cs.LGApr 16, 2026

StoSignSGD: Unbiased Structural Stochasticity Fixes SignSGD for Training Large Language Models

Authors: Dingzhi Yu, Rui Pan, Yuxing Liu, Tong Zhang

Organizations: University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign

Abstract

Sign-based optimization algorithms, such as SignSGD, have garnered significant attention for their remarkable performance in distributed learning and training large foundation models. Despite their empirical superiority, SignSGD is known to diverge on non-smooth objectives, which are ubiquitous in modern machine learning due to ReLUs, max-pools, and mixture-of-experts. To overcome this fundamental limitation, we propose \textbf{StoSignSGD}, an algorithm that injects structural stochasticity into the sign operator while maintaining an unbiased update step. In the regime of (online) convex optimization, our theoretical analysis shows that StoSignSGD rigorously resolves the non-convergence issues of SignSGD, achieving a sharp convergence rate matching the lower bound. For the more challenging non-convex non-smooth optimization, we introduce generalized stationary measures that encompass prior definitions, proving that StoSignSGD improves upon the best-known complexity bounds by dimensional factors. Empirically, StoSignSGD exhibits robust stability and superior efficiency across diverse large language model (LLM) training regimes. Notably, in low-precision FP8 pretraining -- a setting where AdamW fails catastrophically -- StoSignSGD remains highly stable and yields a remarkable 1.44×\times to 2.14×\times speedup relative to established baselines. Furthermore, when fine-tuning 7B LLMs on mathematical reasoning tasks, StoSignSGD delivers substantial performance gains over both AdamW and SignSGD. Finally, to dissect the mechanisms driving its success, we develop a sign conversion framework capable of transforming any general optimizer into its unbiased, sign-based counterpart. Utilizing this framework, we deconstruct the core components of StoSignSGD and present a comprehensive ablation study to empirically validate our algorithmic design choices.

Explore similar work

CardsList
May 7, 2026cs.LG

When and Why SignSGD Outperforms SGD: A Theoretical Study Based on \ell_1-norm Lower Bounds

Sign-based optimization algorithms, such as SignSGD and Muon, have garnered significant attention for their remarkable performance in training large foundation models. Despite this empirical success, we still lack a theoretical understanding of when and why these sign-based methods outperform vanilla SGD. The core obstacle is that under standard smoothness and finite variance conditions, SGD is known to be minimax optimal for finding stationary points measured by ℓ2\ell_2-norms, thereby fundamentally precluding any complexity gains for sign-based methods in standard settings. To overcome this barrier, we analyze sign-based optimizers leveraging ℓ1\ell_1-norm stationarity, ℓ∞\ell_\infty-smoothness, and a separable noise model, which can better capture the coordinate-wise nature of signed updates. Under this distinct problem geometry, we derive matched upper and lower bounds for SignSGD and explicitly characterize the problem class in which SignSGD provably dominates SGD. Specifically, we compare the \emph{upper bound of SignSGD} with the \emph{lower bound of SGD}, illustrating that SignSGD effectively reduces the complexity by a factor of dd under \emph{sparse noise}, where dd is the problem dimension. Furthermore, we elevate this framework to the matrix domain, providing an equivalent optimal lower bound for the Muon optimizer, proving that extending the sign operator to matrices preserves this optimal scaling with dimensionality. Finally, we bridge our theoretical bounds to practice, demonstrating that the theoretical superiority of SignSGD accurately predicts its faster convergence during the pretraining of a 124M parameter GPT-2 model.
Hongyi Tao, Dingzhi Yu, Lijun Zhang
Stochastic Gradient DescentRiemannian OptimizationSpectral NormLower BoundsStationarityTheoretical Foundations
AskPDF
Apr 28, 2026cs.LG

Enhancing SignSGD: Small-Batch Convergence Analysis and a Hybrid Switching Strategy

SignSGD compresses each stochastic gradient coordinate to a single bit, offering substantial memory and communication savings, but its 1-bit quantization removes magnitude information and is known to leave a generalization gap relative to well-tuned SGD. We revisit SignSGD from a 1-bit quantization and dithering perspective and contribute three improvements. First, we derive a small-batch convergence rate for SignSGD under unimodal symmetric gradient noise using a signal-to-noise weighted stationarity measure, removing the large-batch assumption of prior analyses. Second, we inject annealed Gaussian noise before the sign operator, which acts as a classical dithering mechanism and probabilistically restores magnitude information lost to hard thresholding. Third, we adapt the SWATS strategy to sign-based updates with a projection-based learning-rate calibration that smoothly transitions from SignSGD to SGD. Single-worker experiments on ResNet-18 isolate optimizer effects from communication aspects: pre-sign dithering surpasses Adam on CIFAR-100, and the calibrated switch reaches 92.18% test accuracy on CIFAR-10, outperforming both pure SGD 91.38% and pure SignSGD with momentum 90.82%.
Haoran Chen, Wentao Wang
Convergence AnalysisConvergenceUnimodal Representations
AskPDF
May 29, 2026cs.LG

Softsign: Smooth Sign in Your Optimizer For Better Parameter Heterogeneity Handling

Sign-based and LMO-inspired optimizers have recently attracted substantial attention in deep learning due to their strong performance and low memory footprint. However, their fixed-magnitude updates can hurt terminal convergence: they decouple update mechanisms from gradient magnitudes and fail to account for parameter heterogeneity, often leading to oscillation rather than convergence. We propose SoftSignum, a smooth relaxation of sign-based optimization that replaces the hard sign map with a temperature-controlled soft-sign transformation, enabling a parameter-wise transition from sign-like updates to magnitude-sensitive SGD-like steps. We complement it with an adaptive quantile-based temperature schedule and extend the same principle to matrix-valued optimizers, obtaining SoftMuon. We also develop a generalized geometry-relaxation framework based on strongly convex regularizers and Fenchel conjugates, proving convergence in stochastic non-convex setting. Experiments on diverse deep learning tasks, including LLM pretraining, show that SoftSignum and SoftMuon consistently improve over their hard sign-based counterparts and standard AdamW.
Dmitrii Feoktistov, Timofey Belinsky, Andrey Veprikov +2
SignHeterogeneity
AskPDF