Scaling Self-Supervised Speech Models Uncovers Deep Linguistic Relationships: Evidence from the Pacific Cluster
Authors: Minu Kim, Hoirin Kim, David R. Mortensen
Organizations: Thomas Lord Department of Computer Science, University of Southern California, USA · School of Electrical Engineering, KAIST, Republic of Korea · Language Technologies Institute, Carnegie Mellon University, USA
Similarities between language representations derived from Self-Supervised Speech Models (S3Ms) have been observed to primarily reflect geographic proximity or surface typological similarities driven by recent expansion or contact, potentially missing deeper genealogical signals. We investigate how scaling an S3M-based language identification system from 126 to 4,017 languages reshapes this topology, and find a non-linear effect: phylogenetic recovery stays flat up to the 1K scale, but the 4K model undergoes a qualitative shift, resolving both clear lineages and long-term linguistic contact. Most strikingly, a robust Pacific macro-cluster emerges, grouping genealogically unrelated Papuan, Oceanic, and Australian languages, and we trace its driver to a concentrated encoding that captures shared acoustic signatures such as global energy dynamics. These results suggest that massive S3Ms internalize multiple layers of language history, offering a promising perspective for computational phylogenetics and the study of language contact.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: Evaluation data exposure: MMS-LID-1K vs. 4K. Identical seen/unseen status for 91.8% (45/49) of evaluation languages ensures that performance gaps come from increased linguistic diversity rather than direct exposure.
Figure 2: Phylogenetic recovery performance across cluster counts K∈[2,20] for four model scales. Performance plateaus up to 1K, but shifting to 4K results in a leap that peaks at K=18 , substantially outperforming all smaller baselines.
Figure 3: 4K model bootstrap consensus dendrogram (1,000 replicates). Branch values indicate support percentages. Red boxes highlight clusters reflecting linguistic contact, including the distinction between Austronesian subgroups A and B. Remarkably, 36 of 37 branches with >50% confidence align with established phylogenetic or areal groupings.
Figure 4: POA cluster quality across K . Precision plateaus at 0.92 for 128, 256, and 1K models, but the 4K model achieves perfect Precision (1.00), demonstrating a unique capacity to isolate Pacific languages.
Figure 5: PCA projections of the embedding spaces for 1K (left) and 4K (right) models across selected groups. The 4K model exhibits more clearly delineated family-level boundaries and a more distinct spatial separation of the POA cluster compared to the 1K model.
MMS-LID-1K
MMS-LID-4K
FDR
Bonf.
FDR
Bonf.
# Sig. Dimensions
257
36
169
25
Feature
Energy dynamic range
18.3
–
18.9
28.0
MFCC 1 std
27.2
11.1
9.5
4.0
MFCC 2 std
17.9
2.8
13.6
12.0
Table 1: Of the total 1,280 dimensions, the first row defines the significant subset used as the denominator for the percentages (%) of Pearson-correlated dimensions per feature. ( p<.05 )
Feature
Direction (POA)
Effect size (Cohen’s d )
Energy dynamic range
Higher
+0.69
MFCC 1 std
Lower
-0.76
MFCC 2 std
Lower
-0.88
MFCC 3 std
Lower
-1.17
MFCC 4 std
Lower
-0.76
Spectral centroid std
Lower
-0.61
Table 2: Significant acoustic differences between POA and Non-POA languages (Mann–Whitney U test). All listed features satisfy p<.001 and ∣d∣>0.5 .
Self-supervised speech models (S3Ms) are known to encode rich phonetic information, yet how this information is structured remains underexplored. We conduct a comprehensive study across 96 languages to analyze the underlying structure of S3M representations, with particular attention to phonological vectors. We first show that there exist linear directions within the model's representation space that correspond to phonological features. We further demonstrate that the scale of these phonological vectors correlate to the degree of acoustic realization of their corresponding phonological features in a continuous manner. For example, the difference between [d] and [t] yields a voicing vector: adding this vector to [p] produces [b], while scaling it results in a continuum of voicing. Together, these findings indicate that S3Ms encode speech using phonologically interpretable and compositional vectors, demonstrating phonological vector arithmetic. All code and interactive demos are available at https://github.com/juice500ml/phonetic-arithmetic .
Computational phylogenetics has become an essential tool in historical linguistics, yet its application at a global scale remains constrained by two factors: the labor-intensive manual annotation of cognacy judgments required for character-based methods and the substantial computational cost of inference on large datasets. This paper introduces a fully self-supervised contrastive learning framework that learns lexical representations directly from raw IPA-transcribed wordlists, without requiring cognacy annotations, alignments, or additional expert input. The model employs a dual contrastive objective: a word-level loss that organizes phonetically similar forms into a coherent space, and an auxiliary language-level loss that encourages the lexical space to reflect broader phonological properties of languages. From the resulting word representations, pairwise language distances are derived and used to infer a global phylogenetic tree of 3,399 language varieties. The inferred tree achieves a generalized quartet distance (GQD) to the Glottolog reference tree competitive with multiple baselines, while requiring only minutes of computation on a standard notebook GPU. Furthermore, the same representations capture diachronic concept stability: variance in pairwise distances across languages yields stability rankings that correlate significantly with established rankings. Ablation studies confirm that both the language-level objective and the use of phonetic feature vectors improved the inferred trees topology with regards to GQD. The framework thus provides a computationally efficient and fully automatic alternative for large-scale phylogenetic inference and offers a unified representation supporting downstream analyses at both the language and concept level.
Transformer-based self-supervised speech models (S3Ms) are often described as contextualized, yet what this entails remains unclear. Here, we focus on how a single frame-level S3M representation can encode phones and their surrounding context. Prior work has shown that S3Ms represent phones compositionally; for example, phonological vectors such as voicing, bilabiality, and nasality vectors are superposed in the S3M representation of [m]. We extend this view by proposing that phonological information from a sequence of neighboring phones is also compositionally encoded in a single frame, such that vectors corresponding to previous, current, and next phones are superposed within a single frame-level representation. We show that this structure has several properties, including orthogonality between relative positions, and emergence of implicit phonetic boundaries. Together, our findings advance our understanding of context-dependent S3M representations.
Kwanghee Choi, Eunjung Yeo, Cheol Jun Cho +2
UT Austin · UC Berkeley · Carnegie Mellon University