Order in Desbordante: Techniques for Efficient Implementation of Order Dependency Discovery Algorithms

Inclusion dependency is a relation between attributes of tables that indicates possible Primary Key-Foreign Key references. Automatic discovery of inclusion dependencies is a relevant problem for both academic and industrial communities. The core concern for this problem is the efficiency of discovery process, since it is a computationally expensive task. However, existing studies only address the algorithmic side, while leaving out the implementation aspect. At the same time, engineering details are at least as important as the algorithmic ones for achieving good performance. In this paper, we describe techniques for efficient implementation of two algorithms for discovery of inclusion dependencies - Spider and Faida. The first one is a classic algorithm whose ideas lie in the foundation of many other inclusion dependency discovery algorithms. We propose an efficient parallelization technique, which greatly speeds up the algorithm while simultaneously reducing its memory consumption. The second one is the state-of-the-art approximate algorithm, which we approach by applying four types of optimizations: data buffering, SIMD-enabled execution, careful hash-table selection and parallelization. In order to experimentally evaluate our techniques, we have implemented these algorithms in Desbordante - an open-source science-intensive data profiler written in C++. For Spider, we have evaluated several different options, and in case of Faida we have demonstrated that all our optimization techniques yield results. We also compared our implementations with Metanome - a Java-based data profiler. Overall, we report up to 5x improvement in terms of run time reduction for Spider and up to 8x for Faida.

Matching dependency is a generalization of the functional dependency concept, which allows users to apply custom similarity functions for matching individual attributes. Matching dependencies have a wide range of applications for solving various data quality problems, such as entity resolution, data deduplication, data integration, schema matching, and many more. However, their discovery is a very computationally intensive problem, which limits their practical application. In this paper, we describe a number of optimization techniques for HyMD - currently the state-of-the-art algorithm for the discovery of matching dependencies. These optimizations belong to both technical and scientific domains. The most important of them are: 1) a new sampling technique, 2) a faster generalization lookup technique, and 3) an improved representation of a dependency. The first one aims to raise the efficiency of inference from record pairs, while the last two are designed to speed up lattice-related operations. To evaluate our optimizations, we implemented our version of HyMD in Desbordante, an open-source high-performance data profiler. Experiments demonstrated that they allow for a speedup of more than 40x over the state-of-the-art implementation on average, reaching a speedup greater than 170x in some cases. Finally, the improved version of HyMD is ready to use by anyone. It comes with bidirectional Python integration, which allows calling the C++ algorithm implementation from Python programs while allowing users to supply their custom matching functions.

Conditional functional dependencies (CFDs) are functional dependencies with a restricted scope: they specify the context in which a dependency holds and are useful for data-quality tasks, specifying complex integrity constraints, and extracting valuable insights from data. We study the CFD discovery problem, which is computationally demanding. We build on the state-of-the-art CFDFinder algorithm and introduce a set of algorithmic and engineering improvements, including a parallelization strategy, to produce ParCFDFinder. Our implementation is integrated into Desbordante - a high-performance open-source data profiler written in C++ that exposes a Python interface, enabling CFD discovery to be invoked from any Python program. Experimental results show that our enhancements speed up the algorithm by up to $318\times$ ($118\times$ on average) and reduce memory usage by up to $23\times$ ($14\times$ on average) compared with the existing Java-based implementation of Metanome. Integrating ParCFDFinder into Desbordante makes it possible, for the first time, to conveniently discover CFDs on datasets with hundreds of thousands of rows on a commodity machine within a reasonable time.