cs.HCApr 12, 2026

Speaking to No One: Ontological Dissonance and the Double Bind of Conversational AI

Authors: Hugh Brosnahan, Izabela Lipinska

Organizations: Bioethics Centre, University of Otago · Independent Researcher

Abstract

Recent reports indicate that sustained interaction with conversational artificial intelligence (AI) systems can, in a small subset of users, contribute to the emergence or stabilisation of delusional experience. Existing accounts typically attribute such cases either to individual vulnerability or to failures of safety engineering. These explanations are incomplete. Drawing on phenomenology, psychiatry, and cognitive neuroscience, this paper argues that the risk arises from the relational and ontological structure of the interaction itself. Conversational AI generates ontological dissonance: a conflict between the appearance of relational presence and the absence of any subject capable of sustaining it. Maintained through a communicative double bind and amplified by attentional asymmetries, this dissonance tends, under conditions of affective vulnerability, to stabilise into a technologically mediated analogue of folie a deux. This account explains why explicit disclaimers often fail to disrupt delusional involvement and clarifies the ethical and clinical implications for the design and use of conversational AI.

Explore similar work

CardsList
  1. AI Psychosis: Does Conversational AI Amplify Delusion-Related Language?

    Mar 20, 2026Soorya Ram Shimgekar, Vipin Gunda, Jiwon Kim +3Mental Health Conversational AgentsAI Safety

  2. Sycophantic Chatbots Cause Delusional Spiraling, Even in Ideal Bayesians

    Feb 22, 2026Kartik Chandra, Max Kleiman-Weiner, Jonathan Ragan-Kelley +1Human-AI InteractionLLM Sycophancy

  3. Lost in Delusion: Examining LLM Safety Under User Delusions and Distress

    May 31, 2026Andrew Aquilina, Chetna Nihalani, Vasudha Varadarajan +3Mental HealthLLM Safety Alignment