Evaluating Speech Articulation Synthesis with Articulatory Phoneme Recognition
Authors: Vinicius Ribeiro, Yves Laprie
Organizations: Universit´e de Lorraine, CNRS, Inria, LORIA · CNRS · Inria · F-54000, Nancy, France
Abstract
Recent advances in machine learning and the availability of articulatory datasets allow vocal tract synthesis to be conditioned on phonetic sequences, a primary task of articulatory speech synthesis. However, quality assessment needs a better definition. Generally, ranking generative models is tricky due to subjectivity. However, articulatory synthesis has the additional difficulty of requiring specialized knowledge in vocal tract anatomy and acoustics. To address this problem, this paper proposes to evaluate speech articulation synthesis using phoneme recognition as a proxy. Our hypothesis is that phoneme recognition using articulatory features better captures nuances in phoneme production, such as correct places of articulation, which traditional metrics (e.g., point-wise distance metrics) do not. We train a neural network with acoustic and articulatory features extracted from a single-speaker RT-MRI dataset. Then, we compare the recognition performance when testing the model with different synthetic articulatory features. Our results show that our articulatory feature set is phonetically rich and helps exploring additional dimensions on speech articulation synthesis.
Real-time MRI makes it possible to observe vocal-tract articulation during speech, but mapping these articulatory patterns to phonetic and phonological categories remains challenging. We investigate whether PhonoQ, an audio-based model trained to recognize structured phonological features, provides useful information for audio--articulatory modeling. Specifically, we extract representations from PhonoQ's Conformer module, whose training is shaped by supervision for manner, place, voicing, and vowel features. Using articulatory contours with synchronized audio-derived features, we compare WavLM-large and HuBERT-large baselines with models that incorporate PhonoQ-derived representations. Across unseen-speech and unseen-subject settings, these features improve macro-F1 for phonological targets including manner, place, voicing, vowel height, and vowel backness, and also improve fine-grained 39-phoneme classification. In a contour-only inference setting, audio-derived teacher supervision yields modest but consistent gains over contour-only training, indicating that phonological information from synchronized audio can be partially transferred to articulatory models. Finally, posterior analyses show interpretable surface-sensitive patterns consistent with flapping-like /t/ realizations, /t/-/r/ retraction or affrication, and nasal place assimilation.
Abner Hernandez, Tomás Arias Vergara, Daiqi Liu +2
Localising artifacts in synthetic speech remains challenging, as most evaluation methods yield only global quality scores. This paper presents XSQ-AST, a framework that combines the SQ-AST speech quality model with WhisperX phoneme alignment and multiple saliency methods to produce temporally localised artifact diagnostics without model retraining. Saliency maps are projected onto continuous distributions via kernel density estimation and onto phoneme boundaries via phoneme-discretised saliency maps. A 40-participant listening test validated the framework across five perceptual dimensions. Attention Rollout, Attention Flow and an adapted GradCAM produced temporal distributions that correlated with listener highlights, with different methods best suited to different artifact types. An AUC-ROC analysis confirmed discrimination above chance.
Ben Heritage, Luca Resti, Mónica Villanueva Aylagas +3
The challenge associated with recognizing dysarthric speech primarily arises from pronounced acoustic variability attributed to impaired articulatory precision. Past research has demonstrated improved recognition through the use of hybrid DNN/HMM sequence discriminative training. This paper presents a comprehensive investigation of various combinations of acoustic features tailored to different Acoustic Models, offering suitable feature selections for each. The incorporation of Pitch features notably improved recognition performance, especially for sentence recognition tasks involving dysarthric speech. Through a systematic examination of the TORGO database, we have demonstrated the potential to enhance the performance of the state-of-the-art Factorized Time Delay Neural Network (F-TDNN) model for recognizing dysarthric speech. Our methods, implemented with the F-TDNN model, resulted in a 4.65% relative improvement in isolated word recognition and a 4.63% relative improvement in sentence recognition for dysarthric speech, compared to previous research. This improvement effectively compensates for speech variability, attributable to our deliberate selection of the number of overlapping frames between consecutive training example chunks.
Paban Sapkota, Hemant Kumar Kathania, Mikko Kurimo +2