A Systematic Comparison of Training Objectives for Out-of-Distribution Detection in Image Classification

Deep learning models are increasingly deployed in safety-critical applications, where reliable out-of-distribution (OOD) detection is essential to ensure robustness. Existing methods predominantly rely on the penultimate-layer activations of neural networks, assuming they encapsulate the most informative in-distribution (ID) representations. In this work, we revisit this assumption to show that intermediate layers encode equally rich and discriminative information for OOD detection. Based on this observation, we propose a simple yet effective model-agnostic approach that leverages internal representations across multiple layers. Our scheme aggregates features from successive convolutional blocks, computes class-wise mean embeddings, and applies L_2 normalization to form compact ID prototypes capturing class semantics. During inference, cosine similarity between test features and these prototypes serves as an OOD score--ID samples exhibit strong affinity to at least one prototype, whereas OOD samples remain uniformly distant. Extensive experiments on state-of-the-art OOD benchmarks across diverse architectures demonstrate that our approach delivers robust, architecture-agnostic performance and strong generalization for image classification. Notably, it improves AUROC by up to 4.41% and reduces FPR by 13.58%, highlighting multi-layer feature aggregation as a powerful yet underexplored signal for OOD detection, challenging the dominance of penultimate-layer-based methods. Our code is available at: https://github.com/sgchr273/cosine-layers.git.

Recent studies show that using potential out-of-distribution (OOD) labels from large corpora as auxiliary information can improve OOD detection in vision-language models (VLMs). However, these methods often fail when real-world OOD samples fall outside the predefined OOD label set. To address this limitation, we propose DynProto, a novel approach that learns OOD prototypes dynamically during testing using only in-distribution (ID) information. DynProto is inspired by a key observation: OOD samples predicted as the same ID class tend to cluster in the feature space. With this insight, we leverage easy-to-detect OOD samples as ``anchors'' to find their harder-to-detect, similar counterparts. To this end, DynProto introduces two modules: Coarse OOD Pattern Capturing Module caches OOD patterns that are easily confused with each ID class during testing, and Fine-grained OOD Pattern Refinement Module subsequently clusters these patterns within each cache and aggregates them into representative OOD prototypes. By measuring similarity to ID and dynamic OOD prototypes, DynProto enables accurate OOD detection. DynProto significantly outperforms prior methods across multiple benchmarks. On ImageNet OOD benchmark, DynProto reduces FPR95 by 11.60% and improves AUROC by 4.70%. Moreover, the framework is architecture-agnostic and can be integrated into various backbones.

Out-of-distribution (OOD) detection is essential for deploying machine learning models in open-world and safety-critical scenarios, where test inputs may deviate from the training distribution and overconfident predictions on unknown samples can lead to unreliable decisions. Outlier Exposure (OE) has emerged as a promising OOD detection paradigm by introducing auxiliary outliers during training to enlarge the margin between in-distribution (ID) and OOD samples. Existing OE-based methods typically enlarge this margin by employing uniform labels to maximize the entropy of OOD samples over ID categories. However, we theoretically show that uniform labels inevitably disregard the relations between OOD samples and ID categories, termed the over-softening effect, leading to a suboptimal margin bound. Our theoretical analysis further reveals that explicitly exploiting such relations can instead yield improved OOD detection performance. Motivated by this insight, we propose Adaptive Confidence OE (AOE), a simple yet effective method that leverages temperature scaling to recalibrate outlier labels. Specifically, AOE generates adaptive soft targets from temperature-scaled model predictions for OOD samples, where the learnable temperature smooths the prediction distribution without fully erasing class-wise relational information. By supervising OOD samples with these adaptive soft targets, AOE preserves the semantic proximity between OOD samples and ID categories while encouraging the softened targets to approach a high-entropy distribution, thereby suppressing overconfident OOD predictions and enlarging the separation margin. Extensive experiments across diverse benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of AOE.