Exploring the Scale and Diversity of Speech Anti-spoofing Datasets: Experiments and Analysis
Authors: Zhuolin Yi, Jun Xue, Yanzhen Ren, Yihuan Huang, Yi Chai, Daixian Li, Guanxiang Feng, Jiajun Liu
Organizations: School of Cyber Science and Engineering, Wuhan University, China
Abstract
The scale of speech anti-spoofing datasets has grown exponentially over the past decade, driven by the assumption that larger data leads to better performance. However, it remains unclear whether indiscriminate scaling commensurately improves model generalization. This study challenges the "scale-first" paradigm by decoupling the impacts of training data scale versus diversity. Through experiments on representative datasets, we report two key findings: (1) Larger is not always better. Expanding data scale excessively under fixed generation methods yields negligible returns and may even degrade cross-domain generalization due to overfitting.(2) Diversity outweighs scale. A smaller composite training set featuring diverse attacks significantly outperforms larger-scale datasets with limited diversity in cross-dataset evaluations. We conclude that future dataset construction should prioritize the diversity of generation methods over scale to effectively enhance model generalization.
Recent advances in speech generation have significantly improved the naturalness of synthetic speech, making spoofing detection increasingly challenging. A key limitation of current anti-spoofing systems is their limited robustness to unseen synthesis methods. In this work, we transform a self-supervised speech representation model into a Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) architecture to improve generalization. Feed-forward blocks in selected encoder layers are replaced by multiple expert networks controlled by a layer-wise gating mechanism, allowing experts to capture complementary acoustic patterns while preserving the representations learned during self-supervised pretraining. We further analyze the architectural choices affecting the performance of this MoE conversion and investigate the activation behavior of the experts. The proposed approach is evaluated on 14 spoofing datasets and reduces the macro EER from 5.46% to 4.81%, corresponding to 11.9% relative improvement over the baseline.
Claims about the robustness and fairness of deepfake speech detectors are only as credible as the datasets used to train and evaluate those systems. We present a dataset-level audit of the deepfake speech landscape. We compile and analyze 39 deepfake speech datasets, examining key attributes including accessibility, documentation, demographic and language coverage, dataset scale, and the underlying bona fide speech sources. Our audit reveals two important takeaways. Firstly, fairness assessment is largely infeasible because most datasets lack demographic metadata, and only a few contain gender or language labels. This prevents any meaningful subgroup analysis and leaves other demographic attributes unaddressed. Secondly, we identify substantial overlap in underlying bona fide source corpora across datasets, which can undermine cross-dataset evaluation and lead to overstated generalization claims.
Recent neural audio codec-based speech generation (CodecFake) produces highly realistic audio, posing a challenge to existing deepfake countermeasure models. While using codec resynthesized speech (CoRS) as proxy data improves performance, it often suffers from limited generalization. We propose Domain-Shift Feature Augmentation (DSFA), which simulates "in-the-wild" variations by transforming deterministic feature statistics into stochastic distributions during fine-tuning. To evaluate generalization, we further introduce Codec-based Speech Generation Extension Evaluation (CoSG ExtEval) dataset, a more challenging extension of the CoSG Eval (from CodecFake+) dataset, featuring 40 unseen generative models and long-form audio. Experimental results demonstrate that combining a post-trained SSL backbone with DSFA effectively narrows the proxy-to-wild domain gap. This approach achieves state-of-the-art performance across diverse CodecFake attacks in both CoSG Eval and CoSG ExtEval.