cs.CVNov 16, 2026

How Many Persistent Features Does a Biometric Need? A Law Linking Equal Error Rate to Feature Count and Persistence

Authors: Oleg Komogortsev, Mehedi Hasan Raju

Organizations: Texas State University, San Marcos, Texas, USA

Abstract

A biometric designer controls the number of features and their temporal persistence. Earlier empirical work linked the equal error rate (EER) to persistence and to the required number of features by straight lines. We derive the law behind these regularities. For NN independent standardized Gaussian features with test-retest correlation ρρ, scored by cosine similarity, Fisher's zz-transform turns the genuine and impostor scores into two normals, giving EER=Φ(−12N atanh⁡ρ)\mathrm{EER}=Φ(-\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{N}\,\operatorname{atanh}ρ) and, inversely, N=(2q/atanh⁡ρ)2N=(2q/\operatorname{atanh}ρ)^2 with q=Φ−1(1−EER)q=Φ^{-1}(1-\mathrm{EER}); intercorrelated features enter through an effective count NeffN_{\mathrm{eff}}. The central extension lets persistence vary across comparisons with spread ττ on Fisher's scale: EER=Φ(−m/(τ2+v+v))\mathrm{EER}=Φ(-m/(\sqrt{τ^2+v}+\sqrt{v})) with v=1/(Neff−2)v=1/(N_{\mathrm{eff}}-2), which for a normal spread has a floor Φ(−m/τ)Φ(-m/τ) that no number of features can lower. With no fitted parameter the simple law reproduces published simulations and the EER-ICC line, and predicts the KCC-EER relation of eye-movement embeddings on GazeBase (R2=0.88R^2=0.88), though less well on GazeBaseVR (0.630.63). Read from the genuine and impostor scores, the general form matches the EER of eye movements, keystroke dynamics, the ECG and face embeddings over 101 conditions with R2=0.98R^2=0.98 and a median error of 0.60.6 points, against 0.870.87 and 1.91.9 points for the simple law. The 61 eye-movement, keystroke and ECG conditions check consistency on the same scores; the 40 face conditions use held-out subjects, with the same accuracy. The product τNeff−2τ\sqrt{N_{\mathrm{eff}}-2} gives a design rule: adding or decorrelating features pays fully while it is well below one and little once it exceeds about three, where only higher or more uniform persistence helps.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables12 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

Jun 23, 2026

EERLoss: A Novel Loss Function for Training Deep Biometric Models. A Case Study in Keystroke Dynamics

Deep learning approaches to biometric verification are commonly trained by optimizing indirect objectives, creating a misalignment between the optimization process and the primary evaluation metric, typically the Equal Error Rate (EER). This paper introduces EERLoss: a subdifferentiable, arbitrarily accurate approximation to EER for training deep biometric models. Furthermore, this framework has the potential to be adapted to optimize any specific operating point on the DET curve, enhancing its generalizability. To validate this approach, EERLoss is evaluated on a particularly demanding behavioral biometric modality: keystroke dynamics verification. This task is characterized by its high intra-class and low inter-class variability. Experiments are conducted on the large-scale KVC-onGoing benchmark, incorporating data from over 185,000 subjects across different scenarios. A comprehensive ablation study initially demonstrates the superiority of EERLoss in comparison to existing state-of-the-art loss functions. It also converges substantially faster compared to other losses, reducing the overall training cost. Additionally, a comparison is made between the proposed loss and the KVC-winning architecture by re-training it with EERLoss, demonstrating that the proposed approach significantly outperforms the original SoTA, achieving a relative EER reduction of up to approx. 30%. This improvement on a challenging, large-scale benchmark validates the effectiveness of EERLoss as a task-aligned training objective specifically suited for high-variance biometric traits.
Sep 24, 2026

Template Ageing and Longitudinal Verification in Fixed-Text Keystroke Dynamics: A Subject-Disjoint Study Across Eight Weeks

Behavioural biometric templates are widely believed to degrade as the gap between enrolment and verification grows, but few studies measure this template ageing effect directly under controlled conditions. We collected a longitudinal dataset of 40 fixed passwords, each typed four times per weekly session over eight consecutive weeks. We compare a scaled-Manhattan matcher (M1), a gradient-boosted classifier (M2), a TypeNet-style recurrent embedding model (M3), and a TypeFormer-style Transformer (M4) under a 5-fold subject-disjoint protocol and a design that jointly varies mechanism and the enrolment-to-query gap, from 0 to 7 weeks. Template ageing proves large and systematic. Error increases monotonically with the gap for every mechanism, from an EER of 14.6-27.2% at a gap of zero to 25.5-37.1% at seven weeks, or 1.7% of decision error per week elapsed (p < 0.001). However, the choice of mechanism matters more than its rate of ageing. Baseline accuracy spans 12.6 percentage points across the four mechanisms, the degradation each accumulates over seven weeks spans only 2.3 points, and ageing never reorders them. A matcher can therefore be chosen on same-session accuracy, with ageing managed by re-enrolment scheduling rather than by matcher selection. The two properties are nonetheless distinct, as M3 is the least accurate mechanism yet ages significantly more slowly than M1 under every specification tested. Training randomness also matters differently by architecture, with 58% of the recurrent model's fold-to-fold variance attributable to seed noise against 19% for the Transformer. Because the smaller ageing-rate differences are sensitive to modelling choices, while the accuracy differences and the ageing effect are not, we recommend that comparative ageing-rate claims be supported by seed-level score fusion, independent replication, and an alternative outcome-model specification.
Feb 17, 2026

Advanced Acceptance Score: A Holistic Measure for Biometric Quantification

Quantifying biometric characteristics within hand gestures involve derivation of fitness scores from a gesture and identity aware feature space. However, evaluating the quality of these scores remains an open question. Existing biometric capacity estimation literature relies upon error rates. But these rates do not indicate goodness of scores. Thus, in this manuscript we present an exhaustive set of evaluation measures. We firstly identify ranking order and relevance of output scores as the primary basis for evaluation. In particular, we consider both rank deviation as well as rewards for: (i) higher scores of high ranked gestures and (ii) lower scores of low ranked gestures. We also compensate for correspondence between trends of output and ground truth scores. Finally, we account for disentanglement between identity features of gestures as a discounting factor. Integrating these elements with adequate weighting, we formulate advanced acceptance score as a holistic evaluation measure. To assess effectivity of the proposed we perform in-depth experimentation over three datasets with five state-of-the-art (SOTA) models. Results show that the optimal score selected with our measure is more appropriate than existing other measures. Also, our proposed measure depicts correlation with existing measures. This further validates its reliability. We have made our code public.