Covenant-72B: Pre-Training a 72B LLM with Trustless Peers Over-the-Internet

The growing computational power of modern GPU data centers has let a few industrial giants train and deploy large language models (LLMs) on massive amounts of data. Yet the sheer scale of these models and their training data makes centralized development increasingly hard to sustain, and at the same time shuts out smaller institutions that hold relevant private data but lack comparable infrastructure. In this paper, we organize our positions on distributed LLM training around the pretraining and fine-tuning paradigms, covering federated learning, split learning, and decentralized approaches, and we assess their readiness for geo-distributed settings with heterogeneous hardware and unreliable connectivity. We then present a {\em unified} system architecture built around a cloud-hosted parameter server that coordinates heterogeneous clients over outbound gRPC connections, reusing one communication, compression, and fault-tolerance stack for both pretraining and a family of fine-tuning methods. We validate the design with real geo-distributed experiments on GPT-2 Medium and Llama3-1B pretraining across multiple university sites, showing stable convergence under realistic conditions. Finally, we chart the road ahead, identifying open problems that span frontier model support, elastic fault tolerance, adaptive compression, federated alignment, privacy and trust, incentive design, and system--algorithm co-design, all of which must be addressed to make democratized LLM training a reality.

This work presents SeedFlood, a new approach to decentralized LLM fine-tuning designed to scale across large models, large collaborations, and complex network topologies while achieving global consensus with negligible communication overhead. Traditional methods suffer from high communication costs that grow with model size, while information decay over network hops renders global consensus inefficient. SeedFlood takes a significant departure from these practices by exploiting the seed-reconstructible structure of zeroth-order gradients and effectively making the messages to transmit near-zero in size, allowing them to be flooded to every client in the network, and thereby enhancing scalability of decentralized training. Consequently, SeedFlood enables training in regimes previously considered impractical, such as billion-parameter scale models or distributed across hundred of clients. Our experiments on decentralized LLM fine-tuning demonstrate that SeedFlood consistently outperforms the standard zeroth-order baselines in both communication efficiency and generalization performance, and even achieves results comparable to first-order gossip-based methods in large-scale settings, while requiring orders-of-magnitude less communication cost. We also provide theoretical analysis to formalize that SeedFlood avoids topology-dependent consensus terms in the convergence bound while retaining the acceleration enabled by increased client participation.

Training large language models at the multi-billion to trillion parameter scale is confined to datacenters, where data-parallel (DP) and model-parallel (MP) techniques presume homogeneous accelerators, high-speed interconnects, and a single orchestrating entity. Frontier model development is thereby concentrated among the few groups able to assemble such clusters. Meanwhile, an enormous pool of compute remains unusable for training: consumer and professional GPUs that are heterogeneous, preemptible, individually owned, and connected only by the internet. We present Agora, a system that makes efficient use of this compute. Agora combines bandwidth-efficient pipeline-parallel model sharding over internet-grade links with multi-party, fault-tolerant collective operations. Each participant holds only one stage of the model, and no single party ever possesses the full weights. We term this setup Protocol Learning: it enables collectively trained, collectively owned models, opening a path to open-source frontier training with economic sustainability. This report presents the outcome of a research effort spanning communication-efficient parallelism, asynchronous optimization, and fault-tolerant systems design. It culminates in the first demonstration of its kind: Pluralis-8B, an open, permissionless pretraining run of an 8.6B-parameter model on 500B tokens of FineWeb-Edu. The model was trained over 40 days by 330 contributor nodes, predominantly consumer GPUs on internet connections, joining and leaving throughout. The run sustained ~170k tokens/s and 4.2 tokens per TFLOP of pooled compute, 63% of the efficiency of a centralized H100 baseline, and converged to within a small margin of a centralized reference run.