Perceptual Quality Optimization of Image Super-Resolution
Authors: Wei Zhou, Yixiao Li, Hadi Amirpour, Xiaoshuai Hao, Jiang Liu, Peng Wang, Hantao Liu
Organizations: School of Computer Science and Informatics, Cardiff University, UK · Christian Doppler Laboratory ATHENA, Alpen-Adria-Universität, Klagenfurt, Austria · XiaomiEV, China · Centre for Vision, Speech and Signal Processing, University of Surrey, UK
Single-image super-resolution (SR) has achieved remarkable progress with deep learning, yet most approaches rely on distortion-oriented losses or heuristic perceptual priors, which often lead to a trade-off between fidelity and visual quality. To address this issue, we propose an Efficient Perceptual Bi-directional Attention Network (Efficient-PBAN) that explicitly optimizes SR towards human-preferred quality. Unlike patch-based quality models, Efficient-PBAN avoids extensive patch sampling and enables efficient image-level perception. The proposed framework is trained on our self-constructed SR quality dataset that covers a wide range of state-of-the-art SR methods with corresponding human opinion scores. Using this dataset, Efficient-PBAN learns to predict perceptual quality in a way that correlates strongly with subjective judgments. The learned metric is further integrated into SR training as a differentiable perceptual loss, enabling closed-loop alignment between reconstruction and perceptual assessment. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our approach delivers superior perceptual quality. Code is publicly available at https://github.com/Lighting-YXLI/Efficient-PBAN.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: Overall framework of the proposed method. Left: SR optimization pipeline driven by Efficient-PBAN. Right: Efficient-PBAN structure with two-stage training, where the “ice” and “fire” icons denote frozen and trainable parameters, respectively. And the details of PBA + block are described in Section 2.1 . LD and LP refer to the distortion-oriented and perceptual loss, respectively.
Test
SR
Model
PSNR ↑
SSIM ↑
LPIPS ↓
PFIQA ↑
EPBAN ↑
SF ↑
SN ↑
SFSN ↑
[ 12 ]
[ 16 ]
Original
26.3513
0.7188
0.3382
3.8528
2.8682
0.9857
2.1952
1.1067
+SSIM
25.6755
0.7304
0.3358
3.8702
2.9415
0.9764
2.3886
1.1177
+EPBAN
25.6203
0.6963
0.3567
3.8911
3.3165
0.9836
2.4982
1.1351
+SSIM & EPBAN
25.6741
0.7110
0.3560
3.9348
3.4025
0.9843
2.4084
1.1268
[ 1 ]
Original
29.2358
0.8251
0.2928
3.6466
2.9568
0.9907
1.9200
1.0836
+SSIM
28.4237
0.8309
0.2931
3.6586
2.9998
0.9861
2.0532
1.0928
Table 1: Quantitative comparison based on CAMixerSR [ 16 ] and LINF [ 18 ] across B100 [ 12 ] and DIV2K [ 1 ] databases with different optimization counterparts. Results are reported as mean score on each testing database. Best and second-best results for each database and baseline are highlighted in red and blue , respectively. Note that EPBAN refers to the Efficient-PBAN.
Figure 2: Visualizations of the original SR images and the corresponding optimization results, where the regions highlighted by red boxes are enlarged for clearer illustration.
β / α
PSNR ↑
SSIM ↑
LPIPS ↓
PFIQA ↑
Efficient-PBAN ↑
SF ↑
SN ↑
SFSN ↑
1/9
26.1260
0.7195
0.3315
3.8717
2.6703
0.9848
2.1308
1.0994
2/8
26.1273
0.7195
0.3314
3.8716
2.6707
0.9848
2.1302
1.0993
3/7
26.1292
0.7194
0.3314
3.8710
2.6712
0.9848
2.1292
1.0992
4/6
26.1334
0.7192
0.3313
3.8692
2.6725
0.9849
2.1269
1.0991
5/5
25.6741
0.7110
0.3560
3.9348
3.4025
0.9843
2.4084
1.1268
6/4
20.2765
0.3358
0.5914
4.9893
4.3056
0.9699
3.4414
1.2171
Table 2: Ablation study on the weighting ratio between the distortion-oriented loss LD (denoted as α ) and the perceptual loss LP (denoted as β ) for CAMixerSR on the B100 dataset. The best performances are highlighted in bold.
