Benchmarking Neural Speech Compression from a Rate-Distortion Perspective
Authors: Jun Xu, Zhengxue Cheng, Fengxi Zhang, Yuhan Liu, Li Song, Wenjun Zhang
Organizations: School of Information Science and Electronic Engineering, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, China
Abstract
Learning-based speech compression has achieved promising low-bitrate performance, but many neural speech codecs still describe quantized latents with preset-rate discrete symbols or apply entropy coding only after symbol generation. Such designs decouple representation learning from probability modeling, limiting their ability to exploit the non-uniform usage and temporal dependencies of learned speech latents. In this paper, we benchmark neural speech compression from a rate--distortion perspective and further investigate entropy-constrained coding for low-bitrate speech compression. We first formulate a unified learning-based speech coding pipeline and provide a benchmark-style analysis of recent neural speech codecs, showing that explicit probability modeling remains underexplored in learned speech compression. We then propose ECC, an Entropy-Constrained Codec that combines scalar quantization with a learned entropy model. ECC integrates hyperprior-based side information, channel-wise context modeling, latent residual prediction, and lightweight temporal modeling to estimate latent likelihoods for rate estimation during training and arithmetic coding during inference. To further improve low-bitrate efficiency, ECC introduces entropy skip, which omits highly predictable residual symbols using decoder-available scale estimates without transmitting additional skip masks. Extensive experiments show that ECC achieves a favorable low-bitrate rate--distortion trade-off over conventional and neural codec baselines, reducing BD-rate by 39.9% on ViSQOL and 76.3% on PESQ on average over two widely-used test sets. Ablation and diagnostic studies further validate the effectiveness of entropy modeling. Project Page: https://avery-xu.github.io/ECC-demo/
Neural speech codecs have become the discrete interface between raw audio and speech language models, yet they remain optimized primarily for acoustic reconstruction fidelity, which leaves emotion-relevant cues vulnerable to being discarded during quantization, limiting the affective capacity of downstream models. We trace this degradation to two mechanisms: reconstruction-driven bit allocation under limited bitrate and cross-stream leakage in concatenation-based codecs, where acoustic gradients can overwrite nominally emotion-reserved dimensions. We propose AffectCodec, an emotion-preserving neural speech codec built on Block-Diagonal Residual Finite Scalar Quantization (BD-RFSQ). By imposing block-diagonal input and output projections over emotion and acoustic subspaces, BD-RFSQ transforms bit allocation from implicit and loss-driven to explicit and structurally guaranteed, while still preserving a flat token interface for downstream speech language models. AffectCodec further combines this structurally constrained quantizer with multi-granularity emotion conditioning and multi-rate training, enabling robust affect preservation at low bitrates. Experiments across multiple emotional speech benchmarks show that AffectCodec substantially improves emotion preservation, especially in the low-bitrate regime, while maintaining competitive acoustic quality and intelligibility. These results suggest that structurally protected quantization is an effective principle for preserving emotion-relevant information and may provide a general route toward attribute-aware neural speech compression.
In bandwidth-constrained communication such as satellite and underwater channels, speech must often be transmitted at ultra-low bitrates where intelligibility is the primary objective. At such extreme compression levels, codecs trained with acoustic reconstruction losses tend to allocate bits to perceptual detail, leading to substantial degradation in word error rate (WER). This paper proposes ClariCodec, a neural speech codec operating at 300 bit per second (bps) that reformulates quantisation as a stochastic policy, enabling reinforcement learning (RL)-based optimisation of intelligibility. Specifically, the encoder is fine-tuned using WER-driven rewards while the acoustic reconstruction pipeline remains frozen. Even without RL, ClariCodec achieves 4.64% WER on the LibriSpeech test-clean set at 300 bps, already competitive with codecs operating at higher bitrates. Further RL fine-tuning reduces WER to 3.55% on test-clean and 10.4% on test-other, corresponding to a 23% relative reduction while preserving perceptual quality.
In bandwidth-constrained communication such as satellite and underwater channels, speech must often be transmitted at ultra-low bitrates where intelligibility is the primary objective. At such extreme compression levels, codecs trained with acoustic reconstruction losses tend to allocate bits to perceptual detail, leading to substantial degradation in word error rate (WER). This paper proposes ClariCodec, a neural speech codec operating at 200 bit per second (bps) that reformulates quantisation as a stochastic policy, enabling reinforcement learning (RL)-based optimisation of intelligibility. Specifically, the encoder is fine-tuned using WER-driven rewards while the acoustic reconstruction pipeline remains frozen. Even without RL, ClariCodec achieves 3.68% WER on the LibriSpeech test-clean set at 200 bps, already competitive with codecs operating at higher bitrates. Further RL fine-tuning reduces WER to 3.20% on test-clean and 8.93% on test-other, corresponding to a 13% relative reduction while preserving perceptual quality.