cs.LGMay 22, 2025

Bigger Isn't Always Memorizing: Early Stopping Overparameterized Diffusion Models

Authors: Alessandro Favero, Antonio Sclocchi, Matthieu Wyart

Organizations: EPFL, Lausanne, Switzerland · Gatsby Unit, UCL, London, UK · Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA

Abstract

Diffusion probabilistic models have become a cornerstone of modern generative AI, yet the mechanisms underlying their generalization remain poorly understood. In fact, if these models were perfectly minimizing their training loss, they would just generate data belonging to their training set, i.e., memorize, as empirically found in the overparameterized regime. We revisit this view by showing that, in highly overparameterized diffusion models, generalization in natural data domains is progressively achieved during training before the onset of memorization. Our results, ranging from image to language diffusion models, systematically support the empirical law that memorization time is proportional to the dataset size, consistent with a kernel-regression bound on the time required to fit the empirical score at low noise. Generalization vs. memorization is then best understood as a competition between time scales. We show that this phenomenology is recovered in diffusion models learning a simple probabilistic context-free grammar with random rules, where generalization corresponds to the hierarchical acquisition of deeper grammar rules as training time grows, and the generalization cost of early stopping can be characterized. We summarize these results in a phase diagram. Overall, our results support that a principled early-stopping criterion - scaling with dataset size - can effectively optimize generalization while avoiding memorization, with direct implications for hyperparameter transfer and privacy-sensitive applications.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables12 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

May 7, 2026

Understanding diffusion models requires rethinking (again) generalization

This position paper argues that understanding generalization in diffusion models requires fundamentally new theoretical frameworks that go beyond both classical statistical learning theory and the benign overfitting paradigm developed for supervised learning. In diffusion models, unlike in supervised learning, memorization of training data and generalization to novel samples are incompatible: a model that has fully memorized its training set generates copies rather than novel data. Several theoretical explanations for why practical diffusion models nevertheless generalize have been proposed, based on capacity limitations, implicit regularization from optimization, or architectural inductive biases, but their interactions remain unclear. We argue that the field should pivot from explaining why the diffusion models do not memorize to investigating what the model actually learns during pre-memorization phase. To highlight our stance, we conduct empirical study of diffusion models trained on CIFAR-10, and we distill the findings into concrete open questions that we believe are key to improve understanding of generalization in diffusion models.
Mar 12, 2026

Beyond Sample Copying: Structural Memorization in Diffusion Models

Diffusion models generalize well in practice. Paradoxically, an optimal diffusion model fully memorizes the training data and therefore fails to generalize, raising the question of what induces generalization in a real diffusion model. We show that diffusion models progressively overfit the denoising training objective, creating a generalization gap between validation and training performance at intermediate noise levels. In a fully analytic 2D toy model with a controlled denoising error, we trace this gap to the interaction between model error and the density of the data distribution's support. The optimal denoising flow field localizes sharply around individual training points, whereas model error suppresses exact recall of training points, yielding a smooth, generalizing flow field. Finally, we examine how training-time overfitting manifests along inference trajectories. We find that predictions made from intermediate trajectory states occupy a distinct feature-space regime from predictions made from noised training and validation images. As training progresses and model size increases, these predictions develop greater relative affinity to the training data, despite the absolute similarity to the validation data not decreasing. Together, these findings show that the denoising objective and inference trajectories express structural memorization differently.
Oct 23, 2026

Information-Theoretic Scaling Laws for Generative Diffusion Training

Diffusion models trained on increasingly large datasets sampled from the same data distribution will converge to the same learned distribution. However, in practice, a model trained on finite data depends on the particular training dataset; this dependence is reflected in properties of the model's outputs, such as memorization and sample quality. To understand this dependence through an information-theoretic lens, we study model information, a computationally tractable measure of how much samples from the trained model depend on the particular training dataset. We explore its scaling behavior as model size and training dataset size vary. Specifically, we uncover two qualitatively distinct scaling regimes: (1) a nonlinear model information regime marking the transition from pure memorization to imperfect generalization, and (2) a generalization regime characterized by linear scaling of the model information and progressively improved generalization and sample quality. We then posit an information-theoretically principled scaling law to quantify these two regimes, and show that this law yields induced scaling laws for memorization and sample quality. We finally demonstrate that these induced scaling laws extrapolate well outside the fit's domain. Our results demonstrate information-theoretic principles for memorization and sample quality scaling laws in diffusion models. Our code is publicly available on GitHub.