cs.ROMay 29, 2026

Per-Group Error, Not Total MSE: Fine-Tuning Vision-Language-Action Models for 11-DoF Mobile Manipulation

Authors: Pau Montagut BofiMario García BlascoTessa PulliMarkus Vincze

Organizations: Vision for Robotics Lab (V4R), TU Wien, Vienna, Austria

Abstract

Fine-tuning Vision-Language-Action (VLA) models for mobile manipulators with heterogeneous joint spaces can produce a counterintuitive result: the checkpoint with the lowest aggregate MSE is not the one that performs best on the real robot. We argue this is a predictable consequence of collapsing heterogeneous joint groups (arm, gripper, head, wheeled base) into a single metric, where easy-to-predict joints can mask joints that still fail. We fine-tune SmolVLA (450M, action-expert only) on the 11-DoF Toyota HSR and compare it against π0.5π_{0.5} (3.3B), a stronger pretrained baseline. Per-group analysis exposes two patterns: in SmolVLA, the mobile base converges slowest and limits overall performance. In expert-only fine-tuning of π0.5π_{0.5} (training only the action head, backbone frozen), total MSE drops below the baseline but arm accuracy degrades. On 60 real-robot trials (20 per model), π0.5π_{0.5} 80k (4.0/4) significantly outperforms both fine-tuned variants (expert-only 3k: 3.75/4; HSR-SmolVLA: 3.5/4; Mann-Whitney p0.010p \leq 0.010), despite expert-only 3k having the lowest total MSE. This separation is most consistent with the offline arm-group error, not total MSE or base-group error. We conclude that per-group error is a more reliable signal than total MSE for checkpoint selection on robots with heterogeneous action spaces. Code: https://github.com/paumontagut/per-group-mse-vla

Explore similar work

Jul 9, 2026cs.RO

FabriVLA: A Lightweight Vision-Language-Action Model for Precise Multi-Task Manipulation

We present FabriVLA, a lightweight Vision-Language-Action model for Precise Multi-Task Manipulation. FabriVLA combines an InternVL3.5 vision-language backbone with a flow-matching action head featuring gated self-attention across action tokens and shallow VLM layer fusion for enriched spatial context. The model is trained via single stage joint optimization from a pretrained VLM and randomly initialized action head. On the Meta-World MT50 benchmark spanning 50 diverse manipulation tasks, FabriVLA achieves a tier-average success rate of 90.0%, demonstrating that a compact VLA built on a 1B scale VLM can achieve strong performance without relying on multi billion parameter VLA backbones.
Shiyuan Yang, Borong Zhang, Jizheng Zhang +5
Dec 5, 2025cs.RO

HiMoE-VLA: Hierarchical Mixture-of-Experts for Generalist Vision-Language-Action Policies

Generalist vision--language--action (VLA) policies are typically trained on heterogeneous mixtures of robot demonstrations spanning diverse embodiments, action spaces, and observation configurations. Modeling such heterogeneity with a shared dense action module can induce negative transfer, particularly when action spaces or visual observations differ across data sources. We address this issue with HiMoE-VLA, a VLA framework built around a Hierarchical Mixture-of-Experts (HiMoE) action module. HiMoE uses Action-Space MoE layers at the input/output boundaries to specialize computation for distinct action spaces, Heterogeneity-Balancing MoE layers in neighboring layers to provide balanced capacity for residual variation in observations, scenes, and embodiments, and dense Transformer blocks in the middle to integrate shared representations. Two auxiliary objectives further guide this hierarchy: a contrastive Action-Space Regularization objective for boundary specialization and a load-balancing objective for stable expert utilization. HiMoE-VLA reaches 3.98 on CALVIN, 98.0% on LIBERO, and 75.0% and 63.7% average success on real xArm7 and ALOHA tasks; under controlled heterogeneous co-training, it turns the negative transfer observed in strong baselines into positive transfer. The code and models are publicly available at https://github.com/ZhiyingDu/HiMoE-VLA.
Zhiying Du, Bei Liu, Yaobo Liang +7
May 26, 2026cs.RO

FineVLA: Fine-Grained Instruction Alignment for Steerable Vision-Language-Action Policies

Vision-Language-Action (VLA) models are increasingly expected to not only complete robot tasks, but also follow human instructions about how those tasks should be executed. However, existing robot datasets usually pair trajectories with coarse goal-level language, leaving execution-critical details such as active arm, approach direction, and contact region unspecified. This limits steerable policy learning and robotic video understanding. We introduce FineVLA, an open framework for action-aligned fine-grained VLA supervision. The framework includes: (1) a data construction tool that unifies 972,247 trajectories across 85K tasks from 10 open-source robot datasets and builds FineVLA-Data, a human-verified dataset of 47,159 fine-grained trajectories; (2) a held-out benchmark with 500 videos, 11,631 atomic facts, and 1,030 VQA questions; (3) a robotics-specialized VLM annotator for scalable fine-grained annotation; and (4) a steerable VLA policy trained with controlled mixtures of fine-grained and raw goal-level instructions. Our experiments yield three findings. First, fine-grained supervision does not sacrifice goal-level success: FG-only improves over Raw-only by +1.4 to +8.1 success-rate points across settings. Second, fine-grained and raw instructions are complementary, following a consistent inverted-U trend peaking at FG:Raw = 1:2 to 1:1. The best mixed setting reaches 86.8%/82.5% in RoboTwin simulation and 62.7/100 in real-world dual-arm manipulation (vs. 49.9 Raw-only). Third, fine-grained supervision improves steerable control: the largest real-world gains appear on pose (+23), color (+18), and approach direction (+18)--factors where goal-level instructions provide no guidance. Overall, fine-grained language should augment goal-level instructions: specifying how to execute alongside what to achieve. Project page: https://finevla.xlang.ai/
Xintong Hu, Xuhong Huang, Jinyu Zhang +11