eess.ASFeb 27, 2026

An Empirical Analysis of Task-Induced Encoder Bias in Fréchet Audio Distance

Authors: Wonwoo Jeong

Organizations: Dept. of Computer Science and Engineering, Sogang University, South Korea

Abstract

Fréchet Audio Distance (FAD) is the de facto standard for evaluating text-to-audio generation, yet its scores depend on the underlying encoder's embedding space. An encoder's training task dictates which acoustic features are preserved or discarded, causing FAD to inherit systematic task-induced biases. We decompose evaluation into Recall, Precision, and Alignment (split into semantic and structural dimensions), using log-scale normalization for fair cross-encoder comparison. Controlled experiments on six encoders across two datasets reveal a four-axis trade-off: reconstruction-based AudioMAE leads precision sensitivity; ASR-trained Whisper dominates structural detection but is blind to signal degradation; classification-trained VGGish maximizes semantic detection but penalizes legitimate intra-class variation. Since no single encoder is a universal evaluator, future metrics must shift toward evaluation-native encoders intrinsically aligned with human perception.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

May 7, 2026eess.AS

Optimal Transport Audio Distance with Learned Riemannian Ground Metrics

In audio generation evaluation, Fréchet Audio Distance (FAD) is a 2-Wasserstein distance with structural constraints for both primitives: the cost is a frozen embedding pullback whose invariance set hides severe artifacts, and the coupling is a Gaussian fit that dilutes rank-1 contamination relative to discrete OT. We propose Optimal Transport Audio Distance (OTAD), which corrects each primitive with one dedicated mechanism -- a residual Riemannian ground-metric adapter for the cost and entropic Sinkhorn optimal transport for the coupling. Across eight encoders under a four-axis protocol, coupling-only comparisons at ε=0.05ε= 0.05 show that Sinkhorn's rank-1 sensitivity exceeds FAD's by a factor of 1.9 to 3.6. Furthermore, OTAD achieves a higher mean Spearman correlation with audio-quality MOS (DCASE 2023 Task 7) than baseline metrics. As an intrinsic benefit of the discrete transport plan, OTAD yields per-sample diagnostics with AUROC ≥0.86\ge 0.86, a capability that scalar- or kernel-aggregated metrics structurally lack.
Jun 4, 2026cs.SD

Probing Spatial Structure in Pretrained Audio Representations

Pretrained spatial audio encoders are increasingly used as general-purpose representations for perceptual tasks, yet their spatial encoding capabilities remain poorly understood. We introduce the Spatial Audio Representation Learning (SARL) benchmark, a controlled framework for evaluating spatial information in pretrained audio models. SARL probes source-level factors (azimuth, elevation, distance, class) and room-level factors (RT60, volume, shape). Experiments across diverse encoders reveal three patterns: input configuration and training paradigm shape spatial encoding; source factors are consistently easier to decode than room factors; and sensitivity analysis under controlled perturbations shows heterogeneous responses to source and room variation. These results reveal systematic biases in current pretrained audio representations. SARL is released as an open-source benchmark for reproducible evaluation of spatial audio representations.
Jul 11, 2026eess.AS

FdAudio: MeanFlow-Anchored Fréchet-Distance Post-Training for One-Step Text-to-Audio Generation

While recent few-step sampling text-to-audio generation models like MeanAudio substantially accelerate generation by modeling average velocities, their strict one-step generation quality still lags significantly behind multi-step counterparts. We propose FdAudio to bridge this gap. Unlike MeanAudio, which relies solely on regression against target velocity fields, our post-training approach optimizes the final one-step distribution directly across pre-trained embedding spaces via a multi-representation Fréchet-distance (FD) loss. Crucially, to prevent the multi-step degradation that naive post-training with FD-loss causes, we introduce a MeanFlow consistency objective as a structural anchor. Results demonstrate that FdAudio establishes state-of-the-art one-step T2A generation quality among few-step systems, yielding an 11.4% reduction in FD score and a 28.8% improvement in FAD score relative to the baseline MeanAudio framework. Notably, we solve FD post-training's naive multi-step degradation issue by proposing the MeanFlow anchor, enabling a 25-step sampling path to maintain high-fidelity audio synthesis that matches or surpasses strong multi-step models at a fraction of their computational latency.