Revisiting the Objective of Echo Chamber Detection
Authors: Abylaikhan Bexeit, Kushani Perera, Shanika Karunasekera, Jean Honorio
Abstract
In this paper, we study the detection of an echo chamber in a social network, i.e., the identification of a set of nodes that agree on a topic, while disagreeing with the rest of nodes. We argue that this problem is different from other social network analysis problems such as community detection, and from other graph problems such as maximum graph cut and maximum clique. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to formalize the objective function of echo chamber detection, by using the theory of Fourier transforms of set functions (Stobbe and Krause, 2012). We propose scalable semidefinite relaxation, solved via an interior point method and sparse linear algebra. Experimentally, our algorithm recovers the ground truth echo chamber better than competing methods on small synthetic experiments. Our algorithm produces echo chambers with better network properties than competing methods on large real-world datasets. To independently validate our proposed objective function, we show that our algorithm finds echo chambers with more agreements with suspended users than competing methods on a small real-world dataset.
Majority illusion is an undesirable phenomenon in social networks in which agents incorrectly perceive a minority opinion as dominant. This can severely distort collective behavior and decision-making. We study the fundamental question of detecting whether a social network allows for a majority illusion. Formally, in the q-Majority Illusion problem, we ask whether there exists a binary labeling of agents in which at least a q-fraction of agents have the majority of neighbors with the minority label. We investigate how various structural properties of the underlying social network influence the tractability of this question, and provide a detailed map of its computational complexity.
Community detection is a fundamental problem in the analysis of complex networks. It has applications across social, biological, and financial domains. Traditional algorithms such as Louvain, LPA, and modularity optimization often require manual parameter tuning. They also suffer from inaccurate cluster center selection and struggle with scalability. To address these challenges, we propose Automatic Laplacian Centrality Means (ALCMeans), a novel community detection algorithm. ALCMeans combines Laplacian energy-based automatic center identification with DeepWalk embeddings for robust node representation. Unlike existing Laplacian-based and clustering methods, ALCMeans eliminates the need to predefine the number of communities, enhances cluster center selection using structural importance, and leverages representation learning for more accurate and stable assignments. Experimental results on benchmark datasets demonstrate 10 to 20 percent higher NMI and ARI scores compared to Louvain, Newman-Girvan, LPA, Fast-Greedy, and a recent GNN-based competitor (MAGI, KDD 2024). Additional evaluations with modularity and F1-scores confirm the superiority of ALCMeans. Ablation studies highlight the critical contributions of each component. Despite its reliance on DeepWalk parameters and increased runtime relative to lightweight heuristics, ALCMeans consistently outperforms state-of-the-art methods. This makes it a promising tool for real-world network analysis.
Recovering latent structure from count data has received considerable attention in network inference, particularly when one seeks both cross-group interactions and within-group similarity patterns in bipartite networks, which is widely used in ecology research. Such networks are often sparse and inherently imperfect in their detection. Existing models mainly focus on interaction recovery, while the induced similarity graphs are much less studied. Moreover, sparsity is often not controlled, and scale is unbalanced, leading to oversparse or poorly rescaled estimates with degrading structural recovery. To address these issues, we propose a framework for structured sparse nonnegative low-rank factorization with detection probability estimation. We impose nonconvex ℓ1/2 regularization on the latent similarity and connectivity structures to promote sparsity within-group similarity and cross-group connectivity with better relative scale. The resulting optimization problem is nonconvex and nonsmooth. To solve it, we develop an ADMM-based algorithm with adaptive penalization and scale-aware initialization and establish its asymptotic feasibility and KKT stationarity of cluster points under mild regularity conditions. Experiments on synthetic and real-world ecological datasets demonstrate improved recovery of latent factors and similarity/connectivity structure relative to existing baselines.