Align, Then Correct: Training-Free Two-Stage Low-Rank Compensation for Extremely Quantized Large Language Models

Post-training quantization is widely used for compressing large neural networks, but aggressive low-bit quantization can significantly degrade model quality. A common remedy is to augment the quantized weights with a low-rank correction, leading to approximations of the form $W\approx Q+LR$. In this paper, we study this low-precision plus low-rank representation through the layer-wise reconstruction objective $\|XW-X(Q+LR)\|_F^2$, where $X$ is a calibration matrix. We establish, to our knowledge, the first information-theoretic lower bounds for this problem under finite-alphabet and bounded low-rank compensation constraints. We then propose GPTQ-intrinsic LoRA, a training-free algorithm that incorporates the low-rank correction directly into a GPTQ-style quantization pass by appropriately augmenting the calibration Hessian. For the choice $L=V_r$, where $V_r$ contains the top right singular vectors of $X$, we prove layer-wise reconstruction error bounds in which the usual GPTQ dependence on $\|X\|_F^2$ is replaced by the rank-$r$ residual $\|X-X_r\|_F^2$, up to regularization terms. Under natural structural assumptions, these bounds match the information-theoretic lower bounds in their dominant scaling, up to constants and mild factors. We also introduce Bid-Up, a fixed-grid quantization refinement step that can be alternated with optimal low-rank compensation with guaranteed non-increasing layer-wise reconstruction error. Experiments on Qwen3 language models and DeiT vision transformers show that GPTQ-intrinsic LoRA improves over GPTQ and GPTQ followed by low-rank compensation, with additional gains from refinement loops.

Layer-wise post-training quantization of large language models minimizes each layer's reconstruction error in isolation, allowing quantization errors to accumulate across depth and causing severe degradation in extreme low-bit regimes. We formulate quantization as a joint optimization over the discrete codes and scales of all layers, driven by two mechanisms: (i) cross-layer error compensation, which maintains the network-level accumulated error through the recursion e_{l+1} = A_l e_l + q_l, with a propagation operator A_l derived from the layer's input differential and a local quantization residual q_l evaluated at teacher features; and (ii) finite-sample feature-statistics matching, which aligns means, projected covariances, and centered empirical kernels between the full-precision and quantized networks under relative normalization. We prove that instantiating the propagation operator as a finite difference of the quantized network makes the recursion exact for arbitrary nonlinear layers, enabling an efficient forward-difference implementation. Binary weights are optimized via a mirror-descent parameterization u = tanh(beta*z) with annealed inverse temperature and group-wise log-scales. On Qwen2.5-1.5B with 1.125-bit group-binary weights, error compensation alone reaches a perplexity ratio of 9.56 +/- 0.15 over the FP16 teacher, outperforming logit distillation (14.09 +/- 0.53; 32 percent relative, more than 8 sigma over 3 seeds) and layer-local reconstruction by two orders of magnitude. The same objective transfers unchanged to 4-bit quantization (1.060 vs. 1.088 for layer-local). Out-of-domain evaluations (C4, CNN/DailyMail) show the advantage of error compensation grows off-domain, while statistics matching keeps feature-statistics discrepancy low off-domain (0.42-0.88 vs. 1.41-2.99 without it), revealing a complementary division of labor between the two mechanisms.

Post-Training Quantization (PTQ) and Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) constitute the standard pipeline for efficient Large Language Model (LLM) deployment. However, applying them sequentially poses a problem: PTQ often leaves behind random noise that is spread out (across the model's weights) in a way LoRA can't easily fix, meaning that LoRA ends up wasting its limited capacity trying to fix uncorrectable noise instead of improving task performance. In this paper, we propose \textbf{ProjQ}, a novel framework for constraining quantization noise to the low-rank manifold via orthogonal subspace projection. We derive an efficient alternating algorithm that shapes the quantization noise into a low-rank structure, effectively offloading dominant error components to the subsequent adapter while minimizing the residual error in the orthogonal "uncorrectable" subspace. Our theoretical analysis demonstrates that ProjQ preserves strictly greater model plasticity for downstream tasks compared to standard PTQ. Extensive experiments on LLaMA-2, Qwen2.5 and Qwen3 confirm that ProjQ consistently outperforms existing methods in both quantization error compensation and downstream task fine-tuning, achieving up to $2\times$ lower evaluation loss for compensation and matching the performance of standard 4-bit baselines on language modeling tasks with only 3 bits. The code is available on https://github.com/yy9301/ProjQ .