Over-parameterization and Adversarial Robustness in Neural Networks: An Overview and Empirical Analysis
Authors: Srishti Gupta, Zhang Chen, Luca Demetrio, Fabio Brau, Xiaoyi Feng, Zhaoqiang Xia, Antonio Emanuele Cinà, Maura Pintor, +4 more
Abstract
Thanks to their extensive capacity, over-parameterized neural networks exhibit superior predictive capabilities and generalization. However, having a large parameter space is considered one of the main suspects of the neural networks' vulnerability to adversarial example -- input samples crafted ad-hoc to induce a desired misclassification. Relevant literature has claimed contradictory remarks in support of and against the robustness of over-parameterized networks. These contradictory findings might be due to the failure of the attack employed to evaluate the networks' robustness. Previous research has demonstrated that depending on the considered model, the algorithm employed to generate adversarial examples may not function properly, leading to overestimating the model's robustness. In this work, we empirically study the robustness of over-parameterized networks against adversarial examples. However, unlike the previous works, we also evaluate the considered attack's reliability to support the results' veracity. Our results show that over-parameterized networks are robust against adversarial attacks as opposed to their under-parameterized counterparts.
Deep neural networks (DNNs) are highly vulnerable to adversarial attacks. Ideally, a robust model should perform well on both perturbed training data and unseen perturbed test data. While DNNs can fit perturbed training data, generalizing to perturbed test data remains a significant challenge. This motivates the study of generalization guarantees from a learning theory perspective. This paper focuses on adversarial Rademacher complexity (ARC), first introduced by Khim and Loh (2018) and Yin et al. (2019). Their work primarily addressed linear functions and highlighted the open question of how to bound ARC for neural networks. Since then, several attempts have been made, with the latest results applying ARC only to two-layer neural networks. The main challenge arises from the dynamic nature and unknown closed-form solution of adversarial examples. In this paper, we resolve this issue and provide the first bound on ARC for deep neural networks. Our bound is qualitatively comparable to Rademacher complexity bounds in similar settings. The key ingredient is a new concept we introduce, termed intermediate adversarial examples, along with a framework for calculating the covering number that is compatible with them. Finally, we present experiments to analyze poor robust generalization, demonstrating that the weight norm is a crucial factor influencing the robust generalization gap.
Adversarial Training (AT) improves neural network robustness, but most methods train a fixed parameter space from the start. This paper asks whether the order in which parameters become optimizable can affect the final robust solution, even when the final architecture or computation budget is controlled. We propose GRAPE, Guided Parameter-Space Evolution, a training framework for compact adversarial robustness. GRAPE combines parameter-space stabilization with progressive hidden expansion: it stabilizes robust optimization in the currently exposed space, gradually releases new optimizable dimensions, and uses an adversarial spectral utilization score to guide newly released capacity toward high-pressure modules. In contrast to fixed-structure AT, GRAPE treats robust model learning as a process of progressive parameter-space exposure and evolution. Under the standard ℓ∞ threat model on CIFAR-10, with fixed-structure ResNet-18 AT as a controlled reference, GRAPE improves PGD-20 robust accuracy from 51.70% to 56.94% at a nearly matched computation budget with a FLOPs ratio of 1.009x, while reducing parameter count by about 21.4%. A sequential grow variant with the same final ResNet-18 architecture reaches 56.52% PGD-20 robust accuracy, indicating that the gain is not only due to final architecture differences but also to the parameter-space exposure path. These results suggest that guided parameter-space evolution can yield compact and robust parameter configurations under matched computation.
Deep learning models are widely deployed in safety-critical domains, but remain vulnerable to adversarial attacks. In this paper, we study the adversarial robustness of NTK neural networks in the context of nonparametric regression. We establish minimax optimal rates for adversarial regression in Sobolev spaces and then show that NTK neural networks, trained via gradient flow with early stopping, can achieve this optimal rate. However, in the overfitting regime, we prove that the minimum norm interpolant is vulnerable to adversarial perturbations.