Think, But Don't Overthink: Reproducing Recursive Language Models
Organizations: The Chinese University of Hong Kong
Abstract
This project reproduces and extends the recently proposed Recursive Language Models'' (RLMs) framework by Zhang et al. (2026). This framework enables Large Language Models (LLMs) to process near-infinite contexts by offloading the prompt into an external REPL environment. While the original paper relies on a default recursion depth of 1 and suggests deeper recursion as a future direction, this study specifically investigates the impact of scaling the recursion depth. Using state-of-the-art open-source agentic models (DeepSeek v3.2 and Kimi K2), I evaluated pure LLM, RLM (depth=1), and RLM (depth=2) on the S-NIAH and OOLONG benchmarks. The findings reveal a compelling phenomenon: Deeper recursion causes models to overthink''. While depth-1 RLMs effectively boost accuracy on complex reasoning tasks, applying deeper recursion (depth=2) or using RLMs on simple retrieval tasks paradoxically degrades performance and exponentially inflates execution time (e.g., from 3.6s to 344.5s) and token costs. Code and data are available at: https://github.com/drbillwang/rlm-reproduction
Figures & tables
| Failure Mode 1: Parametric Hallucination (Context Anchoring Loss) |
|---|
| Model: DeepSeek v3.2 Task: S-NIAH (Depth=2) Time: 260.5s |
| Prompt: What are all the special magic numbers for unknown mentioned in the provided text? |
| Raw Output: “The special magic numbers for unknown (atomic nuclei) mentioned in the text are: 2, 8, 20, 28, 50, 82, 126. These numbers represent the nuclear magic numbers where atomic nuclei are particularly stable due to filled nuclear shells.” |
| Insight: The deep recursion caused the model to abandon the input context and hallucinate real-world physics constants based on its pre-trained weights. |
| Failure Mode 2: Formatting Collapse in REPL |
| Model: Kimi K2 Task: OOLONG (Depth=1) Time: 1223.6s |
Recursive Language Models
Recursive Language Models use repeated or decomposed computation to extend language-model reasoning beyond a single pass.
See all 59 papers