Do Compact SSL Backbones Matter for Audio Deepfake Detection? A Controlled Study with RAPTOR

Audio deepfake detection systems often fail to generalize across domains because they rely on features tied to specific attacks or recording conditions. Self-supervised speech models offer rich multi-layer representations, yet existing approaches either use a single layer or fuse all layers indiscriminately, and only reveal layer importance after training. We propose a model-agnostic, two-stage methodology that identifies informative depth zones before any task-specific model is trained. In the first stage, lightweight XGBoost probes evaluate each transformer layer's cross-domain discriminative power, producing a layer ranking. In the second stage, a compact neural classifier fuses only the selected layers through per-layer attention pooling and a shared bottleneck projection, while the backbone remains frozen. Applied across three backbones, the probing reveals two key findings. First, informative layers cluster in depth zones rather than at uniquely optimal positions: within-zone substitutions fall within multi-seed noise, while zone violations degrade performance by up to 5x. Second, the probing produces backbone-specific selections rather than a fixed layer recipe. On XLS-R-300M, four probing-selected layers with 1.34M trainable parameters achieve 4.94 +/- 0.32% equal error rate on In-The-Wild and 5.07% cross-domain average over four shared datasets, a 28% relative improvement over the best prior frozen-backbone result (Xiao and Vu, 2025) using all 25 layers with identical training data.

Self-supervised learning (SSL) has transformed speech processing, with benchmarks such as SUPERB establishing fair comparisons across diverse downstream tasks. Despite it's security-critical importance, Audio deepfake detection has remained outside these efforts. In this work, we introduce Spoof-SUPERB, a benchmark for audio deepfake detection that systematically evaluates 20 SSL models spanning generative, discriminative, and spectrogram-based architectures. We evaluated these models on multiple in-domain and out-of-domain datasets. Our results reveal that large-scale discriminative models such as XLS-R, UniSpeech-SAT, and WavLM Large consistently outperform other models, benefiting from multilingual pretraining, speaker-aware objectives, and model scale. We further analyze the robustness of these models under acoustic degradations, showing that generative approaches degrade sharply, while discriminative models remain resilient. This benchmark establishes a reproducible baseline and provides practical insights into which SSL representations are most reliable for securing speech systems against audio deepfakes.

The increasing realism of speech generated by text-to-speech and voice conversion systems poses growing challenges to media integrity and voice authentication. Self-supervised learning (SSL) has substantially advanced speech deepfake detection, where downstream backbones conventionally process SSL representations through a single forward pass. This work investigates the practical effectiveness of recurrent hierarchical reasoning for this task. We term this controlled study REIMU and systematically compare conventional single-pass backbones, weight-shared recurrence, homogeneous HRM, and heterogeneous HRM across four Base-scale SSL frontends. We further examine heterogeneous high- and low-level modules that combine self-attention with linear attention. Experiments on the ASVspoof 2019 and 2021 evaluation sets show that recurrence and hierarchical decomposition do not inherently improve detection, whereas heterogeneous operator assignment provides a more competitive configuration. Notably, the heterogeneous design remains competitive while using 10.8% fewer downstream parameters than the matched baseline, demonstrating its potential for parameter-efficient speech deepfake detection.