Lahav Dabah, Tom Tirer

In many classification applications, the prediction of a deep neural network (DNN) based classifier needs to be accompanied with some confidence indication. Two popular post-processing approaches for that aim are: 1) calibration: modifying the classifier's softmax values such that their maximum (associated with the prediction) better estimates the correctness probability; and 2) conformal prediction (CP): devising a score (based on the softmax values) from which a set of predictions with theoretically guaranteed marginal coverage of the correct class is produced. While in practice both types of indications can be desired, so far the interplay between them has not been investigated. Toward filling this gap, in this paper we study the effect of temperature scaling, arguably the most common calibration technique, on prominent CP methods. We start with an extensive empirical study that among other insights shows that, surprisingly, calibration has a detrimental effect on popular adaptive CP methods: it frequently leads to larger prediction sets. Then, we turn to theoretically analyze this behavior. We reveal several mathematical properties of the procedure, according to which we provide a reasoning for the phenomenon. Our study suggests that it may be worthwhile to utilize adaptive CP methods, chosen for their enhanced conditional coverage, based on softmax values prior to (or after canceling) temperature scaling calibration.

Submitted: Feb 8, 2024