Diffusion prior-based methods have shown impressive results in real-world image super-resolution (ISR), yet two key challenges persist: balancing pixel-level fidelity with semantic quality, and adapting to diverse degradations. Existing dual-branch approaches freeze the pixel module during semantic training, but the semantic branch can still expand capacity within the pixel subspace, precluding genuine perceptual improvement. Moreover, using a single static adapter cannot generalize across heterogeneous real-world corruptions. To address both issues, we propose FreqOrtho-SR, which comprises: Frequency-guided Mixture of LoRA Experts (FreqMoE), it routes inputs to specialized experts via a non-parametric FFT-based degradation-feature extractor that encodes frequency-domain signatures, enabling stable and interpretable specialization across corruption types; and Orthogonal Gradient Projection (OGP), which reframes the dual-objective optimization as a subspace-constrained problem: by extracting the pixel-fidelity subspace via SVD on combined expert weight deltas and projecting semantic gradients onto its null space, OGP guarantees orthogonality between the two objectives, enabling genuinely complementary learning without mutual interference. Experiments show that FreqOrtho-SR achieves competitive overall performance and a strong fidelity-perception trade-off across multiple benchmarks with efficient single-step inference. The source code of our method can be found at sonhm3029/FreqOrtho-SR.
Minh Son Hoang, Dinh Phu Tran, Quyen Nguyen Duc +2
Fidelity and perceptual quality are two inherently competing and conflicting objectives in the image super-resolution (SR) task. Different loss functions focus on these objectives to varying extents. Regression losses enhance the model's fidelity but lack sufficient attention to high-frequency details, resulting in a loss of fine details. In contrast, perception losses improve the model's visual quality but may introduce undesirable artifacts. Balancing these two optimization goals can be viewed as a Multi-Objective Optimization problem. Existing methods are limited to cautiously adjusting weight parameters between these losses, overlooking the underlying Interest Entanglement problem. To address this problem, we explore the inherent frequency-domain conflict between the regression objective and the perceptual objective, and analyze the causes of Interest Entanglement in SR tasks. According to our findings, we propose the Shared-Feature-Representation based Super-Resolution framework (SFR), which decouples the learning process of different optimization objectives, allowing the model to explore a common optimization direction for both goals and achieve an effective balance between them. To better leverage shared features, we also proposed the InfoSqueeze module, which filters redundant information through a dimensionality reduction and expansion process, effectively transforming features into a consistent space. Quantitative and qualitative experiments across five representative datasets affirm the superiority of SFR.
Junxiong Lin, Xinji Mai, Qianyu Guo +5
College of Intelligent Robotics and Advanced Manufacturing, Fudan University · Shanghai Institute of Virology, Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine · The University of Hong Kong +1
The effectiveness of super resolution (SR) models hinges on their ability to recover high frequency structure without introducing artifacts. Diffusion based approaches have recently advanced the state of the art in SR. However, most diffusion based SR pipelines operate purely in the spatial domain, which may yield high frequency details that are not well supported by the underlying low resolution evidence. On the other hand, unlike supervised SR models that may inject dataset specific textures, single image SR relies primarily on internal image statistics and can therefore be less prone to dataset-driven hallucinations; nevertheless, ambiguity in the LR observation can still lead to inconsistent high frequency details. To tackle this problem, we introduce BATDiff, an unsupervised Bivariate A trous Wavelet Diffusion model designed to provide structured cross scale guidance during the generative process. BATDiff employs an a Trous wavelet transform that constructs an undecimated multiscale representation in which high frequency components are progressively revealed while the full spatial resolution is preserved. As the core inference mechanism, BATDiff includes a bivariate cross scale module that models parent child dependencies between adjacent scales. It improves high frequency coherence and reduces mismatch artifacts in diffusion based SR. Experiments on standard benchmarks demonstrate that BATDiff produces sharper and more structurally consistent reconstructions than existing diffusion and non diffusion baselines, achieving improvements in fidelity and perceptual quality.