A Controlled Study of Decoding-Time Truthfulness Methods on Instruction-Tuned LLMs

Ao Sun

cs.CLJun 10, 2026

A Controlled Study of Decoding-Time Truthfulness Methods on Instruction-Tuned LLMs

Authors: Ao Sun

Abstract

Decoding-time truthfulness methods -- layer-contrast decoding, inference-time intervention, and learned logit adapters -- have demonstrated 10-30 point gains on TruthfulQA when applied to base language models. However, modern instruction-tuned LLMs already achieve substantially higher baselines (61-76%), raising the question of whether these methods remain effective in practice. We design a six-control evaluation framework -- out-of-distribution training, multi-judge validation, simple decoding baselines, confound controls, bootstrap confidence intervals, and seed variance -- and apply it across 5 models (1B-70B), 3 benchmarks, and 15 methods. We find that previously reported gains shrink substantially under strict controls: on the full TruthfulQA benchmark (N=817), no token-level method achieves statistically significant improvement, and the best learned adapter scores -2.0 points below greedy (p=.23). We identify five evaluation sensitivities -- contamination, judge choice, missing baselines, confounds, and statistical noise -- that individually or jointly account for these discrepancies. Cross-benchmark validation on HaluEval QA and TriviaQA confirms that these patterns extend beyond TruthfulQA. Deliberative prompting methods (chain-of-thought, self-critique) appear more robust in the evaluated regime, with CoT achieving +5.6-19pp across benchmarks as a training-free, single-pass method. We release a seven-point evaluation checklist and discuss implications for future truthfulness research.

Explore similar work

Sep 22, 2025cs.CL

Training-free Truthfulness Detection via Sparse MLP Value Vectors

Large language models (LLMs) are prone to generating factually incorrect content, motivating methods for assessing truthfulness from internal model signals. While supervised probing approaches can be effective, they require labeled data and classifier training. Recent training-free methods avoid parameter optimization but rely on coarse activation statistics that provide limited insight into how truthfulness-related signals arise within the model. We present a training-free approach that operates at the level of individual multi-layer perceptron (MLP) value vectors. Through a systematic analysis, we find that although most value vectors show no meaningful signal, a sparse subset exhibits stable and directionally consistent correlations with content truthfulness. Leveraging this observation, we propose \textbf{TruthV}, a simple inference method that aggregates preferences expressed by these value vectors. TruthV requires only a small support set to identify relevant vectors and introduces no additional model parameters or classifier weights. We evaluate TruthV across model scales from 2B to 13B and multiple benchmarks, including question answering, natural language understanding, and hallucination evaluation. TruthV consistently outperforms existing training-free baselines, demonstrating that truthfulness-related variation in LLMs is captured in a sparse and structured manner at the level of MLP value vectors.

Runheng Liu, Heyan Huang, Xingchen Xiao +2

Truth Multilayer Perceptrons

Ask PDF

May 30, 2026cs.LG

Hallucination Is Linearly Decodable from Mid-Layer Hidden States in Quantized LLMs

We investigate whether open-source LLMs encode a linearly separable truthfulness signal in their hidden states, and at which network depth this signal is strongest. Across three

7

B--

8

B instruction-tuned models (Llama-3.1-8B, Mistral-7B, Qwen2.5-7B) loaded in

4

-bit NF4 quantization, we extract per-layer hidden states on four hallucination benchmarks (TruthfulQA, HaluEval-QA, FEVER, and a controlled synthetic set) and compare four detection approaches: linear and MLP probes, INSIDE EigenScore, self-consistency, and attention entropy. A linear probe on a single mid-network layer achieves

0.904

1.000

AUROC on held-out splits, while sampling-based detectors do not exceed

0.541

AUROC under the same protocol. The truthfulness signal is approximately linear: MLP probes rarely surpass linear probes by more than

0.01

AUROC. Peak probing layers fall in a consistent band across model families on natural-language benchmarks -- blocks~

13

18

of~

32

for Llama and Mistral, and blocks~

19

25

of~

28

for Qwen. First-block attention entropy provides a complementary signal in knowledge-grounded settings (

0.866

0.941

AUROC on HaluEval-QA) at no additional inference cost. The low discriminability of sampling methods under this protocol reflects a structural mismatch between paired-label evaluation and the information these methods access, rather than an inherent limitation of those methods. Code and data are released for full reproducibility on a single

8

,GB GPU.

Aizierjiang Aiersilan

Hidden States Large Language Model Quantization Truth Hallucinations

Ask PDF

Jul 25, 2026cs.CL

Attention-Guided Layer Selection for Contrastive Decoding in Large Language Models

Contrastive decoding methods such as DoLa improve the factuality of Large Language Models (LLMs) by contrasting the output distributions of mature and premature layers. However, DoLa's dynamic layer selection relies solely on divergences in output vocabulary distributions. In this work, we propose three attention-guided strategies: Attention-JSD, Attention-Entropy-Max, and Attention-Entropy-Min, which leverage structural information carried by internal self-attention mechanisms as a signal for layer selection. Experimental results on TruthfulQA demonstrate that our strategies, particularly Attention-JSD and Attention-Entropy-Min, consistently outperform the original DoLa. We observe significant gains on multi-answer metrics (MC2 and MC3), suggesting that attention distributions can provide a more sensitive signal for resolving factual knowledge than output vocabulary distributions.

Yusuke Sakai, Natthawut Kertkeidkachorn, Kiyoaki Shirai

Contrastive Decoding Attention-Guided Transunet

Ask PDF