Spacing Out: On the Reliability of Binaural Music Source Separation Metrics

Evaluation of musical source separation (MSS) has traditionally relied on Blind Source Separation Evaluation (BSS-Eval) metrics. However, recent work suggests that BSS-Eval metrics exhibit low correlation between metrics and perceptual audio quality ratings from a listening test, which is considered the gold standard evaluation method. As an alternative approach in singing voice separation, embedding-based intrusive metrics that leverage latent representations from large self-supervised audio models such as Music undERstanding with large-scale self-supervised Training (MERT) embeddings have been introduced. In this work, we analyze the correlation of perceptual audio quality ratings with two intrusive embedding-based metrics: a mean squared error (MSE) and an intrusive variant of the Fréchet Audio Distance (FAD) calculated on MERT embeddings. Experiments on two independent datasets show that these metrics correlate more strongly with perceptual audio quality ratings than traditional BSS-Eval metrics across all analyzed stem and model types.

Recent spatial self supervised audio models achieve high performance on localization tasks, raising questions about their encoding of microsecond interaural phase fine structures. We propose a psychoacoustic benchmark based on the binaural masking level difference to evaluate this. Using an equalization cancellation baseline and a GCC PHAT positive control we evaluate nine frozen audio models spanning binaural SSL, monaural SSL, and neural audio codecs. Four monaural negative controls yield zero BMLD confirming binaural specificity. Two general purpose binaural SSL models exhibit minimal phase sensitivity while dedicated binaural spatial SSL models achieve BMLD comparable to the analytical baseline. Progressive physical ablations show that general purpose binaural SSL models rely on spectro temporal interference textures rather than cross channel phase computation. High detection rates in speech reflect a confounding reliance on broadband envelopes rather than genuine phase encoding.

Music Source Separation (MSS), the task of recovering individual sound components (stems) from a polyphonic mixture, is central to applications ranging from karaoke and remixing to audio restoration and content production. The separation quality depends on engineering decisions across the entire pipeline: model choice, training data preparation and augmentation, loss function and metrics choice, training configuration, validation, and post-processing. This paper presents MSST (Music-Source-Separation-Training) - a universal open-source framework for MSS tasks, which unifies training, validation, and inference for a broad range of modern demixing model families under a single, configuration-driven interface. The framework supports various model architectures, data preprocessing and augmentations, multiple loss functions and evaluation metrics, which helps with fast iterations and ablation studies. Additionally, the framework supports a range of practical techniques that improve separation quality, such as sliding-window inference with cross-fading, test-time augmentation, model ensembling, and fine-tuning via Low-Rank Adaptation (LORA). Our ablation studies demonstrate improvements of MSS using the above techniques. By consolidating these components into a reproducible, YAML-configurable framework, MSST lowers the barrier to systematic experimentation and enables rapid iteration from idea to verifiable result.