Hierarchical Aggregation of Semantic Uncertainty in 3D Scene Graphs
Organizations: University of Turku, Finland · Aragón Institute of Technology (ITA) and the University of Zaragoza, Spain
Abstract
Open-vocabulary 3D Scene Graphs (3DSGs) ground each object node in a vision-language embedding, yet they record every entry as equally certain, so a robot querying the map cannot tell which of its entries are unreliable. Estimators of semantic uncertainty could supply that distinction, but they require repeated sampling of a model, training, or held-out labels, none of which are available to a deployed system at query time. We present a framework that exploits the detector confidence and the embeddings a 3DSG already stores, converts them into a probability that an entry is correct, and propagates that probability through the containment hierarchy into a belief that a room contains a queried class. Four signals, each paired with the object-level error it indicates, are converted to probabilities at the logit scale learned by the vision-language model and combined in closed form with no additional perception or training. Objects sharing a detector and a vocabulary fail together, so the framework aggregates them in the fully correlated limit, where an aggregation under independence would treat one repeated error as repeated evidence. Evaluated on HM3DSem against a state-of-the-art 3DSG system, the framework improves object retrieval and lowers the error of the room-level assertions of the graph it reads.
Figures & tables
| Scene | Method | OS@ | OS@ | OS@ | OMRR@ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00824 | HOV-SG | ||||
| Belief ( ours ) | |||||
| 00829 | HOV-SG | ||||
| Belief ( ours ) | |||||
| 00843 | HOV-SG | ||||
| Belief ( ours ) |
| Brier | AUROC | Brier | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Method | All | All | Frequent | Common | Rare |
| As built | |||||
| Noisy-OR | |||||
| Belief ( ours ) | |||||
| Method | 00824 | 00829 | 00843 | 00847 | 00849 | 00877 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| As built | ||||||
| Noisy-OR | ||||||
| Belief ( ours ) |
3D Scene Understanding
3D scene understanding builds geometric and semantic representations of environments for spatial reasoning, perception, and interaction.
See all 295 papers