Paper ID: 2409.14302

PretextTrans: Investigating Medical Factual Knowledge Mastery of LLMs with Predicate-text Dual Transformation

Yuxuan Zhou, Xien Liu, Chen Ning, Ji Wu

In the study, we aim to investigate current LLMs' mastery of medical factual knowledge with a dynamic evaluation schema, which can automatically generate multiple test samples for each medical factual knowledge point. Test samples produced directly by LLMs always introduce factual errors and lack diversity in the manner of knowledge expression. To overcome the drawbacks, here we propose a novel evaluation method, Predicate-text Dual Transformation (PretextTrans), by introducing predicate transformations into the dynamic evaluation schema. Specifically, each medical knowledge point is firstly transformed into a predicate expression; then, the predicate expression derives a series of variants through predicate transformations; lastly, the produced predicate variants are transformed back into textual expressions, resulting in a series of test samples with both factual reliability and expression diversity. Using the proposed PretextTrans method, we systematically investigate 12 well-known LLMs' mastery of medical factual knowledge based on two medical datasets. The comparison results show that current LLMs still have significant deficiencies in fully mastering medical knowledge, which may illustrate why current LLMs still perform unsatisfactorily in real-world medical scenarios despite having achieved considerable performance on public benchmarks. Our proposed method serves as an effective solution for evaluation of LLMs in medical domain and offers valuable insights for developing medical-specific LLMs.

Submitted: Sep 22, 2024