Paper ID: 2411.08504

Towards Objective and Unbiased Decision Assessments with LLM-Enhanced Hierarchical Attention Networks

Junhua Liu, Kwan Hui Lim, Roy Ka-Wei Lee

How objective and unbiased are we while making decisions? This work investigates cognitive bias identification in high-stake decision making process by human experts, questioning its effectiveness in real-world settings, such as candidates assessments for university admission. We begin with a statistical analysis assessing correlations among different decision points among in the current process, which discovers discrepancies that imply cognitive bias and inconsistency in decisions. This motivates our exploration of bias-aware AI-augmented workflow that surpass human judgment. We propose BGM-HAN, a hierarchical attention network enhanced by byte-pair encoding, multi-head attention and gated residual connection. Using it as backbone model, we further propose a Shortlist-Analyse-Recommend (SAR) agentic workflow, which simulate real-world decision-making. In our experiments, both the proposed model and the agentic workflow significantly improves on both human judgment and alternative models, validated with real-world data.

Submitted: Nov 13, 2024