Deep Network Approximation: Beyond ReLU to Diverse Activation Functions

In contrast to most studies on neural network approximation theory that characterize results through a single parameter, such as the total number of network parameters, \cite{shen2020deep} pioneered the characterization of approximation rates as a joint function of the width parameter $N$ and the depth parameter $L$, thereby granting greater architectural flexibility. Existing works using the $(N,L)$-characterization focus on function classes with finite smoothness $s$, establishing a typical approximation rate of $\mathcal{O}\left(N^{-2s/d}L^{-2s/d}\right)$ with $d$ denoting the input dimension, which indicates that network depth and width play symmetric roles for these classes. In contrast, this paper establishes upper bounds for the approximation of analytic functions, which possess infinite smoothness, via ReLU networks under the $(N,L)$-characterization. Specifically, we derive approximation rates of $\mathcal{O}\left(N^{-C L^τ}\right)$, where $C>0$ is some constant and $τ>0$ is a parameter influenced by the relation between $L$ and $N$. In particular, $τ=1$ if $N$ scales roughly as $L^d$. Our findings reveal that depth plays a more critical role than width in the context of analytic function approximation. The main technical difficulty of obtaining such upper bounds lies in the trade-off between the smoothness parameters and the approximation accuracy. To overcome this difficulty, we employ refined constructions of several ReLU networks to approximate power functions, multivariate multiplication, and polynomials, which may be of independent interest.

We develop a unified function space theory of deep fully connected neural networks. Functions in our spaces are defined recursively as $\ell^1$-bounded linear combinations of activated functions from preceding layers, with a dictionary of affine functions at the first layer. Unlike existing theories that are largely specialized to homogeneous activations such as the ReLU, our framework provides a meaningful notion of functional complexity for deep networks with a broad range of homogeneous and non-homogeneous activation functions commonly used in practice. This simple construction unites several seemingly disparate ideas from the literature, including norm-based complexity bounds and variational characterizations of depth, and facilitates novel analyses of what kinds of functions deep norm-constrained networks can represent. To this end, we prove a novel representer theorem for our spaces and establish novel function-space complexity bounds showing that the associated function classes remain qualitatively small at arbitrary depth. In the univariate ReLU case, we prove a "depth saturation" result: depth in this setting yields only a small constant rescaling of the function class, with no added functional diversity. As a consequence, we show that deep norm-controlled ReLU functions in any dimension cannot exhibit high frequencies along any direction. This finding reveals that some commonly cited expressivity benefits of depth disappear once network complexity is controlled by an appropriate function space norm, rather than parameter count or other representational costs that permit compounded rescaling across layers. Overall, our results illustrate how a function space perspective yields new structural insights into the relationship between depth and complexity.

In this work, we investigate new activation functions for achieving arbitrary-accuracy Sobolev approximation by fixed-size neural networks. We first show that any function in $W^{2,\infty}((a,b)^d)$ can be approximated with arbitrary accuracy, measured in the $W^{1,\infty}$-norm, by a fixed-size neural network using the Elementary Universal Activation Function ($\mathrm{EUAF}$). To extend this result to $W^{s,\infty}((a,b)^d)$ for $s\in\mathbb{N}$, we introduce a smooth activation $\mathrm{DUAF}_{\infty}$ from the family of Differentiable Universal Activation Functions ($\mathrm{DUAF}_n$). We prove that any function in $W^{s,\infty}((a,b)^d)$ can be approximated with arbitrary accuracy in the $W^{s-1,\infty}$-norm by a fixed-size $\mathrm{DUAF}_{\infty}$-activated network. We further construct sigmoidal variants $\widetilde{\mathrm{DUAF}}_n$ and show that, for every $1\leq s\leq n$, fixed-size $\widetilde{\mathrm{DUAF}}_n$-activated networks still approximate any $f\in W^{s,\infty}((a,b)^d)$ with arbitrary accuracy in the $W^{s-1,\infty}$-norm. In all these results, the width and depth bounds are computed explicitly, and the proposed activations are elementary.