Beyond Structure: Revolutionising Materials Discovery via AI-Driven Synthesis Protocol-Property Relationships
Authors: Guillaume Lambard
Organizations: Data-driven materials design group, Center for Basic Research on Materials (CBRM) National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS), Namiki 1-1, Tsukuba, Ibaraki, 305-0044, Japan
Abstract
The current structure-centric paradigm in artificial intelligence (AI)-driven materials discovery, despite delivering thousands of candidate structures, is stalling at a critical barrier: the synthesizability gap. We argue that closing this gap demands a pivot to a synthesis-first paradigm in which executable synthesis protocols, not just atomic configurations, are treated as primary design variables. We outline a roadmap built on three pillars: (i) representing synthesis procedures as machine-readable protocols, (ii) deploying generative and inverse-design models to propose actionable reaction pathways and recipes, and (iii) integrating closed-loop optimisation to refine protocols against experimental realities and sustainability constraints. Framed in terms of the causal backbone P->X->y from protocol P to structure X and properties y, this perspective sets out methodological building blocks, standards needs and self-driving laboratory (SDL) integration strategies to accelerate reproducible, data-first materials discovery.
Artificial intelligence (AI) is accelerating materials prediction and design by enabling efficient exploration of chemical and structural spaces, with particular promise for novel materials discovery. However, novelty in materials discovery encompasses chemical plausibility, structural distinctiveness, property relevance and experimental realisability, making AI-driven novelty claims difficult to substantiate. We introduce a materials property hierarchy, from intrinsic, composition-determined properties to extrinsic, processing-dependent performance, to clarify deployment constraints and distinguish structural, physical and deployment novelty. This framework motivates an evidence-based view of multimodal materials data spanning chemical composition, microstructure, processing, and testing and characterisation, showing that current evidence remains concentrated in composition and idealised structure while heterogeneous, under-represented and weakly integrated modalities limit support for physical and deployment novelty. It also highlights the limitations of benchmarks based mainly on computational labels and proxy novelty criteria. Community-wide standards for data collection, modality alignment and evidence synthesis are needed to support multimodal data construction, process-aware multimodal modelling, feasibility-first generative modelling and deployment-aware benchmarking, so that generative and multimodal AI can design experimentally realisable materials with defensible scientific and practical novelty.
This thesis develops robust and efficient AI frameworks for accelerating crystalline materials discovery by addressing both major stages of the materials-design pipeline: crystal property prediction and crystal structure generation. Motivated by the high computational cost of Density Functional Theory (DFT) and the limited availability of labeled materials data, the thesis explores graph representation learning, pretraining, multimodal learning, and generative modeling for scalable materials design. For property prediction, the thesis first introduces CrysXPP, which learns transferable crystal representations through unsupervised graph autoencoding, reducing dependence on large property-labeled datasets. It then proposes CrysGNN, a large-scale self-supervised graph pretraining framework that captures atomic connectivity, chemical attributes, and global structural information and transfers this knowledge to downstream property predictors through knowledge distillation. CrysMMNet further enriches crystal representations by jointly modeling graph structure and textual descriptions, thereby incorporating both local chemical and global structural knowledge. For crystal generation, the thesis introduces TGDMat, a text-guided joint diffusion framework that jointly models lattice parameters, atomic types, and atomic coordinates while incorporating textual structural knowledge during denoising. This enables the generation of more valid and stable periodic materials while also supporting conditional generation from natural-language descriptions. Overall, the thesis establishes a unified AI-based framework for data-efficient property prediction and controllable crystal generation, demonstrating how graph learning, multimodal representations, and generative models can reduce computational cost and improve the scalability of materials
Wide access to advanced experimental methods in materials science has given rise to an abundance of procedural knowledge, which is scattered across decades of scientific literature and recorded in unstructured formats that are challenging to analyze systematically. In this work, we present LeMat-Synth Parser, a modular, open-source, and multi-modal extraction toolbox that utilizes large language models (LLMs) and vision language models (VLMs) to automatically structure synthesis protocols and performance metrics extracted from both text and figures of publications. Applying LeMat-Synth Parser to 81K open-access publications, we curate LeMat-Synth, an extensive dataset of 58K synthesis procedures and to our knowledge the largest and most diverse structured inorganic materials synthesis dataset to date, covering 35 synthesis methods and 16 material classes based on a domain-specific ontology. We validate extraction quality against annotations by domain experts and a scalable LLM-as-a-judge framework, and benchmark a suite of models to identify optimal configurations and characterize cross-model biases. To demonstrate the extensibility of LeMat-Synth Parser, we apply it to two distinct domains. First, we link synthesis protocols and catalyst identity to thermocatalytic performance across a corpus of ammonia-decomposition publications. Second, we cross-validate text- and figure-reported critical transition temperatures across 1,384 superconductivity papers, then use the validated pipeline to recover the critical transition temperature for every composition in a sample series. We release LeMat-Synth Parser and the LeMat-Synth dataset openly on GitHub and Hugging Face