cs.CVNov 10, 2026

PhyRubric: Rubric-Grounded Diagnostic Evaluation of Physical Commonsense in Text-to-Video Generation

Authors: Huiyi Chen, Weitai Kang, Shicheng Fan, Xinshuo Wang, Zhixiang Shen, Yan Yan, Philip S. Yu, Baoxin Li

Organizations: Department of Computer Science, University of Illinois Chicago

Abstract

As text-to-video (T2V) models are increasingly positioned as world simulators, it is essential to evaluate whether their videos conform to physical commonsense. However, existing benchmarks rely on annotators who rate each video with a single score based on intuition, yielding ratings that are subjective and do not tell which physical principle is violated. We introduce PhyRubric, a rubric-grounded diagnostic framework for evaluating physical commonsense in T2V generation. For each caption, PhyRubric constructs a caption-specific rubric before any video is seen, decomposing the caption into semantic and physical items, and derives scores from item-level verdicts grounded in timestamped evidence. We instantiate this framework as PhyRubric-Bench, which spans 34 categories across five physical domains, and scale it up to PhyRubric-Train with 3,788 videos, on which we fine-tune the open-source PhyRubric-Judge. Empirical results across ten T2V models show that physical commonsense remains far from solved, and that PhyRubric-Judge correlates more closely with human judgments than existing open-source judges while matching the frontier proprietary Gemini 4 Argon. Further analysis provides actionable insights for T2V models.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables26 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

Jul 21, 2025

PhysVidBench: Language-Grounded Evaluation of Physical Commonsense in Text-to-Video Models

Text-to-video (T2V) models now produce striking visuals, yet they routinely violate everyday physics; objects float, tools are misused, and causal sequences break down. Existing benchmarks mostly probe isolated physical laws and rely on vision-language models to score videos directly, which entangles perception and reasoning in one judgment and correlates poorly with humans. We introduce PhysVidBench, a benchmark of 383 base prompts, expanded to 766 prompts with enriched variants and 4,123 manually reviewed QA items, together with a language-grounded evaluation framework that takes a different route: instead of asking a VLM "Is this video physically correct?", we caption the video, then ask a language model to answer prompt-derived yes/no physics questions using only the captions. This split between seeing and reasoning makes each score traceable to the captions that justify it and aligns more closely with human judgment than direct VLM scoring (Pearson r=0.45-0.69, compared with 0.21-0.47 for the strongest direct VLM evaluator). To test the framework, we carefully curate a set of human-validated prompts spanning seven physical dimensions, with a focus on tool use and affordances - areas largely absent from prior physics-focused benchmarks. Across 12 open and proprietary T2V systems, the best model reaches only 36.2% average accuracy, and no model consistently handles everyday physical reasoning. The same pipeline can also guide iterative error-guided prompt refinement, improving CogVideoX-2B from 21.6 to 32.7 and CogVideoX-5B from 17.8 to 29.7 without retraining.
Oct 14, 2026

PhyMetric: Diagnosing Physical Plausibility in Text-to-Video Generation via Scene-Level QA

Text-to-video (T2V) generation models can produce visually realistic videos that nevertheless violate the physical consequences implied by the prompt and scene. Existing benchmarks largely rely on holistic plausibility scores or broad quality dimensions, leaving it unclear which physical behavior is being tested and why a model fails. We introduce PhyMetric, a scene-level diagnostic benchmark that recasts physical plausibility evaluation as verifiable, scene-grounded question answering. PhyMetric contains 1{,}115 scenes spanning 50 physical categories across six domains, paired with 8{,}920 answer-balanced binary questions over 12 evaluation dimensions. Each scene is associated with eight targeted yes/no questions and a structured physical prior specifying the governing law, expected temporal sequence, observable signatures, and common failure modes. At evaluation time, a vision-language model (VLM) judge answers each question from question-aware sampled frames conditioned on the prior, and correctness is hierarchically aggregated into scene, dimension, physical category, and model scores. Experiments on four open-source T2V models and three VLM judges show that scene-specific binary QA is a critical component of the protocol: when each targeted question is replaced by a single generic plausibility query, evaluator accuracy drops to the chance level. Structured physical priors offer a complementary signal that improves human alignment of the resulting scores, with effects that vary across VLM judges of different capacity. These findings establish PhyMetric as a benchmark that turns physical plausibility evaluation from opaque holistic scoring into interpretable, scene-level inspection. Our project page is available at: https://mengsiwei.github.io/PhyMetric/.
Mar 3, 2026

PhyPrompt: RL-based Prompt Refinement for Physically Plausible Text-to-Video Generation

State-of-the-art text-to-video (T2V) generators frequently violate physical laws despite high visual quality. We show this stems from insufficient physical constraints in prompts rather than model limitations: manually adding physics details reliably produces physically plausible videos, but requires expertise and does not scale. We present PhyPrompt, a two-stage reinforcement learning framework that automatically refines prompts for physically realistic generation. First, we fine-tune a large language model on a physics-focused Chain-of-Thought dataset to integrate principles like object motion and force interactions while preserving user intent. Second, we apply Group Relative Policy Optimization with a dynamic reward curriculum that initially prioritizes semantic fidelity, then progressively shifts toward physical commonsense. This curriculum achieves synergistic optimization: PhyPrompt-7B reaches 40.8% joint success on VideoPhy2 (8.6pp gain), improving physical commonsense by 11pp (55.8% to 66.8%) while simultaneously increasing semantic adherence by 4.4pp (43.4% to 47.8%). Remarkably, our curriculum exceeds single-objective training on both metrics, demonstrating compositional prompt discovery beyond conventional multi-objective trade-offs. PhyPrompt outperforms GPT-4o (+3.8% joint) and DeepSeek-V3 (+2.2%, 100×\times larger) using only 7B parameters. The approach transfers zero-shot across diverse T2V architectures (Lavie, VideoCrafter2, CogVideoX-5B) with up to 16.8% improvement, establishing that domain-specialized reinforcement learning with compositional curricula surpasses general-purpose scaling for physics-aware generation.