MUON+: Towards More Effective Muon via One Additional Normalization Step for LLM Pre-training

The success of large language models (LLMs) has been accompanied by continued growth in model size and pretraining costs. Muon offers high accuracy and training efficiency in LLM pretraining. Recent work introduces row-wise normalization into Muon to balance update magnitudes and improve pretraining performance. However, row-wise normalization alone cannot accommodate different imbalance patterns in update matrices. In this paper, we propose an improved Muon optimizer, called matrix-equilibrating Muon~(MeqMuon), for LLM pretraining. MeqMuon balances both row and column magnitudes through normalization that can be automatically tailored to different imbalance patterns without manual intervention. Moreover, MeqMuon eliminates the need to store AdamW's second-moment estimates, reducing optimizer-state memory usage. Empirical results demonstrate that MeqMuon achieves better convergence performance than AdamW, Muon, and other baselines in LLM pretraining.

Orthogonalized-update optimizers such as Muon improve training of matrix-valued parameters, but existing extensions typically either rescale updates after orthogonalization or use heavier whitening-based preconditioners before it. We introduce {\method}, a lightweight family of pre-orthogonalization equilibration schemes for Muon with three forms: two-sided row/column normalization (RC), row normalization (R), and column normalization (C). By rebalancing the momentum matrix before finite-step Newton--Schulz orthogonalization, {\method} improves the geometry seen by orthogonalization. We show that finite-step orthogonalization is governed by the input spectrum, especially stable rank and condition number, and that row/column normalization acts as a zeroth-order surrogate for whitening. For hidden matrix weights, R is the default variant. Theoretically, {\method} (R) retains the standard $\widetilde{\mathcal O}(T^{-1/4})$ Muon-type nonconvex stationarity guarantee with decoupled weight decay and a horizon-free diminishing learning-rate schedule, and extends it to finite-step NS5 up to an explicit inexactness constant. In LLaMA2 pretraining on C4, {\method} (R) consistently outperforms Muon on 130M, 350M, and 1B models, with faster convergence and lower validation perplexity. The code is available at the MuonEq codebase.

Muon has emerged as a promising optimizer for large-scale foundation model pre-training by exploiting the matrix structure of neural network updates through iterative orthogonalization. However, the orthogonalization quality of Muon hinges on the number of Newton--Schulz (NS) iterations performed, which poses efficiency challenges due to its non-trivial computation and communication cost. We propose Muon$^2$, an extension of Muon, to improve both quality and efficiency by applying Adam-style adaptive second-moment preconditioning before orthogonalization. Our key insight is that the core challenge of polar approximation in Muon lies in the ill-conditioned momentum matrix, of which the spectrum is substantially improved by Muon$^2$, leading to faster convergence toward a practically sufficient orthogonalization. We further characterize the practical orthogonalization quality via directional alignment, under which Muon$^2$ demonstrates dramatic improvement over Muon at each polar step. Across GPT, LLaMA, and Mixture-of-Experts pre-training experiments up to 13B parameters, Muon$^2$ (and its memory-efficient variant Muon$^2$-F that preserves most of its benefits) consistently outperforms Muon and its variants while reducing NS iterations by 40%, and saves up to 1/4 training time over Muon when achieving the same loss.