Not All Tokens Matter Equally: Dynamic In-context Vector Distillation with Decisive-Token Supervision for Long-form Medical Report Generation
Authors: Ning Wu, Rui Liu, Xinkun Lin, Weixing Chen, Jinxi Xiang, Tao Wei, Lina Yao, Mingjie Li
Abstract
Distilling demonstration effects into hidden-space interventions offers a lightweight alternative to full finetuning. However, existing multimodal variants are mostly evaluated on short-form tasks, where outputs end after a few tokens. Extending these methods to long-form generation exposes a fundamental yet underexamined limitation: token-level distillation implicitly treats all output tokens as equally informative, but long-form outputs are dominated by high-frequency template and grammatical tokens, while the tokens that actually determine output quality are sparsely distributed. In medical report generation (MRG), two such decisive tokens stand out: pathology-related tokens that determine diagnostic content, and the end-of-sequence (EOS) event that determines termination. Both receive insufficient supervision under uniform cross-entropy, and autoregressive decoding further compounds the problem by drifting away from teacher-forced trajectories. We propose DIVE, a frozen-backbone distillation framework that addresses long-form report generation through two complementary mechanisms matched to these failures. Decisive-token supervision restores supervision balance by upweighting the cross-entropy contribution of pathology-related tokens and the EOS event, ensuring that content fidelity and termination are learned during training rather than imposed at decoding time. State-conditioned dynamic steering replaces fixed open-loop residuals with hidden-state-dependent adapters, allowing the injected signal to adapt as decoding drifts. Experiments on MIMIC-CXR and CheXpert Plus with two medical VLM backbones show that DIVE consistently ranks among the strongest methods across lexical and clinical-proxy metrics. Our method achieves the best BLEU-4, ROUGE-L, and RadGraph F1 in all dataset--backbone settings, while remaining competitive on coarse label-level CheXbert F1.
Training vision-language models (VLMs) for medical report generation is often hindered by the scarcity of high-quality annotated data. This work evaluates the use of a weighted loss function to improve data efficiency. Compared to standard cross-entropy loss, which treats all token prediction errors equally, the reweighted loss shifts the focus to semantically salient tokens with outsized clinical importance. In experiments on ophthalmological report generation, we show that this simple method improves efficiency across multiple data scales, achieving similar report quality with up to ten times less training data.
Alexander Weers, Daniel Rueckert, Martin J. Menten
Diffusion language models, which generate text by denoising a token canvas bidirectionally instead of emitting tokens left to right, have become competitive with autoregressive (AR) generation. Medical foundation models, however, remain almost entirely autoregressive. We adapt a mixture-of-experts diffusion language model, DiffusionGemma-26B, and benchmark it against its same-size AR sibling Gemma-4-26B under an identical LoRA recipe on medical visual question answering datasets, scored by a verbosity-robust LLM judge. Diffusion matches or exceeds AR on all of them, and the finetuned model (3.8B active) is competitive with frontier vision-language models; its decoding is also 3.5-4.4x faster. Beyond this parity, the diffusion model offers a drafting capability AR lacks: any-order infill. Because the canvas is denoised bidirectionally, a radiologist can fix report fragments and have the model fill the text between them, an operation inherent to diffusion but not to autoregression, which is subpar at it. This suits real reports, which are often terse or inconsistent across clinicians and institutions.
Max Van Puyvelde, Halil Ibrahim Gulluk, Wim Van Criekinge +1
Reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards has rapidly advanced reasoning in vision--language models. However, for chest X-ray report generation, the standard rewards (i.e. exact-match accuracy and step-level processes) are incompatible because the reports consist of unordered and orthogonal findings, rather than a causal reasoning chain. We address this gap with a set-based view: each report is split into sentences and embedded by a frozen sentence transformer, yielding unordered embedding sets. We propose the use of set-to-set distances between generated and reference embeddings as continuous, permutation-invariant rewards. Across two datasets and three vision--language models (Qwen3-VL-2B/4B, Gemma3-4B), post-training with set-to-set distance based rewards via GRPO consistently outperforms supervised fine-tuning and exact-match GRPO on all headline metrics (BERTScore, RadGraph F1 and CheXbert F1 by average %6.80, %7.82 and %4.45 relative improvements respectively). The same set distances also enable test-time best-of-N selection: scoring candidates by their distance to training-report embeddings outperforms random selection on our trained models as well as three closed-source LLMs (Mistral-Small, Gemini-2.5 Flash-Lite, GPT-4o-mini) with on average %16.4 relative improvement on BERTScore. Used as a streaming signal, they support a more efficient form of test-time scaling: pruning low-scoring candidates mid-generation reduces generated tokens by over 50% while preserving the Findings quality of full best-of-N selection. Together these results establish set-distance rewards as a unified signal for both post-training and test-time scaling in chest X-ray report generation. Our code is publicly \href{https://anonymous.4open.science/r/Set-Distance-Rewards-CXR-BFDA}{available}.
Halil Ibrahim Gulluk, Max Van Puyvelde, Wim Van Criekinge +1