LRS-VoxMM: A benchmark for in-the-wild audio-visual speech recognition

Current Audio-Visual Speech Recognition (AVSR) models achieve near-perfect performance on the standard LRS3 benchmark, raising concerns of adaptive overfitting. To systematically assess true generalisability, we construct a highly controlled, unseen evaluation set subsampled from the massive MultiVSR dataset. Unlike standard out-of-distribution benchmarks, our subset strictly matches the acoustic, visual, and demographic distributions of the LRS3 test set. Evaluating five state-of-the-art architectures reveals a universal performance collapse, proving that current systems fail to generalise even under strictly aligned conditions. Through a fine-grained attribute analysis across seven factors, we isolate the specific drivers of this degradation. Furthermore, we uncover a profound lexical bias, expose distinct error patterns, and surprisingly reveal that audio-visual performance even lags behind audio-only settings. We release our matched test set for future benchmarking.

Current audio-visual speech recognition (AVSR) benchmarks, like LRS3, rely heavily on clean, scripted and rehearsed speech. They fail to reflect the complexity of natural conversation, which involves overlapping speech, spontaneous turn-taking, unscripted vocabulary and variable acoustic conditions. To shift the field toward realistic dialogue, we introduce Candor-LR, a conversational benchmark derived from the CANDOR corpus of 1,656 natural dyadic videoconferences. Our custom data preparation pipeline yields 713.5, 10.1, and 60.1 hours of training, validation, and test data, respectively. Evaluating pretrained AVSR models on Candor-LR reveals that audio-only accuracy drops sharply compared to LRS3, but visual cues compensate effectively, driving much larger performance gains on Candor-LR than on LRS3. Furthermore, training on this corpus significantly improves cross-domain robustness under both clean and noisy conditions, as its realistic conversational data captures broader audio-video features. We open-source our pipeline to ensure reproducibility, establishing Candor-LR as a challenging benchmark for conversational AVSR.

While AVSR has achieved sub-1% word error rates on the standard LRS3 benchmark, its reliance on broadcast speech obscures whether this reflects true generalization or just domain adaptation. To investigate this gap, we evaluate three AVSR architectures across six conditions: controlled broadcast speech, fixed-grammar utterances, hyper-articulated Lombard speech, read speech from professional lipspeakers and non-professional speakers, and spontaneous multi-party video conversations. We find that visual-only performance deteriorates rapidly beyond broadcast domains, and audio-video fusion mainly benefits Lombard speech environments. Visual understanding degrades sharply at 90° profile views, with multimodal systems relying largely on acoustic fallback. Additionally, speaker articulation proves more critical than minor camera shifts, and LLM-based architectures suffer from poor out-of-domain generalization. Our work highlights a significant generalization gap in current AVSR research. To address this, we also introduce RoomReader-AV as a new benchmark for AVSR and release a unified data preprocessing pipeline to make comprehensive multi-condition evaluation accessible.