Which Speech Representation Better Matches Text-Native Reasoning? A Study of Speech-Text Alignment on Frame Rate and Representation
Authors: Zhen Ye, Xu Tan, Yiming Li, Guangyan Zhang, Chimin Chan, Haohe Liu, Zhengxi Liu, Hongzhan Lin, +5 more
Abstract
Spoken dialogue models typically start from text LLM backbones, yet reasoning often degrades when conditioning on speech instead of text. We attribute part of this modality gap to a temporal-granularity mismatch: speech tokens are temporally redundant and far longer than text under matched semantics, diluting per-token semantic density and weakening text-native reasoning dynamics. We study speech token design as a representation selection problem and sweep frame rates under a frozen LLM backbone with a fixed information rate. To make low frame rates feasible, we introduce factorized FSQ and a lightweight non-autoregressive audio LM head, scaling capacity to nearly 300,bits/frame without sacrificing efficient prediction. With the bottleneck removed, we sweep frame rates (50→2.08,Hz) and alignment depth, and observe a consistent best regime for speech QA at 4.17,Hz with intermediate-layer representation alignment.
Spoken language models (SLMs) extend LLMs to speech input and output, but existing systems use fixed frame rates (e.g., 25 or 12.5 Hz), overlooking speech's time-varying information density and limiting inference-time quality-speed tradeoffs. Recent dynamic-frame-rate audio tokenizers enable very low average frame rates and controllability, yet had not been applied to SLMs. We introduce FlexiSLM, the first SLM with dynamic, controllable frame rates, using pretrained FlexiCodec for dynamic speech output tokens. It integrates this representation into a multi-task speech-to-speech SLM, extends it with input-side frame compression, and adds direct frame-rate conditioning for accurate control during inference. FlexiSLM outperforms fixed-frame-rate 7B models, including Qwen2.5-Omni and Kimi-Audio, at 12.5 and 6.25 Hz; it can be steered down to 4.0 Hz, and at 6.25 Hz roughly halves inference time relative to 12.5 Hz while retaining strong speech-to-speech quality. Audio samples: https://flexislm.github.io; code and data: https://github.com/AmphionTeam/FlexiSLM.
Strong speech-to-text (S2T) LLMs already provide robust speech perception and text reasoning, but adding speech-to-speech (S2S) output is challenging: fine-tuning the backbone can degrade the original S2T performance, while attaching a downstream talker reintroduces a serial text-to-speech bottleneck. We present PRIME-Speech, a frozen-backbone S2S conversion framework that trains only speech-generation modules. PRIME-Speech synchronizes a causal audio post-decoder with intermediate hidden states of the frozen backbone, so codec tokens are generated from the model's evolving reasoning trajectory rather than from completed text chunks. The post-decoder uses mixed hidden-state, text, and audio-history conditioning, and a training-time packing strategy with turn-level audio KV-cache and position reset stabilizes multi-turn spoken interaction without additional multi-turn S2S training data. Multi-token prediction further reduces the effective codec prediction rate and improves first-audio latency without modifying the reasoning path. Across speech translation, spoken QA, speech understanding, and multi-turn dialogue, PRIME-Speech preserves the S2T behavior of the frozen backbone while producing accurate, low-WER spoken responses.
Scaling Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) to long-form speech is bottlenecked by the explosive growth of input tokens. Existing speech-language models project high-frame-rate acoustic features directly into the LLM input space, making long-context processing computationally prohibitive. Unlike images or videos, speech lacks spatial redundancy, making extreme token compression particularly challenging. To address this limitation, we propose FastSLM, a token-efficient architecture featuring the Hierarchical Temporal Abstractor (HTA), which progressively distills acoustic features across multiple temporal scales. HTA achieves an extreme compression rate of 1.67 tokens per second (97% reduction) while preserving essential linguistic information for downstream speech-language understanding. Experimental results demonstrate that FastSLM achieves competitive performance across diverse speech-language tasks while requiring substantially fewer speech tokens and FLOPs than existing speech-language models. The source code and model checkpoints are available at https://github.com/Lee-junseok1025/FastSLM.