cs.LGNov 17, 2026

Encoding, Decodability, and Use: A Five-Layer Framework for Benchmark Measurement Audits with Evidence from UAV Intent Recognition

Authors: Zhirong Su, Tian Zhang

Organizations: Shandong Management University, Jinan 250357, China. · Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China.

Abstract

Benchmark accuracy is routinely read as evidence that a model understands the construct the benchmark measures. We propose and instantiate on AeroIntent a five-layer framework that decomposes that reading into observation, representation, decoding, use, and behaviour. The framework separates encoding, decodability, and use as distinct levels. In the instantiation, the observation layer is unreliable on 7 of the 20 Drone programs and floors the direct visual correlate of radial velocity at a 0.26% scale change. The representation layer exposes two task-designed RGB features with nominal signals. RAFT flow radial bias reaches r=+0.257r=+0.257 (p=0.030p=0.030), and bounding-box optical-flow divergence reaches r=+0.203r=+0.203 (p=0.029p=0.029). No multi-feature readout gives a fold-mean test correlation above the cluster minimum detectable effect (MDE), and the largest positive global out-of-sample correlation is r=+0.080r=+0.080. The decoding layer sets the MDE at ∣r∣=0.599|r|=0.599 at the multi-feature Bonferroni threshold (α=0.00714α=0.00714, power 0.80), and the observed r=+0.080r=+0.080 has power 0.00. Two injection experiments establish the MDE's condition from both sides: aligned injections are detected at or above the simulated power, and orthogonal injections are not detected. The use layer finds accuracy consistent with program memory (program-identity 0.937/0.597/0.210) and multi-region static cues. The behaviour layer is consistent with accuracy not requiring a radial-velocity readout (appearance 0.6552 vs bounding-box trajectory 0.4080, cluster-level paired Δ=+0.2471Δ=+0.2471, p=0.0132p=0.0132).

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

Oct 19, 2026

AeroIntent: A Synchronized Multimodal Benchmark for UAV Mission Intent Recognition

Reliable recognition of mission-level UAV intent from multimodal observations is essential for low-altitude airspace surveillance and security. Existing multimodal UAV datasets primarily support detection, tracking, and localization, leaving limited support for evaluating mission-intent recognition across held-out trajectory programs and incomplete radar histories. We introduce AeroIntent, a simulation-based benchmark comprising 990 synchronized multimodal sequences generated by 22 trajectory programs across five mission intents. The benchmark provides radar, RGB, infrared, and depth observations, together with program-disjoint, radar-gap, and observation-prefix evaluation protocols. Building on this benchmark, we propose AeroMIR, a structured Multimodal Intent Reasoner that integrates radar trajectories, derived behavioral features, selected visual evidence, and task knowledge for candidate-based UAV intent recognition. Under a strict program-disjoint protocol evaluating unseen tactical realizations, AeroMIR achieves a mean accuracy of 71.56% and a mean Macro-F1 of 69.84% across three seeds, outperforming the strongest trajectory-only baseline by 7.79 Macro-F1 points and a conventional radar-RGB late-fusion baseline by 19.32 points. AeroMIR also demonstrates strong performance under controlled radar gaps and early intent recognition settings. AeroIntent and AeroMIR provide a reproducible foundation for multimodal UAV intent recognition. The benchmark is available at: https://anonymous.4open.science/r/AeroIntent
Jul 1, 2026

How Much Do RF Drone Benchmarks Overstate? A Controlled Study and Theory of Data Leakage in UAV Signal Identification

Radio-frequency (RF) sensing is a central modality for counter-unmanned-aerial-system (counter-UAS) defence because it exploits the control, telemetry, and video links between a drone and its operator. Reported accuracies for RF-based drone detection and identification are often very high, but many are obtained using cross-validation that splits a small number of continuous recordings into short segments. This can place near-duplicate slices of the same recording in both training and test partitions, creating data leakage. We study this leakage problem through theory and measurement. We formalise the optimism of segment-level cross-validation and show, using Cover's function-counting theorem, that a classifier can exactly memorise the recording-to-label map when the number of independent recordings, R, is small relative to the feature dimension, d. In particular, this can occur when 2R is less than or approximately equal to d. Under these conditions, naive accuracy approaches 1, and the inflation gap approaches 1 - ACC*, where ACC* is the Bayes accuracy. The inflation eases only once R grows beyond this separability threshold. A controlled synthetic experiment with 10 seeds confirms the predicted curves: naive balanced accuracy rises from the Bayes level toward 1.0 as recording-specific nuisance variation grows, while honest recording-grouped evaluation declines to chance, with a gap reaching about 0.5. On the public DroneRF dataset, pooled leave-one-recording-out cross-validation shows drone type identification, AR versus Bebop, collapsing from a naive macro-F1 of 0.74 to 0.46, the two-class chance level. A leakage-pathway ablation attributes essentially all of the inflation to segment-level leakage.
Nov 5, 2026

FlyingDrones: A Dataset and Benchmark for Optical Flow Estimation from UAV motion

Optical flow is an important cue for drone analysis in aerial surveillance, airspace monitoring, and long-range target tracking, where motion remains informative when appearance is weak. Estimating the motion of small Unmanned Aerial Vehicles, however, is difficult because distant targets occupy few pixels, have low contrast, and move against complex dynamic backgrounds. Standard optical-flow benchmarks emphasize large, object-centric motions and therefore do not characterize distant aerial targets well. We introduce FlyingDrones, a generated benchmark with dense ground-truth optical flow and segmentation masks derived from physically based rendering, and define resolution-normalized metrics (EPE Norm) that normalize flow by image dimensions. We evaluate 16 state-of-the-art model families on a motion- and size-stratified subset of 999 flow pairs at three resolutions. Every family recovers drone motion better than the zero-flow reference, but the gap between families widens with resolution: at 1920x1080, global-matching, recurrent, transformer, and short-window temporal models separate clearly from pyramid, classical, self-supervised, lightweight, and diffusion models. Within-family checkpoint spread is comparable to or larger than between-family spread, so the training curriculum is as important as the architecture. Two complementary studies test the benchmark beyond synthetic accuracy: a ground-truth-free motion-alignment evaluation on 21 cameras of real UAV footage shows that the synthetic ranking carries a moderate, significant signal about real-world performance (Spearman \r{ho} = 0.63 over 41 checkpoints) while the exact top ranks differ, and a fine-tuning study shows that 800 FlyingDrones pairs reduce held-out drone-region error by up to 37% and improve drone localization on the real footage for all four architectures tested.