cs.CVNov 18, 2026

Why Multi-Source Audio Fails to Compose: A Geometric Diagnosis and Its Remedy

Authors: Anurag Singh, Prajwal Singh, Shanmuganathan Raman

Organizations: CVIG Lab, IIT Gandhinagar Gandhinagar, Gujarat, India

Abstract

Multi-source audio-to-image generation exhibits consistent compositional failures when audio tokens occupy geometrically displaced, semantically unanchored positions in the CLIP text-token space, where the diffusion U-Net lacks the prior to reliably attend to them or ground them in distinct spatial regions. We formalize this as the geometric displacement phenomenon and expose it through a two-level clustering analysis comparing BEATs and CLAP embeddings at the raw encoder and projected CLIP token levels. Three geometric properties emerge as important: intra-class compactness, angular alignment with the CLIP text manifold, and inter-token spatial separation. We show that CLAP, whose contrastive language-audio pretraining aligns embeddings with natural language semantics, substantially outperforms BEATs on all three properties, improving the silhouette score by more than 3x and the Audio-Image Content score as well. Building on this analysis, we introduce a multi-token extension that requires no diffusion-backbone retraining and assigns each audio source to a distinct placeholder token in the CLIP tokenizer, complemented by a mixed inference-time objective that combines Attend-and-Excite with an A* spatial separation loss to resolve residual cross-token interference. For evaluation, we construct multi-audio compositional benchmarks from VGGSound (VGG2, VGG3, and VGGN) and extend six standard audio-image metrics to the multi-source setting. Across five benchmarks and four strong baselines, our method achieves strong results on the metrics most directly tied to compositional faithfulness, with AIC improvements of up to 2.25x over the strongest baseline and FID reduced by nearly 2x on two-source generation. We propose geometric displacement as a diagnostic framework for cross-modal generation systems that project learned embeddings into a pretrained contrastive space.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables16 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

Sep 30, 2026

PLACE: Positional Latent Adaptation via Conditioned Embeddings for Binaural Audio Generation

We present PLACE, a method that extends the pretrained any-to-audio model AudioX for binaural generation from arbitrary combinations of text, video, and optional audio prompts. PLACE augments video conditioning with Perception Encoder Core features, aligns text and video representations to derive spatial cues, and applies a conditioning-dependent low-rank transformation to the generated latent. The adapter is supervised via decoded-audio interaural level and time difference objectives. Trained on MRSAudio, PLACE improves most metrics over ViSAGe on FAIR-Play and achieves an improved SpatialCLAP score over SpatialSonic on the BEWO-1M Single Static test split. Listener evaluations favor PLACE for video-to-audio and out-of-distribution text-to-audio generation, demonstrating flexible multimodal control and improved spatial consistency.
May 28, 2026

COMET: Concept Space Dissection of the Modality Gap in Audio-Text Multimodal Contrastive Embeddings

Contrastive Language-Audio Pretraining (CLAP) models are widely used for audio understanding and support modality-agnostic condition swapping in many zero-shot applications. However, their performance is heavily affected by the modality gap between audio and text embeddings. Existing explanations mainly attribute this gap to the cone effect, treating it as a shift between mean embeddings, yet correcting the mean alone yields only limited improvements. Alternative hypotheses, such as information imbalance and dimensionality collapse, have also been proposed, but they remain insufficiently verified and have not been thoroughly studied in the audio domain. Meanwhile, several works attempt to decompose multimodal contrastive embeddings into interpretable concepts, but none explicitly analyze the modality gap from the perspective of concept decomposition. In this work, we introduce COMET (Concept space Organization and Modality gap Explanation with PLS-SVD Transformation), a novel partial least squares singular value decomposition (PLS-SVD) framework for CLAP that unveils a broader perspective of the modality gap. Our framework reveals that only a small, interpretable subset of axes, which captures shared concepts, contributes substantially to similarity computation, and that the mean component represents only partially the modality gap. Building on this insight, we propose a simple spectral truncation method that mitigates the modality gap in a training-free manner. The method enables zero-shot audio captioning with condition swapping to approach fully supervised performance, without requiring large auxiliary memory banks or expensive computation. At the same time, it achieves substantial embedding dimensionality reduction while preserving strong performance on retrieval and audio captioning tasks.
Sep 23, 2026

Do Audio Representations Compose Additively?

Compositionality, the ability to represent complex acoustic scenes as combinations of simpler sound sources, is central to auditory perception and classical additive signal models. Still, it remains unclear whether modern pre-trained audio representations internalize additive structure without compositional supervision. Existing evaluation frameworks of audio compositional reasoning largely focus on cross-modal audio-text alignment, leaving open whether audio representations themselves exhibit additive compositional structure independent of text grounding, analogous to vector arithmetic in word representations. To investigate this, we adopt a two-step diagnostic for frozen audio representations. First, we quantify linear alignment between representations and sound source labels using canonical correlation analysis. Second, we test additive compositional generalization via leave-one-combination-out reconstruction, grouping clips by exact source-label set, averaging their representations, and predicting held-out means from per-source contributions fitted only on training combinations. With larger combination holdouts, CLAP outperforms the permuted and label-overlap baselines on FSD50K, while the speech models do not outperform the label-overlap baseline. We examine representations generated by Wav2Vec2, HuBERT, and CLAP on FSD50K and CHiME-Home datasets. All three models show consistently higher linear correlation and more accurate leave-one-combination-out reconstructions than the permuted baselines. However, only CLAP shows large cosine similarity gains, which could be associated with its training on many kinds of audio and text. Finally, we note that all three models exhibit reconstruction residuals, revealing limits of additive compositionality such as nonlinear or non-compositional audio structure.