Comprehensive empirical evaluation of feature extractors in computer vision

Image matching is a fundamental problem in Computer Vision with direct applications in robotics, remote sensing, and geospatial data analysis. We present an analytical and experimental evaluation of classical local feature-based image matching algorithms on satellite imagery, focusing on the Scale-Invariant Feature Transform (SIFT) and the Oriented FAST and Rotated BRIEF (ORB). Each method is evaluated through a common pipeline: keypoint detection, descriptor extraction, descriptor matching, and geometric verification via RANSAC with homography estimation. Matching quality is assessed using the Inlier Ratio - the fraction of correspondences consistent with the estimated homography. The study uses a manually constructed dataset of GPS-annotated satellite image tiles with intentional overlaps. We examine the impact of the number of extracted keypoints on the resulting Inlier Ratio.

A widespread assumption in local feature research holds that classical handcrafted descriptors are accuracy-limited relics best replaced by learned alternatives. We show this is wrong. Through an 8-configuration ablation spanning four benchmarks (HPatches, ROxford5K, IMC Phototourism, MegaDepth), we demonstrate that classical SIFT with DSP multi-scale pooling outperforms neural descriptor and orientation replacements (HardNet, OriNet) on every accuracy metric--while running 2--18$\times$ faster--and that learned matchers (LightGlue) complement rather than supersede classical features. The conclusion reframes a decade of work: not "replace SIFT" but "compose with SIFT," classical extraction paired with learned matching only where geometric context demands it. This finding was invisible because no prior GPU SIFT kept the complete pipeline in VRAM or offered modularity for controlled classical-vs-learned ablations. We present PySIFT, the first fully GPU-resident SIFT, implemented in CuPy/Numba CUDA kernels with DLPack zero-copy handoff to downstream DL frameworks--submillisecond O(1) metadata swap regardless of keypoint count. On a laptop-grade NVIDIA RTX 3050 (4 GB VRAM), PySIFT achieves: (i) higher Mean Matching Accuracy (MMA) than OpenCV SIFT on HPatches, (ii) 383 ms faster per pair on high-resolution MegaDepth, (iii) higher geometric accuracy on cross-dataset benchmarks (+5.6 pp AUC@10${}^\circ$ on MegaDepth, more inliers on IMC Phototourism), and (iv) bitwise deterministic output--identical keypoints and descriptors across runs, with detection reproducing identically even across GPU architectures: a guarantee that learned extractors cannot match without significant performance sacrifice, and cannot achieve at all across GPU architectures due to cuDNN's architecture-dependent algorithm selection. PySIFT is open-source, requiring no C++ compilation.

Multi-view computer vision pipelines typically rely on accurate sparse keypoints and robust descriptors. While incorporating line features has shown clear benefits for matching and pose estimation, existing point-line approaches remain inefficient: they detect points and lines separately, use increasingly heavy networks, and depend on CPU-bound heuristics that hinder real-time performance. We introduce a Unified Efficient Points and Lines (UPAL) feature extractor that jointly extracts keypoints, line segments, and feature descriptors within a single lightweight architecture. A shared backbone provides common representations that feed different branches for point and line features. Line segments are recovered through an accelerated post-processing stage, an enhanced and highly efficient variant of the LSD algorithm. UPAL matches or exceeds state-ofthe-art performance in both point and line applications while significantly reducing computational cost, achieving, for instance, a 4x speedup and 10x smaller memory footprint over the ALIKED + DeepLSD pipeline. Code is publicly available at https://github.com/francois141/upal.