Service, Solidarity, and Self-Help: A Comparative Topic Modeling Analysis of Community Unionism in the Boot and Shoe Union and Unite Community
Organizations: University of York
Abstract
This paper presents a comparative analysis of community unionism (CU) in two distinct historical and organizational contexts: the National Boot and Shoe Union (B&S) in the 1920s and Unite Community in the 2010s--2020s. Using BERTopic for thematic modeling and cTF-IDF weighting, alongside word frequency analysis, the study examines the extent to which each union's discourse aligns with key features of CU -- such as coalition-building, grassroots engagement, and action beyond the workplace. The results reveal significant differences in thematic focus and discursive coherence. While Unite Community demonstrates stronger alignment with outward-facing, social justice-oriented themes, the B&S corpus emphasizes internal administration, industrial relations, and member services -- reflecting a more traditional, servicing-oriented union model. The analysis also highlights methodological insights, demonstrating how modern NLP techniques can enhance the study of historical labor archives. Ultimately, the findings suggest that while both unions engage with community-related themes, their underlying models of engagement diverge significantly, challenging assumptions about the continuity and universality of community unionism across time and sector.
Figures & tables
| Word | Count bs | Percentile bs | Count uc | Percentile uc | Diff (uc–bs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| branch | 3058 | 99.96 | 2631 | 100.0 | 0.04 |
| member | 6584 | 100.0 | 2144 | 99.99 | -0.01 |
| community | 155 | 96.74 | 2081 | 99.98 | 3.24 |
| unite | 37 | 91.05 | 2023 | 99.97 | 8.92 |
| report | 3013 | 99.96 | 1893 | 99.96 | 0.0 |
| meeting | 2078 | 99.88 | 1851 | 99.95 | 0.07 |
| Corpus | Total Sents | Avg Len | Min Len | Max Len | 5 Wds | 25 Wds |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B&S | 95,557 | 15.22 | 5 | 270 | 0 | 4,763 |
| UC | 16,864 | 17.64 | 3 | 535 | 1 | 1,202 |
| Thematic Group | Topic Labels | Notes / Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Trade Unions | Unite Community; Trade Unions | Core identity and affiliation terms. |
| Campaign Issues | Housing Issues; Climate Change; Fight the Far Right; Disability Support; Palestine Solidarity; Better Buses Campaign | Outward-facing mobilisation topics reflecting CU’s social justice alignment. |
| Administration | Branch Meetings; Meetings and Working Groups; Branch Finances; Education; Local Events | Internal governance and coordination; ongoing organising infrastructure. |
| Politics | Labour Party; CLP Relations | Formal political relationships, party activism/motions; ties to party politics. |
| Thematic Group | Topic Labels | Notes / Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Trade Unions | Unite Community, Trade Unions | Core identity and affiliation terms |
| Campaign Issues | Housing Issues, Climate Change, Fight the Far Right, Disability Support, Palestine Solidarity, Better Buses Campaign | Outward-facing mobilisation topics reflecting CU’s social justice alignment |
| Administration | Branch Meetings, Meetings and Working Groups, Branch Finances, Education, Local Events | Internal governance and coordination themes; reflect ongoing organising infrastructure |
| Politics | Labour Party, CLP Relations | Formal political relationships, party activism, and motions; ties to party politics |
| Thematic Group | Topic Labels | Notes / Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Administration | Trade Unions, Conferences, Finances, Local Events | Internal structure and union governance dominate, reflecting a formal institutional focus. |
| Member Services | Holiday and Insurance Schemes, Death and Sympathy Notices | Indicates a mutual aid model: provision of benefits, welfare support, and recognition of members’ personal lives. |
| Industrial Relations | Court Cases and Arbitration, Industry and Trade Boards, Boot and Shoe Industry, Trade Evaluation | Focus on labor disputes, sector-specific regulation, and employment conditions, highlighting the union’s role in workplace advocacy. |
| Politics | Government Policy, Labour Party, Russia and International Affairs, Women | Engages with broader political discourse, including foreign affairs and gender issues; reflects ideological reach beyond immediate workplace concerns. |
| Corpus | Gini Score | Appearance Percentage (%) | Topic 20 Size | PUV | Ngram Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B&S | 0.38 | 54.73 | 984 | 0.97 | 0.19 |
| UC | 0.28 | 58.33 | 261 | 0.95 | 0.27 |
| Metric | Description |
|---|---|
| Gini Score | Measures how evenly topics are distributed across the dataset. A lower score indicates a more balanced spread of topic sizes, while higher values suggest a few dominant clusters. Values closer to 0 reflect good balance. |
| Appearance Percentage | The percentage of sentences/documents that were assigned a topic (i.e., not excluded as noise). Higher is better, indicating broader model coverage. |
| Topic 20 Size | The total number of documents belonging to the top 20 topics. This gives a sense of how concentrated the model is in its most prominent clusters. |
| PUV (Pairwise Uniqueness Value) | Indicates the uniqueness of topic assignment across sentence pairs. Values near 1.0 reflect high topic distinctiveness, meaning documents are not frequently assigned the same topic. |
| Ngram Value | A custom score reflecting how often top topic keywords appear in the dataset’s most meaningful bigrams. Higher values suggest better lexical coherence and relevance between topic keywords and the actual corpus. |
| Metric | B&S Model | Mean | Standard Deviation | Min | Max |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Percentage Appearance | 54.73 | 53.44 | 3.81 | 48.56 | 65.38 |
| Keyword_Freq_Score | 0.19 | 0.18 | 0.01 | 0.15 | 0.20 |
| Gini_Score | 0.38 | 0.46 | 0.10 | 0.32 | 0.76 |
| Topic_20_Size | 984 | 793.05 | 251.98 | 117.0 | 1421.0 |