Active Flow Expansion for Out-of-Distribution Discovery: from Theory to Molecules
Authors: Riccardo De Santi, Bruce Lee, Cristian Perez Jensen, Kimon Protopapas, Sophia Tang, Cheng-Hao Liu, Pranam Chatterjee, Yisong Yue, +1 more
Abstract
Standard flow and diffusion pre-training matches the distribution of available data (e.g., molecules), which often covers only a small fraction of the valid design space. In generative discovery, however, one aims to sample valid new-to-nature designs, assigned negligible probability under, and thus inaccessible to, standard models fitted to the observed data. To overcome this limitation, we depart from data distribution matching and view a generative model through its generable set: the region it covers with non-negligible probability. This allows to introduce a new learning principle for out-of-distribution flow modeling: enlarging a model's generable set to increase coverage of the valid design space. We propose Active Flow Expansion (ActFlow), a continued pre-training method that employs verifier feedback to expand a pre-trained model over new valid regions by iteratively adapting to synthetic data generated through active exploration in the learned flow representation. Theoretically, we establish to our knowledge first-of-their-kind statistical learning guarantees for out-of-distribution flow modeling, analyzing generable set expansion as a local-to-global reachability process over a learned representation. Empirically, we assess ActFlow with suitable out-of-distribution generative modeling metrics across small organic molecules, mid-sized drug-like molecules, therapeutic peptides, and protein sequence design tasks. Results show that ActFlow expands valid coverage far beyond the region modeled by the initial pre-trained model, significantly outperforming widely adopted synthetic flow pre-training methods.
Although generative models hold promise for discovering molecules with optimized desired properties, they often fail to suggest synthesizable molecules that improve upon the properties of the structures represented in the training distribution. We find that this limitation arises not only from the molecule generation process itself, but also from the poor generalization capabilities of molecular property predictors. We address this challenge by creating a closed-loop molecule generation pipeline with iterative retraining on new quantum chemical simulation data. Compared against static, single-pass generative modeling approaches, only our closed-loop iterative workflow generates molecules with properties extending beyond the training distribution (up to 0.44 standard deviations beyond the original range) and achieves a 79% improvement in out-of-distribution molecule classification accuracy. Furthermore, by conditioning molecular generation on thermodynamic stability data obtained during the iterative loop, the proportion of stable and hence potentially synthesizable molecules generated is 3.5x higher than the next-best model.
The scalability of pool-based active learning is limited by the computational cost of evaluating large unlabeled datasets, a challenge that is particularly acute in virtual screening for drug discovery. While active learning strategies such as Bayesian Active Learning by Disagreement (BALD) prioritize informative samples, it remains computationally intensive when scaled to libraries containing billions samples. In this work, we introduce BALD-GFlowNet, a generative active learning framework that circumvents this issue. Our method leverages Generative Flow Networks (GFlowNets) to directly sample objects in proportion to the BALD reward. By replacing traditional pool-based acquisition with generative sampling, BALD-GFlowNet achieves scalability that is independent of the size of the unlabeled pool. In our virtual screening experiment, we show that BALD-GFlowNet achieves a performance comparable to that of standard BALD baseline while generating more structurally diverse molecules, offering a promising direction for efficient and scalable molecular discovery.
Adapting generative foundation models, in particular diffusion and flow models, to optimize given reward functions (e.g., binding affinity) while satisfying constraints (e.g., molecular synthesizability) is fundamental for their adoption in real-world scientific discovery applications such as molecular design or protein engineering. While recent works have introduced scalable methods for reward-guided fine-tuning of such models via reinforcement learning and control schemes, it remains an open problem how to algorithmically trade-off reward maximization and constraint satisfaction in a reliable and predictable manner. Motivated by this challenge, we first present a rigorous framework for Constrained Generative Optimization, which brings an optimization viewpoint to the introduced adaptation problem and retrieves the relevant task of constrained generation as a sub-case. Then, we introduce Constrained Flow Optimization (CFO), an algorithm that automatically and provably balances reward maximization and constraint satisfaction by reducing the original problem to sequential fine-tuning via established, scalable methods. We provide convergence guarantees for constrained generative optimization and constrained generation via CFO. Ultimately, we present an experimental evaluation of CFO on both synthetic, yet illustrative, settings, and a molecular design task. Across these evaluations, CFO achieves consistent increases in reward while ensuring high constraint satisfaction, showcasing its practical utility for constrained generative optimization.
Sven Gutjahr, Riccardo De Santi, Luca Schaufelberger +2