A 1/R Law for Kurtosis Contrast in Balanced Mixtures
Authors: Yuda Bi, Wenjun Xiao, Linhao Bai, Vince D Calhoun
Organizations: Tri-Institutional Center for Translational Research in Neuroimaging and Data Science (TReNDS), Georgia State University, Georgia Institute of Technology, and Emory University, Atlanta, GA 30303 USA · Department of Computer Science, The George Washington University, Washington, DC 20052 USA · School of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332 USA
Kurtosis-based Independent Component Analysis (ICA) weakens in wide, balanced mixtures. We prove a sharp redundancy law: for a standardized projection with effective width Reff (participation ratio), the population excess kurtosis obeys ∣κ(y)∣=O(κmax/Reff), yielding the order-tight O(cbκmax/R) under balance (typically cb=O(logR)). As an impossibility screen, under standard finite-moment conditions for sample kurtosis estimation, surpassing the O(1/T) estimation scale requires R≲κmaxT. We also show that purification -- selecting m≪R sign-consistent sources -- restores R-independent contrast Ω(1/m), with a simple data-driven heuristic. Synthetic experiments validate the predicted decay, the T crossover, and contrast recovery.
Figures & tables
Fig. 1: Empirical validation (mean ± SEM). (a) FastICA error err(W,A) increases with 1/Δκ ( R2=0.78 ). (b) Balanced Student- t mixtures (df =8 , κ0=1.5 ) show ∣κ^(y)∣∝1/R for R=2,…,50 ( R2=0.986 ); unbalanced power-law weights decay more slowly. Inset at R=50 : std(κ^)∼σ0/T ( σ0≈5.3 ); dotted line: ∣κ0∣/R . (c) At R=50 (df ∈[6,30] ), purification ( m=5 ) increases contrast from ≈0.03 to ≈0.43 (oracle) / ≈0.44 (sample-based), ∼14× .
Fig. 2: Paired kurtosis-gap comparison in COBRE group ICA ( n=155 ) for model orders k=53 and k=100 , with FNC insets. Top: two-level FNC summaries (edge-level S and fingerprint-level F ). Bottom: example connectivity fingerprint ( ∣z∣ ) and one representative subject’s static FNC matrix for component k∗=51 in the k=53 solution (with ∣z∣ clipped at the 98th percentile for visualization). FNC insets are qualitative context only and are not used in the redundancy-law inference.
Linear Independent Component Analysis (ICA) recovers jointly independent source signals from their linear mixtures. To achieve this, classical ICA algorithms attempt to maximize non-Gaussianity, measured by negentropy, which is linked to independence by information theory. Because exact negentropy optimization is intractable, they rely on proxy contrast functions, such as fourth-order cumulants and parametric log-likelihoods. We propose instead to use the squared L2-Wasserstein distance to a standard Gaussian as the ICA contrast. We show that the Wasserstein distance between a standard normal distribution and linear projections of the data is maximized when the projection recovers an independent component, and that under a regularity condition on the sources this maximum is separated from every genuine mixture by an explicit margin. We uncover the advantageous properties of the resulting estimator: for sources with a smooth density it is N-consistent and asymptotically normal with a closed-form variance, whereas for a source with an atom the contrast has a kink at the true direction, which makes the estimator exact with probability tending to one. The proposed OT-ICA algorithm finds this projection by gradient-based optimization. Empirical evaluation on simulated data shows that OT-ICA outperforms proxy-based methods and that the W22 contrast provides more robust signal than proxy contrasts in measuring non-Gaussianity for different distributional mixtures of the latent variables. Application to linear causal disentanglement and EEG artifact removal, along with further applications detailed in the appendix, confirms OT-ICA can be used for applied ICA tasks without distributional assumptions.
Ashutosh Jha, Michel Besserve, Simon Buchholz
Methods Center, University of Tübingen · Max Planck Institute for Intelligent Systems, Tübingen · Institute of Artificial Intelligence, TU Braunschweig
We study the problem of learning disentangled signals from data using non-linear Independent Component Analysis (ICA). Motivated by advances in self-supervised learning, we propose to learn self-sufficient signals: Given the remaining values of a recovered signal, observing other signals should not change the conditional distribution of its missing value. We formulate this problem as the minimization of a conditional KL divergence. Our algorithm is prior-free and likelihood-free in the sense that it prescribes neither parametric source densities nor an observation likelihood. To tackle the KL divergence minimization problem, we propose a sequential algorithm that learns a de-mixing flow model at each iteration, and prove local descent of the total correlation for its idealized Wasserstein-gradient-flow variant with exact velocities and a population projection condition. This approach completely avoids the unstable adversarial training, a common issue in minimizing the KL divergence. Experiments on toy and real-world datasets show the effectiveness of our method.
We present the mathematical foundations of linear independent component analysis (ICA) models based on standard literature in a self-contained note. It is aimed at readers with a background in measure-theoretic probability theory. We first develop the theory of the characteristic functions of probability measures on Rd, including their analyticity and the way in which they determine and characterise the distributions. We then focus on several identifiability results of ICA models with successively strengthened assumptions on the sources: from merely non-constant, to non-Gaussian, to Gaussian-free independent sources. Under the strictest assumptions, we show that the independent sources are identifiable up to translation, permutation, scales and signs, and this even in the presence of additive Gaussian noise. Furthermore, we present the online equivariant gradient descent ICA algorithm for recovering the independent sources from data, in the standard complete noiseless non-Gaussian ICA setting.
Patrick Forré
AI4Science Lab Korteweg-de Vries Institute for Mathematics University of Amsterdam