cs.CEApr 1, 2026

Bias Inheritance in Neural-Symbolic Discovery of Constitutive Closures Under Function-Class Mismatch

Authors: Hanbing Liang, Ze Tao, Fujun Liu

Organizations: Nanophotonics and Biophotonics Key Laboratory of Jilin Province, School of Physics, Changchun University of Science and Technology, Changchun 130022, P.R. China

Abstract

We investigate the data-driven discovery of constitutive closures in nonlinear reaction-diffusion systems with known governing PDE structures. Our objective is to robustly recover diffusion and reaction laws from spatiotemporal observations while avoiding the common pitfall where low residuals or short-horizon predictions are conflated with physical recovery. We propose a three-stage neural-symbolic framework: (1) learning numerical surrogates under physical constraints using a noise-robust weak-form-driven objective; (2) compressing these surrogates into restricted interpretable symbolic families (e.g., polynomial, rational, and saturation forms); and (3) validating the symbolic closures through explicit forward re-simulation on unseen initial conditions. Extensive numerical experiments reveal two distinct regimes. Under matched-library settings, weak polynomial baselines behave as correctly specified reference estimators, showing that neural surrogates do not uniformly outperform classical bases. Conversely, under function-class mismatch, neural surrogates provide necessary flexibility and can be compressed into compact symbolic laws with minimal rollout degradation. However, we identify a critical "bias inheritance" mechanism where symbolic compression does not automatically repair constitutive bias. Across various observation regimes, the true error of the symbolic closure closely tracks that of the neural surrogate, yielding a bias inheritance ratio near one. These findings demonstrate that the primary bottleneck in neural-symbolic modeling lies in the initial numerical inverse problem rather than the subsequent symbolic compression. We underscore that constitutive claims must be rigorously supported by forward validation rather than residual minimization alone.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables3 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

Feb 24, 2026

SymTorch: Symbolic Distillation of Neural Networks

What mathematical functions do neural network components learn? Symbolic distillation addresses this question by expressing neural network components with interpretable, closed-form mathematical expressions that expose the functional structure learned during training. We develop symbolic distillation as a systematic, architecture-agnostic methodology, and release our approach as the open-source SymTorch package - a PySR-powered library built natively for the PyTorch ecosystem. Applying this methodology across diverse architectures, we find that SymTorch is successful in the automated discovery of physical laws. Specifically, our approach (1) recovers pairwise interaction forces from graph neural networks trained on empirical nn-body observations, (2) distills the exact closed-form PDE/ODE solutions of multiple physical systems, including the value of constants, from physics-informed neural networks trained on sparse data, and (3) uncovers the chaotic dynamics of the Lorenz system from high-dimensional data, ultimately outperforming the base neural network on downstream prediction tasks. We further demonstrate the utility of our framework for model interpretability by providing an optimized implementation of SLIME - a symbolic extension to the LIME explainability method. SLIME consistently outperforms LIME across predictive metrics across eight popular classification and regression benchmarks, while still providing an interpretable local symbolic model. Lastly, we investigate replacing transformer MLP layers with symbolic surrogates: replacing 1-7 layers with symbolic approximations yields 2-19% throughput improvements and up to 18.7% VRAM reduction, with the resulting hybrid models lying on the Pareto front of throughput versus perplexity among open-source LLMs of comparable scale.
Mar 25, 2026

Symbolic--KAN: Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks with Discrete Symbolic Structure for Interpretable Learning

Symbolic discovery of governing equations is a long-standing goal in scientific machine learning, yet a fundamental trade-off persists between interpretability and scalable learning. Classical symbolic regression methods yield explicit analytic expressions but rely on combinatorial search, whereas neural networks scale efficiently with data and dimensionality but produce opaque representations. In this work, we introduce Symbolic Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks (Symbolic-KANs), a neural architecture that bridges this gap by embedding discrete symbolic structure directly within a trainable deep network. Symbolic-KANs represent multivariate functions as compositions of learned univariate primitives applied to learned scalar projections, guided by a library of analytic primitives, hierarchical gating, and symbolic regularization that progressively sharpens continuous mixtures into one-hot selections. After gated training and discretization, each active unit selects a single primitive and projection direction, yielding compact closed-form expressions without post-hoc symbolic fitting. Symbolic-KANs further act as scalable primitive discovery mechanisms, identifying the most relevant analytic components that can subsequently inform candidate libraries for sparse equation-learning methods. We demonstrate that Symbolic-KAN reliably recovers correct primitive terms and governing structures in data-driven regression and inverse dynamical systems. Moreover, the framework extends to forward and inverse physics-informed learning of partial differential equations, producing accurate solutions directly from governing constraints while constructing compact symbolic representations whose selected primitives reflect the true analytical structure of the underlying equations. These results position Symbolic-KAN as a step toward scalable, interpretable, and mechanistically grounded learning of governing laws.
Jan 14, 2025

A Neural Operator-Based Approach to Symbolic Discovery of PDEs

Discovering governing equations from data remains challenging when the underlying dynamics involve nonlocal differential operators, field interactions governed by auxiliary equations, or temporal memory effects. We propose Neural Operator-based symbolic Model approximaTion and discOvery (NOMTO), a framework that extends Equation Learner-type symbolic architectures by incorporating pretrained neural operators as nodes in the symbolic network. NOMTO represents candidate equations as sparse differentiable computational graphs that combine algebraic operations with fixed neural operator surrogates pretrained to approximate nonlinear operators. We evaluate the method on model-discovery problems involving nonlocal spatial operators, couplings mediated by auxiliary field equations, and temporal integral terms representing memory effects. The results show that NOMTO can recover compact governing equations containing nonlocal operator terms, thereby extending symbolic model discovery beyond libraries restricted to local derivatives and point-wise algebraic combinations.