Thinking with Tables: Enhancing Multi-Modal Tabular Understanding via Neuro-Symbolic Reasoning
Authors: Kun-Yang Yu, Zhi Zhou, Shi-Yu Tian, Xiao-Wen Yang, Zi-Yi Jia, Ming Yang, Zi-Jian Cheng, Lan-Zhe Guo, Yu-Feng Li
Organizations: State Key Laboratory of Novel Software Technology, Nanjing University, China · School of Artificial Intelligence, Nanjing University, China · School of Intelligence Science and Technology, Nanjing University, China
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have demonstrated remarkable reasoning capabilities across modalities such as images and text. However, tabular data, despite being a critical real-world modality, remains relatively underexplored in multimodal learning. In this paper, we focus on the task of Tabular-Vision Multi-Modal Understanding (TVMU) and identify three core challenges: (1) high structural variability and data incompleteness in tables, (2) implicit and complex feature dependencies, and (3) significant heterogeneity in problem-solving pipelines across downstream tasks. To address these issues, we propose Thinking with Tables (TWT). TWT employs a program-aided code-based neuro-symbolic reasoning mechanism that facilitates key operations, such as information extraction and element modeling, by interacting with external environments. We evaluate TWT on eight representative datasets. Experimental results demonstrate that TWT consistently outperforms existing baselines by an average of 10% in accuracy, achieving performance comparable to, or even surpassing, proprietary commercial SOTA LLMs on TVMU tasks. Models and codes are available at https://github.com/kunyang-YU/Thinking-with-Tables
Figures & tables
Figure 1
Figure 3: TWT framework. It realizes robust and good performance via code-base neuro-symbolic reasoning in TVMU tasks.
Models
Multimodal Table QA
Multimodal Table Prediction
AVG_rank
TabMWP
WikiTQ
FinQA
TAT-QA
Adoption
SkinCA
Pawpularity
Paintings
ACC ↑
ACC ↑
ACC ↑
ACC ↑
ACC ↑
ACC ↑
nRMSE ↓
nRMSE ↓
-
API-based MLLMs
GPT-5.1
92.50
40.82
47.68
56.38
26.12
65.51
0.366
0.098
3.63
Qwen3VL-Plus
98.70
76.10
64.41
72.39
18.67
51.55
0.539
0.178
4.25
General Open-Source MLLMs
Table 1: Comparison of different models on multimodal table question answering and multimodal table prediction benchmarks. The best results are shown in bold , and the second-best results are underlined.
Method
Table QA
Table Prediction
WikiTQ
TAT-QA
SkinCA
Paintings
ACC ↑
ACC ↑
ACC ↑
nRMSE ↓
Qwen3VL-8B
50.64
62.53
40.38
0.172
+TO-SFT
78.38
71.31
71.08
0.099
+AL-GRPO
78.95
72.82
73.65
0.093
Table 2: Experimental Results of Qwen3-VL-8B under TO-SFT and AL-GRPO on Table QA and Table Prediction Benchmarks. Best is shown in bold
Method
Adoption
Pawpularity
ACC ↑
nRMSE ↓
TWT w features
32.90
0.199
TWT w/o features
31.40
0.200
Table 3: Experiment results of TWT under situation w and w/o table features in multimodal table prediction tasks
Figure 4: Comparison of code execution accuracy of TWT w and w/o AL-GRPO
Table images preserve structural information that are often lost in text serialization, and reasoning over them requires locating relevant rows, columns, and cells step by step. Current multimodal large language models (MLLMs) encode the whole image once before reasoning, so they cannot pick up row-, column-, and cell-level evidence as the question unfolds. Encoder-side table structure and generic interleaved visual chain-of-thought still do not bind each reasoning step to that structure. We propose InterTab, an Interleaved structure-aware framework for CoT reasoning over Table images, interleaves chain-of-thought with tool calls that crop structure-aligned table regions. First, we build InterTab-22K, includes reasoning trajectories in which each step is tied to both a structural location and a bounding box. InterTab is trained in two stages: supervised structure-aware alignment (SSA) on InterTab-22K teaches the model to interleave reasoning with structure-aligned crops, and active localization optimization (ALO) further optimizes answer correctness, localization IoU, and output format, while penalizing missing or excessive tool calls. Experiments on nine table benchmarks show that InterTab improves the average accuracy of its backbone from 68.28% to 73.17% and achieves the best average performance among all compared methods. Code and data will be released soon.
Hanqian Li, Sirui Huang, Chen Ling +12
The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (Guangzhou) · Ant Group · Hong Kong Polytechnic University +4
Despite the success of Large Language Models (LLMs) in table understanding, their internal mechanisms remain unclear. In this paper, we conduct an empirical study on 16 LLMs, covering general LLMs, specialist tabular LLMs, and Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models, to explore how LLMs understand tabular data and perform downstream tasks. Our analysis focus on 4 dimensions including the attention dynamics, the effective layer depth, the expert activation, and the impacts of input designs. Key findings include: (1) LLMs follow a three-phase attention pattern -- early layers scan the table broadly, middle layers localize relevant cells, and late layers amplify their contributions; (2) tabular tasks require deeper layers than math reasoning to reach stable predictions; (3) MoE models activate table-specific experts in middle layers, with early and late layers sharing general-purpose experts; (4) Chain-of-Thought prompting increases table attention, further enhanced by table-tuning. We hope these findings and insights can facilitate interpretability and future research on table-related tasks.
Jia Wang, Chuanyu Qin, Mingyu Zheng +3
Institute of Information Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China · School of Cyber Security, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China
Reasoning over tabular data is a crucial capability for tasks like question answering and fact verification, as it requires models to comprehend both free-form questions and semi-structured tables. However, while methods like Chain-of-Thought (CoT) introduce reasoning chains, purely symbolic methodes are inherently limited by their blindness to holistic visual patterns. To address this, we propose the Coarse-to-Fine Multimodal Synthesis framework (CFMS), a novel two-stage paradigm that hierarchically decouples high-level visual perception from granular symbolic reasoning. In the Coarse Stage, CFMS leverages the Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) to perform a one-time synthesis of a multi-perspective knowledge tuple. This tuple subsequently serves as a dynamic reasoning map to guide the fine stage, where a symbolic engine executes a targeted and efficient sequence of iterative operations over the table. Extensive experiments on the WikiTQ and TabFact benchmarks demonstrate that CFMS achieves competitive accuracy. The framework exhibits particular robustness when handling large tables and when instantiated with smaller backbone models, validating its effectiveness and generalizability.