Cross-Domain Generalization Limits of Vision Foundation Models in Facial Deepfake Detection
Authors: Ibrahim Delibasoglu
Organizations: Department of Software Engineering, Faculty of Computer and Information Sciences, Sakarya University, Esentepe, Sakarya, 54050 Türkiye.
Abstract
The rapid evolution of generative models has enabled the creation of hyper-realistic facial deepfakes, exposing a critical vulnerability in modern digital forensics: the inability of detectors to generalize to unseen manipulation techniques. Traditional networks suffer from representation collapse, overfitting to localized artifact fingerprints of specific training generators. This work investigates whether modern Vision Foundation Models can serve as generalizable, out-of-the-box feature extractors capable of tracking forensic anomalies across entirely unseen generative manifolds. We conduct a systematic cross-domain evaluation comparing three foundational learning paradigms: fully supervised macro-semantic features (RoPE-ViT), pure self-supervised geometric features (DINOv3), and multi-teacher agglomerative representations (NVIDIA C-RADIOv4-H). By deploying frozen backbones subjected to downstream linear probing, we map the performance limitations of these architectures on the challenging DF40 benchmark. Our empirical findings expose the intrinsic trade-offs between pre-training paradigms and parameter scale, proving that while foundation models retain high discriminative capabilities for entire face synthesis, localized face editing techniques expose fundamental boundaries in linear probe evaluation structures. Source code and model weights are available in http://github.com/mribrahim/deepfake
Pretrained self-supervised representations have emerged as a core component of current deepfake detection methods, yet it remains unclear which of their properties make real and fake media distinguishable. In this work, we uncover a surprisingly consistent phenomenon: across multiple pretrained models, datasets, and both image and video domains, fake samples systematically produce lower-magnitude representations than their real counterparts. Motivated by this finding, we formulate deepfake detection as an anomaly detection problem and show that simple statistics of feature magnitude achieve competitive performance with far more sophisticated deepfake detection methods. We further investigate the origin of this effect and demonstrate that reduced feature magnitude is primarily associated with semantic shifts introduced by fake content, while low-level generative fingerprints play a comparatively smaller role. Finally, we show that this discriminative signal strengthens as the size of the underlying foundation model grows, suggesting that advances in representation learning naturally translate into stronger zero-shot deepfake detectors.
Stefan Smeu, Dragos-Alexandru Boldisor, Elisabeta Oneata +1
The growing realism and accessibility of manipulated and generated faces threaten the trustworthiness of digital media. To detect such forgeries, deepfake detectors based on vision foundation models have shown promising performance, but they typically rely on a single pretrained representation and are prone to overfitting to particular training distributions. To improve generalization to unseen forgeries, we propose UCF-Net, an uncertainty-aware cascaded fusion network that harnesses CLIP's language-aligned semantic priors and DINO's self-supervised visual-structure priors. UCF-Net extracts hierarchical features across Transformer depths, uses layer-wise expert aggregation to adaptively combine each encoder's multi-level cues, and performs weighted fusion of the resulting representations based on entropy-derived uncertainty. We further consolidate public deepfake datasets into a unified benchmark of approximately 4M images and construct a separate cross-generator evaluation set with over 8K face images from eight recent generators. On the unified benchmark, UCF-Net achieves the best mean AUC among the evaluated methods in both in-domain and cross-domain evaluations. On the cross-generator set, it adapts effectively with limited target-domain data, although zero-shot transfer remains challenging.
Deepfakes are artificially generated images, audio, or videos that threaten privacy, security, and information integrity. Detecting such content is crucial for countering disinformation, as the latest models generate highly realistic content. While spatial- or frequency-based approaches achieve good detection rates on Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs)-based generated deepfakes, they often struggle with recent diffusion model-generated images. In particular, existing approaches rarely exploit complementary multi-domain representations or systematically evaluate cross-generator robustness. To address these challenges, we propose a multi-domain deepfake detection framework called SGFF-Net (Spatial-Gradient-Frequency Fusion Network) that integrates spatial, gradient, and DWT (Discrete Wavelet Transform)-based frequency representations within a dual residual learning architecture. Experimental results show that the SGFF-Net achieves 98.95% accuracy in intra-dataset evaluation and improves performance in both cross-model (70.46%) and cross-paradigm (69.94%) settings. Incorporating multi-source training and data augmentation further enhances robustness, increasing accuracy from 70.46% to 79.80% in cross-model evaluation, from 69% to 78% in cross-paradigm evaluation, and from 61.50% to 75.80% on real-world data. Unlike single-domain detectors, the SGFF-Net learns complementary forensic cues across spatial, gradient, and wavelet-frequency domains, resulting in greater robustness under cross-generator and cross-paradigm evaluation. The results further show that combining multi-domain representations with data diversity and augmentation substantially improves generalization, providing practical insights for developing more reliable deepfake detection systems.