eess.SPMay 7, 2026

The frame-level leakage trap: rethinking evaluation protocols for intrinsic image decomposition, with source-separable uncertainty as a case study

Authors: Jihwan Woo

Organizations: Amazon Web Services (AWS), Partner Field APJ, Sr. Specialist Solutions Architect, AI/ML

Abstract

Evaluation protocols for learned intrinsic image decomposition on MPI Sintel have been inconsistent. Several prior works split the dataset by frames, which allows spatially similar frames of the same scene to appear in both train and test partitions. We quantify this leakage effect for the first time, across three architectures: a frame-level split inflates test R_PSNR by 1.6 to 2.0 dB (p less than 0.01 for all three, paired t-test across 3 seeds) relative to a scene-level split, confirming an architecture-independent protocol effect. A three-point gradient (random/temporal/scene) shows the gap is continuous, and under extended training the frame-level inflation exceeds 10 dB. We advocate scene-level splits as the community standard and provide reference numbers for six representative models under this protocol. As a case study within the corrected protocol, we present a physics-informed decomposition I = R composed with S + N with a source-separable three-way heteroscedastic uncertainty head. We empirically verify channel specialization: the non-Lambertian uncertainty channel shows r = 0.67 cross-correlation with non-Lambertian residual error, more than 4 times the texture channel's correlation. We further demonstrate downstream utility: filtering out the 75% highest-uncertainty pixels reduces reconstruction MSE by 77% on retained pixels, whereas random filtering produces no improvement. The specialization also holds on out-of-distribution real photographs. We report negative results for a more elaborate variant combining frequency decomposition, cross-task supervision, evidential learning, contrastive loss, and test-time adaptation. Our method reaches 15.98 plus or minus 0.41 dB R_PSNR, within 0.8 dB of a 5-member Deep Ensemble at one-fifth the cost, with the unique capability of source-separated uncertainty.

Explore similar work

CardsList
Dec 29, 2025cs.CV

MVID: Feed-Forward Multi-View Intrinsic Image Decomposition

Intrinsic image decomposition aims to recover material and illumination factors from RGB observations, but real-world images entangle reflectance with illumination, visibility, shadows, and non-diffuse appearance. Recent single-image methods address this entanglement with a residual image formation model, decomposing RGB into albedo, diffuse shading, and a non-diffuse residual. However, applying such decomposition independently to consecutive frames lacks scene-level context, leading to inconsistent factor assignments, albedo drift, and leakage across views. Meanwhile, multi-view inverse-rendering methods recover properties, such as material, lighting, and geometry, but they rely on synthetic data due to the highly uncertain estimation, and do not generalize to supervision by real images. We present MVID, Multi-View Intrinsic image Decomposition, a feed-forward framework built on the residual image formation model. MVID builds a scene-level multi-view representation and decodes a view-consistent albedo together with coherent per-view shading and residual factors through a factor query adapter, while using the same image formation model for self-supervised RGB reconstruction on unlabeled real-world sequences. Experiments on indoor, real-world, and outdoor benchmarks show that MVID improves both per-frame decomposition quality and cross-view consistency over single-view intrinsic, generative intrinsic, and multi-view inverse-rendering baselines. The resulting view-stable factors support practical image-space applications, including multi-view consistent illumination editing and specularity removal.
Kang Du, Duotun Wang, Wanling Li +2
Multi-ViewInverse RenderingVisible Image FusionReflectanceLong Video UnderstandingImage Editing
AskPDF
Sep 1, 2026cs.CV

Ten Architectures, One Error: Shared Failure Modes in Hyperspectral Classification under Spatially Disjoint Evaluation

Hyperspectral image classification still relies heavily on random pixel splits within a single scene. The Salinas dataset, randomly split, is among the most widely used datasets for comparing different architectures. However, under a random split method, a large fraction of test pixels fall immediately adjacent to a training pixel, which inflates reported accuracy. This work introduces a leakage-free evaluation protocol linking spatial separation to the model's receptive field. Applying this protocol across ten different architectures, including classical, spectral, spectral-spatial, transformer, vision-backbone, and state-space families, shows that Macro-F1 drops by 0.147 on average and model rankings change by as many as five places. Furthermore, leakage-free evaluation limits which architectures can be tested on a given benchmark. Since each partition supports patches only within a finite radius, reporting this radius alongside the receptive field is essential for fair comparison. In addition, this study reveals that all ten architectures misclassify largely the same pixels, pointing to a spectral ambiguity in the data that none of them resolves.
Ehsan Faghih, Fatemeh Ashrafi, Marguerite Moore +1
Hyperspectral Image ClassificationImage ClassificationReceptive FieldsNeural ArchitecturesLeakagePixels+2
AskPDF
Jul 13, 2026cs.CV

Backbone-Agnostic Stochastic Perturbation Learning for End-to-End Real-World Image Dehazing

Real-world paired image dehazing remains challenging because haze degradation is spatially non-uniform, illumination-dependent, and physically ambiguous even when haze-free references are available. Existing end-to-end restoration networks usually learn a deterministic mapping from a hazy observation to a clean target, while degradation-sensitive feature responses, reverse haze-formation consistency, and cross-domain negative structure remain insufficiently exploited. In this paper, we propose Backbone-Agnostic Stochastic Perturbation Learning (BSPL), a plug-and-play framework for end-to-end real-world image dehazing. BSPL first introduces a Learnable Stochastic Perturbation Modulator (LSPM), which learns input-conditioned channel-wise and spatial-wise perturbation distributions and converts the resulting feature-response discrepancies into adaptive modulation weights. It then develops a Prior-informed Perturbation-guided Reconstruction Module (PPRM), which reuses the learned bottleneck perturbations together with transmission and atmospheric-light priors to reconstruct the hazy observation from the restored result and enforce degradation consistency. Furthermore, we propose a Dual-space Domain-diversified Distribution-aware Contrastive Loss (D3D^3CL) to regularize both clean restoration and hazy reconstruction spaces with real-world and synthetic negatives. Experiments on five real-world paired benchmarks show that BSPL consistently improves multiple representative backbones with only marginal additional inference overhead.
Bingcai Wei
Single Image DehazingMotion PriorsReal-World
AskPDF