cs.LGApr 28, 2026

RCProb: Probabilistic rule extraction from classification tree ensembles

Authors: Josue Obregon

Organizations: Department of Industrial Engineering Seoul National University of Science and Technology

Abstract

Tree ensembles provide strong classification performance but usually behave as black-box models. Post-hoc interpretability techniques such as RuleCOSI+ extract a small ruleset that approximates the ensemble, but this simplification can leave the probabilities attached to the extracted rules unreliable. In particular, RuleCOSI+ assigns empirical class probabilities to the extracted rules and repeatedly uses those rule statistics during its greedy combination and simplification procedure. We present RCProb, a probabilistic extension that uses smoothed atomic class-conditional evidence for the expensive search stages and a support-adaptive mixture with an ensemble-informed m-estimate for the final rule probabilities. The method is evaluated on 18 binary and 5 multiclass datasets using random forest (RF) and gradient boosting machine (GBM) ensembles. Relative to RuleCOSI+, the median paired log-loss reduction is 71.9% for RF and 62.5% for GBM, with both differences remaining significant after Holm correction. The number of rules decreases by 38.7% for RF and 38.5% for GBM, while the primary tests do not detect a macro-F1 difference. Confidence-ECE also decreases for both ensembles, with statistical support for RF after correction. A separate controlled experiment with dedicated calibration data shows that native RCProb probabilities are competitive with RuleCOSI+ followed by temperature scaling, although additional post-hoc calibration can still improve RCProb. The results show that probability estimation is an important part of rule extraction and not only a post-processing step.

Explore similar work

CardsList
Oct 22, 2025cs.AI

RLIE: Rule Generation with Logistic Regression, Iterative Refinement, and Evaluation for Large Language Models

Large Language Models (LLMs) can propose rules in natural language, sidestepping the need for a predefined predicate space in traditional rule learning. Yet many LLM-based approaches ignore interactions among rules, and the opportunity to couple LLMs with probabilistic rule learning for robust inference remains underexplored. We present RLIE, a unified framework that integrates LLMs with probabilistic modeling to learn a set of weighted rules. RLIE has four stages: (1) Rule generation, where an LLM proposes and filters candidates; (2) Logistic regression, which learns probabilistic weights for global selection and calibration; (3) Iterative refinement, which updates the rule set using prediction errors; and (4) Evaluation, which compares the weighted rule set as a direct classifier with methods that inject rules into an LLM. We evaluate multiple inference strategies on real-world datasets. Applying rules directly with their learned weights yields superior performance, whereas prompting LLMs with the rules, weights, and logistic-model outputs surprisingly degrades accuracy. This supports the view that LLMs excel at semantic generation and interpretation but are less reliable for precise probabilistic integration. RLIE clarifies the potential and limitations of LLMs for inductive reasoning and couples them with classic probabilistic rule combination methods to enable more reliable neuro-symbolic reasoning.
Yang Yang, Hua XU, Zhangyi Hu +1
Inductive Logic ProgrammingLLM Reasoning MethodsProbabilistic Inference
AskPDF
Mar 8, 2026cs.LG

TT-Sparse: Learning Sparse Rule Models with Differentiable Truth Tables

Interpretable machine learning is essential in high-stakes domains where decision-making requires accountability, transparency, and trust. While rule-based models offer global and exact interpretability, learning rule sets that simultaneously achieve high predictive performance and low, human-understandable complexity remains challenging. To address this, we introduce TT-Sparse, a flexible neural building block that leverages differentiable truth tables as nodes to learn sparse, effective connections. A key contribution of our approach is a new soft TopK operator with straight-through estimation for learning discrete, cardinality-constrained feature selection in an end-to-end differentiable manner. Crucially, the forward pass remains sparse, enabling efficient computation and exact symbolic rule extraction. As a result, each node (and the entire model) can be transformed exactly into compact, globally interpretable DNF/CNF Boolean formulas via Quine-McCluskey minimization. Extensive empirical results across 28 datasets spanning binary, multiclass, and regression tasks show that the learned sparse rules exhibit superior predictive performance with lower complexity compared to existing state-of-the-art methods.
Hans Farrell Soegeng, Sarthak Ketanbhai Modi, Thomas Peyrin
SparsityDecision TreesSparse SupervisionInductive Logic ProgrammingSingular Learning Theory
AskPDF
Jul 31, 2022cs.LG

Rule Extraction in Machine Learning: Chat Incremental Pattern Constructor

Rule extraction is a central problem in interpretable machine learning because it seeks to convert opaque predictive behavior into human-readable symbolic structure. This paper presents Chat Incremental Pattern Constructor (ChatIPC), a lightweight incremental symbolic learning system that extracts ordered token-transition rules from text, enriches them with definition-based expansion, and constructs responses by similarity-guided candidate selection. The system may be viewed as a rule extractor operating over a token graph rather than a conventional classifier. I formalize the knowledge base, definition expansion, candidate scoring, repetition control, English-rule heuristics, and response construction mechanisms used by ChatIPC. I further situate the method within the literature on rule extraction, decision tree induction, association rules, interpretable machine learning, and sequence construction. The updated C++ code implementation of ChatIPC is also reviewed in detail: it parses an embedded dictionary, normalizes lexical keys, caches definition tokens and part-of-speech tags, computes Jaccard scores on bitsets, applies heuristic linguistic bonuses, and persists the knowledge base with a versioned binary format. The paper emphasizes mathematical formulation and algorithmic clarity, and it provides pseudocode for the learning, scoring, and construction algorithms.
Caleb Princewill Nwokocha
Interpretable Machine LearningMachine Learning
AskPDF