Paper ID: 2406.10059

Double-Anonymous Review for Robotics

Justin K. Yim, Paul Nadan, James Zhu, Alexandra Stutt, J. Joe Payne, Catherine Pavlov, Aaron M. Johnson

Prior research has investigated the benefits and costs of double-anonymous review (DAR, also known as double-blind review) in comparison to single-anonymous review (SAR) and open review (OR). Several review papers have attempted to compile experimental results in peer review research both broadly and in engineering and computer science. This document summarizes prior research in peer review that may inform decisions about the format of peer review in the field of robotics and makes some recommendations for potential next steps for robotics publication.

Submitted: Jun 14, 2024