When Preference Labels Fall Short: Aligning Diffusion Models from Real Data

Preference optimization has emerged as an efficient alternative to online reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) for aligning text-to-image diffusion models. However, existing methods largely reduce supervision to binary pairwise comparisons. This pairwise reduction is limiting when training data naturally contains multiple candidate images for the same prompt, and when continuous reward scores can provide richer information than a single winner-loser label. To address these limitations, we propose Diffusion LAIR, a reward-aware listwise preference optimization method for diffusion models. For each prompt, LAIR converts reward scores across a group of candidate images into centered advantage weights, then optimizes an advantage-weighted regression objective on the implicit reward, defined as the denoising-loss improvement of the current model over a fixed reference model, with a quadratic penalty that regularizes the magnitude of the implicit reward. The resulting objective uses all candidates simultaneously rather than selecting pairs, and remains conservative by explicitly controlling the magnitude of the implicit reward. The LAIR objective admits a bounded closed-form optimum in implicit-reward space, clarifying how the regularization strength controls the magnitude of the preference update. Experiments show that Diffusion LAIR outperforms strong preference optimization baselines on SD1.5 and SDXL across text-to-image generation, compositional generation, and image editing benchmarks.

Diffusion models have achieved impressive results in generative tasks such as text-to-image synthesis, yet they often struggle to fully align outputs with nuanced user intent and maintain consistent aesthetic quality. Existing preference-based training methods such as Diffusion Direct Preference Optimization help address these issues, but obtain their supervision targets from the forward process $q(\boldsymbol{x}_{t-1}\!\mid\!\boldsymbol{x}_t,\boldsymbol{x}_0)$ derived from terminal samples, which is not directly aligned with the model's actual backward denoising transitions at each step. In this work, we introduce Direct Diffusion Score Preference Optimization (DDSPO), which defines stepwise preference supervision directly over backward denoising transitions through a contrastive policy pair, rather than relying on forward-process approximations from terminal samples. We propose two practical instantiations of the contrastive policy pair: training separate winning and losing models on preference data, and inducing a contrastive policy pair without additional training by using a pretrained reference model conditioned on an original prompt and a semantically degraded variant, requiring neither reward modeling nor manual annotations. Empirical results show that contrastive-policy-pair supervision is more effective than forward-process-based supervision across text-image alignment and aesthetic-quality tasks. Our implementation is available at: https://dohyun-as.github.io/DDSPO

Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has been popular for aligning text-to-image (T2I) diffusion models with human preferences. As a mainstream branch of RLHF, Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) offers a computationally efficient alternative that avoids explicit reward modeling and has been widely adopted in diffusion alignment. However, existing preference-based methods for diffusion alignment still rely on reward-induced preference signals and typically assume that human preferences can be adequately modeled by the Bradley--Terry (BT) model, which may fail to capture the full complexity of human preferences. In this paper, we formulate diffusion alignment from a game-theoretic perspective. We propose Diffusion Nash Preference Optimization (Diff.-NPO), an intuitive general preference framework for diffusion alignment. Diff.-NPO encourages the current policy to play against itself to achieve self improvement and lead to a better alignment. Empirically, we demonstrate the effectiveness of Diff.-NPO on the text-to-image generation task via various metrics. Diff.-NPO consistently outperforms existing preference-based diffusion alignment methods.