cs.LGNov 13, 2026

Deep Neural Networks Training Efficiency: Does Grokking Modify its Dynamics?

Authors: Eduardo Cueto-Mendoza, John D. Kelleher

Organizations: Technological University Dublin · Trinity College Dublin

Abstract

We study whether grokking, the delayed emergence of out-of-distribution generalization after apparent overfitting, alters training efficiency in deep neural networks, where efficiency is measured as accuracy per unit energy. Using two canonical settings, modular arithmetic and MNIST, we analyze two neural network models under 16-, 32-, and 64-bit precision and use Orthograd to test whether grokking produces noticeable deviations from the typically decreasing dynamics of training efficiency. We consider both short training runs of up to 500 epochs and long training runs of up to 20,000 epochs, and in both cases identify grokking as a sharp improvement in test accuracy after a sustained train-test gap. In the short-horizon experiments, applying Orthograd at progressively stronger levels during early training does not induce grokking, and efficiency remains smoothly decreasing. In the long-horizon experiments, Orthograd induces grokking, but the efficiency curves remain approximately monotonic and show no appreciable local increase at the grokking transition. These results suggest that, in our setting, grokking does not materially alter overall training-efficiency dynamics.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

Mar 26, 2026

A Systematic Empirical Study of Grokking: Depth, Architecture, Activation, and Regularization

Grokking the delayed transition from memorization to generalization in neural networks remains poorly understood, in part because prior empirical studies confound the roles of architecture, optimization, and regularization. We present a controlled study that systematically disentangles these factors on modular addition (mod 97), with matched and carefully tuned training regimes across models. Our central finding is that grokking dynamics are not primarily determined by architecture, but by interactions between optimization stability and regularization. Specifically, we show: (1) depth has a non-monotonic effect, with depth-4 MLPs consistently failing to grok while depth-8 residual networks recover generalization, demonstrating that depth requires architectural stabilization; (2) the apparent gap between Transformers and MLPs largely disappears (1.11×\times delay) under matched hyperparameters, indicating that previously reported differences are largely due to optimizer and regularization confounds; (3) activation function effects are regime-dependent, with GELU up to 4.3×\times faster than ReLU only when regularization permits memorization; and (4) weight decay is the dominant control parameter, exhibiting a narrow ``Goldilocks'' regime in which grokking occurs, while too little or too much prevents generalization. Across 3--5 seeds per configuration, these results provide a unified empirical account of grokking as an interaction-driven phenomenon. Our findings challenge architecture-centric interpretations and clarify how optimization and regularization jointly govern delayed generalization.
May 26, 2026

Two Speeds of Learning: A Representation-Readout Decomposition of Grokking and Double Descent

Training loss and accuracy are the standard signals used to monitor generalization during deep neural network training. Two well-documented phenomena complicate this picture: in grokking, train loss falls rapidly while test performance improves abruptly only after a long delay; in epoch-wise double descent, train loss decreases monotonically while test loss or error rises and falls. Existing accounts are often task-specific, and a task-agnostic analysis framework for diagnosing and explaining these phenomena across realistic tasks and architectures is missing. We address this challenge by analyzing two competing processes that underlie learning dynamics: representation learning in the encoder and readout calibration in the final classifier. Using tools from representational geometry, neural tangent kernels, and linear probing, we show that both processes are active throughout training, with the fluctuations of their relative speed giving rise to seemingly anomalous generalization dynamics. Applying the representation-readout decomposition to grokking across a wide range of tasks and architectures, we find that the readout is train-biased before grokking onset, and representation learning is gradual but not absent, contrary to the lazy-to-rich account. The framework further provides diagnostic signatures distinguishing spurious from genuine generalization: in a previously reported MNIST grokking example and an epoch-wise double descent example, apparent delayed or non-monotone generalization is shown to arise from representation degradation and readout misalignment induced by non-standard training recipes. Together, these results establish the representation-readout decomposition as a top-down framework for understanding learning dynamics and revealing underlying algorithms for interpretability research.
Jun 15, 2026

Noise-Driven Escape from Metastable Phases explains Grokking in Deep Neural Networks

Deep neural networks (DNNs) exhibit first order phase transitions under variations of the L2 regularization strength, with each transition marking the onset of a new learnable feature. Below a critical regularization strength, all features are in principle learnable, but coexisting metastable states, separated by energy barriers, can trap the network and impede convergence. A strength of DNNs is their ability to generalize. But many open questions remain, among them the origin of so called grokking: the abrupt, delayed onset of generalization after prolonged apparent overfitting. We show for linear DNNs that grokking is consistent with hysteresis in first-order L2 phase transitions: using L2 regularization to engineer deliberate trapping, we demonstrate that a model in a low-accuracy metastable state escapes only when SGD noise drives it across an energy barrier, with escape times following Arrhenius scaling. We reproduce grokking-like delayed convergence across two orders of magnitude in escape time by deliberately trapping models in metastable phases. Using sparse sub-sampling we also reproduce the canonical grokking curve where test error eventually approaches the final training error. Our work suggests that the number of metastable states equals the number of learnable features -- one per singular value of the data covariance -- the potential for hysteresis grows naturally with task complexity. We provide evidence that the same mechanism likely operates in general nonlinear DNNs. Our results provide routes toward more efficient learning schemes.