cs.LGFeb 24, 2026

Ski Rental with Distributional Predictions of Unknown Quality

Authors: Qiming Cui, Michael Dinitz

Organizations: Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD USA

Abstract

We revisit the central online problem of ski rental in the "algorithms with predictions" framework from the point of view of distributional predictions. Ski rental was one of the first problems to be studied with predictions, where a natural prediction is simply the number of ski days. But it is both more natural and potentially more powerful to think of a prediction as a distribution p-hat over the ski days. If the true number of ski days is drawn from some true (but unknown) distribution p, then we show as our main result that there is an algorithm with expected cost at most OPT + O(min(max({eta}, 1) * sqrt(b), b log b)), where OPT is the expected cost of the optimal policy for the true distribution p, b is the cost of buying, and {eta} is the Earth Mover's (Wasserstein-1) distance between p and p-hat. Note that when {eta} < o(sqrt(b)) this gives additive loss less than b (the trivial bound), and when {eta} is arbitrarily large (corresponding to an extremely inaccurate prediction) we still do not pay more than O(b log b) additive loss. An implication of these bounds is that our algorithm has consistency O(sqrt(b)) (additive loss when the prediction error is 0) and robustness O(b log b) (additive loss when the prediction error is arbitrarily large). Moreover, we do not need to assume that we know (or have any bound on) the prediction error {eta}, in contrast with previous work in robust optimization which assumes that we know this error. We complement this upper bound with a variety of lower bounds showing that it is essentially tight: not only can the consistency/robustness tradeoff not be improved, but our particular loss function cannot be meaningfully improved.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

Mar 31, 2026

Robust and Consistent Ski Rental with Distributional Advice

The ski rental problem is a canonical model for online decision-making under uncertainty, capturing the fundamental trade-off between repeated rental costs and a one-time purchase. While classical algorithms focus on worst-case competitive ratios and recent "learning-augmented" methods leverage point-estimate predictions, neither approach fully exploits the richness of full distributional predictions while maintaining rigorous robustness guarantees. We address this gap by establishing a systematic framework that integrates distributional advice of unknown quality into both deterministic and randomized algorithms. For the deterministic setting, we formalize the problem under perfect distributional prediction and derive an efficient algorithm to compute the optimal threshold-buy day. We provide a rigorous performance analysis, identifying sufficient conditions on the predicted distribution under which the expected competitive ratio (ECR) matches the classic optimal randomized bound. To handle imperfect predictions, we propose the Clamp Policy, which restricts the buying threshold to a safe range controlled by a tunable parameter. We show that this policy is both robust, maintaining good performance even with large prediction errors, and consistent, approaching the optimal performance as predictions become accurate. For the randomized setting, we characterize the stopping distribution via a Water-Filling Algorithm, which optimizes expected cost while strictly satisfying robustness constraints. Experimental results across diverse distributions (Gaussian, geometric, and bi-modal) demonstrate that our framework improves consistency significantly over existing point-prediction baselines while maintaining comparable robustness.
Sep 4, 2026

Learning-Augmented Algorithms: Guarantees, Construction Mechanisms, and System-Level Implications

Learning-augmented algorithms use fallible predictions while retaining formal performance guarantees. This survey synthesizes prediction interfaces, error measures, consistency--robustness trade-offs, and five representative construction mechanisms across online optimization, caching, learned data structures, graph problems, and mechanism design. An orthogonal theorem-level axis distinguishes achieved upper bounds from matched asymptotic dependence. Formal guarantees are separated from empirical systems evidence, with explicit treatment of prediction cost, feedback, and composition. The resulting synthesis states sufficient conditions for limited end-to-end reasoning and delineates open problems in cost-aware prediction, endogenous error, semantic predictors, and benchmarking.
Jun 3, 2026

Learning-Augmented Online Minimization with Dual Predictions

We present learning-augmented algorithms for two general classes of online minimization problems: metrical task systems and laminar set cover. Both algorithms achieve improved theoretical guarantees using machine-learned predictions of an optimal solution to the dual linear program. Unlike optimal primal solutions, which can change drastically under tiny instance perturbations, these dual solutions are much more stable, which ensures the existence of good (and learnable) predictions for families of similar instances. While previous work has used dual predictions in offline settings and for online maximization problems, our algorithms are, to the best of our knowledge, the first demonstration that such dual predictions can be effective for online minimization. Our theoretical results are complemented by experiments on the kk-server problem and the parking permit problem.