Analyzing news coverage in multilingual societies can offer valuable insights into the dynamics of public discourse and the development of collective narratives, yet comprehensive studies that account for linguistic and cultural diversity within national media ecosystems remain limited, particularly in complex contexts such as Switzerland. This paper studies temporal trends in Swiss digital media across the country's three main linguistic regions, French, German, and Italian, using a triangulated methodology that combines quantitative analyses with qualitative insights. We collected and processed over 1.7 million news articles, applying lexical metrics, named entity recognition and Wikidata-based linking, targeted sentiment analysis, and consensus-based change-point detection. To enable principled cross-language comparisons and to connect to theories of domestication and cultural proximity, we derive domestication profiles together with a proximity salience ratio. Our analysis spans thematic, recurrent, and singular events. By integrating quantitative data with qualitative interpretation, we provide new insights into the dynamics of Swiss digital media and demonstrate the usefulness of triangulation in media studies. The findings reveal distinct temporal patterns and highlight how linguistic and cultural contexts influence reporting. Our approach offers a framework applicable to other multilingual or culturally diverse media environments, contributing to a deeper understanding of how news is shaped by linguistic and cultural factors.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: Triangulated methodology for temporal analysis of Swiss digital news events. The diagram summarizes the integrated workflow, combining multilingual data collection, automatic event extraction, quantitative analyses, qualitative interpretation, and triangulated findings on temporal and cross-lingual patterns.
Figure 4: Standardized composite lexical index for Brexit (monthly, 3‑month MA).
Figure 5: Standardized composite lexical index for Swiss Wolf (monthly, 3‑month MA).
Figure 6: Weekly domestication profile for Brexit .
Figure 7: LPSR over time for Brexit (weekly averages).
Figure 8: Weekly domestication profile for Swiss Wolf .
Figure 9: LPSR over time for Swiss Wolf (weekly averages).
Figure 10: Monthly frequency of Brexit key named entities in French-language coverage.
Figure 11: Evolution of weekly sentiment scores for Brexit -event entities in French-language coverage.
Figure 12: Monthly frequency of Swiss Wolf key named entities across all languages.
Figure 13: Evolution of weekly sentiment scores for key entities in Swiss Wolf coverage (by language).
Appendix figures & tables19 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
German
French
Italian
20 Minuten
20 minutes
Corriere del Ticino
Aargauer Zeitung
24 heures
Swissinfo
Basler Zeitung
La Gruyère
Ticinolibero
bz Basel
La Tribune de Genève
TicinOnline
ch.ch
RFJ
Der Bund
RJB
Appendix
Table 1: List of selected news sources by language.
Parameter
Values
UMAP Parameters
n_components
[5, 7]
min_dist
[0.05, 0.1]
neighbors
[15, 30, 50]
HDBSCAN Parameters
min_sample_fraction
[0.3, 0.5, 0.75]
Appendix
Table 2: Hyperparameter grid for UMAP and HDBSCAN.
Parameter
German
French
Italian
n_components
7
7
7
min_dist
0.1
0.05
0.1
neighbors
15
30
30
min_sample_fraction
0.3
0.3
0.3
min_cluster_size
100
30
30
cluster_selection_method
eom
eom
eom
Appendix
Table 3: Best hyperparameters found per language.
Figure 14: Brexit: relative-change composite lexical index by language (monthly, three-month rolling mean).
Figure 15: Swiss Wolf: relative-change composite lexical index by language.
Figure 16: Christmas (Nov–Mar): relative-change composite lexical index by language.
Figure 17: British Royal Family: relative-change composite lexical index by language.
Figure 18: Weekly distribution of Christmas -related news articles across all languages, with change points detected (consensus bands). For Christmas, lexical plots display only Nov–Mar when the sample is meaningful.
Figure 19: Evolution of the standardized composite lexical index for Christmas in French, German, and Italian Swiss media (monthly averages, three-month rolling mean).
Figure 20: Weekly domestication profile for Christmas by language.
Figure 21: LPSR over time for Christmas by language (weekly averages).
Figure 22: Monthly frequency of named entities related to Christmas across French, German, and Italian Swiss media.
Figure 23: Evolution of monthly sentiment scores for key entities in Christmas coverage (by language).
Figure 24: Weekly distribution of British Royal Family -related news articles across French and German, with change points detected (consensus bands).
Figure 25: Evolution of the standardized composite lexical index for British Royal Family in French and German Swiss media (monthly averages, three-month rolling mean).
Figure 26: Weekly domestication profile for British Royal Family by language.
Figure 27: LPSR over time for British Royal Family by language (weekly averages).
Figure 28: Monthly frequency of named entities in French and German coverage of the British Royal Family . The star marks the first mention of “Charles III” in the corpus.
Figure 29: Evolution of monthly sentiment scores for key entities in British Royal Family coverage (by language).
Today most media content is consumed based on algorithmic recommendations. Evidence suggests that this can lead to politically biased media consumption patterns. Automated extraction of political agendas from texts can reveal and analyze political biases in online media -- and thus help fostering politically unbiased media consumption. Here we employ modern political text analysis methods demonstrating the potential of automated fine-grained political bias analysis in online media. We conduct an analysis of political content in German language online media during the period 2019--2022, encompassing several million articles and tweets covering events with profound societal impact globally and nationally, the COVID-19 pandemic and the beginning of the war in Ukraine. Our analysis identifies thematic similarity between national (German and Swiss) reporting, particularly for categories driven by international events. We also find divergences emerging in domestically influenced categories, reflecting differences in national policies and institutional structures. A comparison of newspaper and Twitter discourse reveals that both media converge around a shared core during the pandemic, yet differ in intensity and temporal dynamics. Newspapers exhibit more stable political content, while Twitter reacts through short-lived event-driven spikes. These findings indicate that international crises act as a powerful synchronizing force on political content in classical media, temporarily overriding both national and media-form differences. Our automated political analysis empowers citizens by rendering political agendas in online media transparent. This transparency also enables media outlets to bridge the gap between algorithm-driven echo chambers and a more informed, balanced public discourse.
Yara Döring, Felix Bießmann
Berliner Hochschule für Technik · Einstein Center Digital Future, Berlin
Policymakers enact and revise privacy laws expecting meaningful benefits for their people in practice. While scholarship has measured the real-world impact of some privacy regulations-the EU and California most notably-limited empirical evidence exists for many of the more than 140 countries that have implemented some form of privacy legislation. Switzerland, a multilingual country bordered almost entirely by EU states, is one such example. This paper analyzes the extent to which a 2023 alignment of Swiss privacy law with EU privacy regulation affected website privacy policies in Switzerland. To address Switzerland's unique multilingual culture, we develop an LLM-based pipeline that extracts legally relevant information as document-level labels in a single inference without requiring translation. On a benchmark of 120 expert-annotated privacy policies in German, French, Italian, and English, our pipeline achieves F1 scores above 0.90 for most pairs of languages and legally relevant disclosures. Applying this pipeline to privacy policies we collected from more than 35,000 Swiss- and EU-facing websites before and after the 2023 privacy law revision, we find significant increases in both mandatory and voluntary disclosures of data subject rights among Swiss privacy policies. In exploring the mechanisms driving increased disclosure rates, we discover heavy use of automated privacy policy generators and find that generated policies are associated with up to 15 percentage points higher disclosure rates. These results provide large-scale empirical evidence of how regulatory change and novel drafting technologies impact the content of privacy policies in a unique multilingual environment.
Luka Nenadic, David Rodriguez, Joseph A. Calandrino
ETH Zurich Zurich, Switzerland · Information Processing and Telecommunications Center Universidad Politécnica de Madrid ETSI Telecomunicación, Spain · Carnegie Mellon University Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA
We present Swiss4Arg, a multilingual dataset for argument mining based on official Swiss voting brochures, covering all four national languages: German, French, Italian, and Romansh (a Romance minority language exclusively spoken in Switzerland). The brochures contain explicitly formulated arguments systematically organized into pro and con sections, resulting in a cross-lingually aligned resource with balanced argumentative stance. We create a dataset that comprises 53 federal voting issues collected between 2019 and 2025, annotated for argument components (major claims, claims, premises, and non-argumentative units) and relations (support and attack) by three native speakers per language. Inter-annotator agreement (Krippendorff's alpha) reaches 0.548 for component classification and 0.623 for relation and target classification, computed jointly across all annotators on the parallel data. We release both adjudicated labels and individual annotator annotations, enabling analyses of disagreement and cross-linguistic variation, and provide baseline results using GPT-5.4 and SwissBERT. Swiss4Arg establishes a novel benchmark for multilingual argument mining, with a particular focus on cross-lingual comparability and low-resource settings such as Romansh. The dataset and code are publicly available at https://anonymous-hf.up.railway.app/a/gozw0nion72y/ (HuggingFace) and https://anonymous.4open.science/r/MultiVote-03BD/ (GitHub).
Sophia Conrad, Fatma-Zohra Rezkellah, Christina Niklaus +1
Department of Computational Linguistics, University of Zurich · University of St. Gallen